Online Self Test
Learn & Practice Quizzes & Challenges Competitive Exams
 

What is Wrong with Indian Films – CBSE NCERT Study Resources

Previous ChapterNext Chapter
Previous Chapter Next Chapter

Study Materials

10th

10th - English (Panorama - Prose)

What is Wrong with Indian Films

Jump to Question Sets

Overview of the Chapter

The chapter "What is Wrong with Indian Films" from the CBSE Grade 10 English textbook (Panorama - Prose) critically examines the flaws and shortcomings of Indian cinema. The author highlights various issues such as lack of originality, overuse of melodrama, and the influence of commercial interests on artistic quality. The chapter encourages students to think critically about the cultural and artistic aspects of Indian films.

Key Theme: The chapter explores the artistic and cultural deficiencies in Indian films, emphasizing the need for more meaningful and original storytelling.

Main Issues Discussed in the Chapter

  • Lack of Originality: Many Indian films rely on repetitive plots and borrowed ideas from foreign cinema.
  • Excessive Melodrama: Overemphasis on emotional exaggeration often overshadows realistic storytelling.
  • Commercialization Over Art: Profit-driven motives frequently compromise the artistic integrity of films.
  • Stereotypical Characters: Characters often lack depth and are based on clichéd representations.
  • Poor Technical Quality: Weak cinematography, editing, and sound design are common criticisms.

Author's Perspective

The author argues that Indian cinema has immense potential but is often held back by these recurring issues. The chapter calls for a shift towards more authentic and innovative filmmaking that reflects India's diverse culture and social realities.

Critical Thinking Question: How can Indian filmmakers balance commercial success with artistic excellence?

Conclusion

The chapter serves as a critique of Indian films while also inspiring students to appreciate and demand higher standards in cinema. It encourages readers to engage with films more thoughtfully and recognize the importance of creativity and originality in storytelling.

All Question Types with Solutions – CBSE Exam Pattern

Explore a complete set of CBSE-style questions with detailed solutions, categorized by marks and question types. Ideal for exam preparation, revision and practice.

Very Short Answer (1 Mark) – with Solutions (CBSE Pattern)

These are 1-mark questions requiring direct, concise answers. Ideal for quick recall and concept clarity.

Question 1:
What is the main criticism of Indian films according to the lesson?
Answer:

Lack of originality and excessive melodrama.

Question 2:
Name one reason why Indian films often fail to impress critics.
Answer:

Overuse of song-and-dance sequences.

Question 3:
What does the lesson say about stereotyping in Indian films?
Answer:

It is repetitive and lacks depth.

Question 4:
How does the lesson describe the dialogue delivery in Indian films?
Answer:

Often exaggerated and unnatural.

Question 5:
What is the issue with plots in Indian films as per the lesson?
Answer:

Predictable and formulaic.

Question 6:
Why do Indian films struggle with realism?
Answer:

Focus on entertainment over authenticity.

Question 7:
What is the lesson's view on item songs in Indian films?
Answer:

Unnecessary and objectifying.

Question 8:
How does the lesson criticize character development in Indian films?
Answer:

Shallow and one-dimensional.

Question 9:
What is the problem with comedy in Indian films according to the lesson?
Answer:

Relies on slapstick and vulgarity.

Question 10:
What does the lesson say about remakes in Indian cinema?
Answer:

Lack creativity and originality.

Question 11:
How does the lesson describe villains in Indian films?
Answer:

Over-the-top and clichéd.

Question 12:
What is the issue with length of Indian films?
Answer:

Too long and dragged.

Question 13:
Why does the lesson criticize foreign influence in Indian films?
Answer:

Copies Western style blindly.

Question 14:
What is the lesson's view on social messages in Indian films?
Answer:

Superficial and preachy.

Question 15:
What is the main criticism of Indian films according to the chapter?
Answer:

The main criticism is that Indian films often prioritize commercial success over artistic quality, leading to repetitive storylines and lack of originality.

Question 16:
Name one common stereotype found in Indian films.
Answer:

One common stereotype is the portrayal of women as either damsels in distress or over-glamorized characters, lacking depth.

Question 17:
How do Indian films often misuse music?
Answer:

Indian films often use music as a filler rather than integrating it meaningfully into the storyline, making it disruptive to the narrative flow.

Question 18:
What is the impact of excessive melodrama in Indian films?
Answer:

Excessive melodrama makes the films unrealistic and reduces their emotional impact, often leading to audience disengagement.

Question 19:
Why do Indian films lack strong character development?
Answer:

They focus more on star power and mass appeal, neglecting the need for well-rounded characters with depth and growth.

Question 20:
What role does commercialization play in Indian films?
Answer:

Commercialization leads to formulaic storytelling, where films are made to cater to box office trends rather than creative expression.

Question 21:
How do Indian films often misrepresent social issues?
Answer:

They either oversimplify or dramatize social issues, failing to provide a nuanced or accurate portrayal.

Question 22:
What is the drawback of relying on star power in films?
Answer:

Relying on star power often overshadows script quality and direction, resulting in films that lack substance.

Question 23:
Why are Indian films criticized for their lack of originality?
Answer:

They frequently remake or copy plots from other films, both domestic and international, without adding innovative elements.

Question 24:
How does the chapter describe the portrayal of villains in Indian films?
Answer:

Villains are often depicted as one-dimensional and over-the-top, lacking complex motivations or depth.

Question 25:
What is the effect of excessive song-and-dance sequences in Indian films?
Answer:

They disrupt the narrative pace and often serve no purpose other than entertainment, weakening the storyline.

Question 26:
How can Indian films improve their storytelling?
Answer:

By focusing on strong scripts, character development, and authentic representation of social issues, rather than relying on stereotypes.

Question 27:
What is the main criticism of Indian films as discussed in the chapter?
Answer:

The main criticism is that Indian films often prioritize commercial success over meaningful content, leading to repetitive storylines and lack of originality.

Question 28:
Name one reason why Indian films are often considered unrealistic.
Answer:

Indian films are considered unrealistic due to excessive use of melodrama and over-the-top action sequences that defy logic.

Question 29:
How does the chapter describe the portrayal of women in Indian films?
Answer:

The chapter states that women are often portrayed in stereotypical roles, such as damsels in distress or glamorous sidekicks, lacking depth.

Question 30:
What is the impact of song-and-dance sequences on Indian films?
Answer:

While they add entertainment value, these sequences often disrupt the narrative flow and make the storyline less coherent.

Very Short Answer (2 Marks) – with Solutions (CBSE Pattern)

These 2-mark questions test key concepts in a brief format. Answers are expected to be accurate and slightly descriptive.

Question 1:
What is the primary criticism of Indian films as discussed in the chapter?
Answer:

The primary criticism is the excessive focus on commercial entertainment rather than meaningful content. Indian films often prioritize song-and-dance sequences and melodrama over realistic storytelling and social messages.

Question 2:
How do Indian films often stereotype characters?
Answer:

Indian films stereotype characters by portraying:

  • Heroes as flawless and villains as one-dimensional.
  • Women in limited roles like damsels in distress or glamorous props.
  • Certain communities or professions in exaggerated, unrealistic ways.

Question 3:
Why is the lack of originality a problem in Indian cinema?
Answer:

The lack of originality leads to:
1. Repetitive plots and clichéd storytelling.
2. Over-reliance on remakes and inspirations from foreign films.
3. Stifling creativity and innovation in the industry.

Question 4:
What role does censorship play in limiting Indian films?
Answer:

Censors often restrict bold or progressive themes, forcing filmmakers to:
1. Avoid controversial topics.
2. Dilute realistic portrayals of society.
3. Conform to outdated moral standards.

Question 5:
How do song sequences affect the narrative of Indian films?
Answer:

Song sequences:

  • Disrupt the flow of the story.
  • Are often inserted for commercial appeal rather than relevance.
  • Reduce screen time for meaningful character development.

Question 6:
Why do Indian films often fail to address social issues effectively?
Answer:

They fail because:

  • Issues are oversimplified for dramatic effect.
  • Solutions are shown as quick fixes rather than realistic struggles.
  • Filmmakers prioritize box-office success over meaningful impact.

Question 7:
How does the star system influence Indian cinema negatively?
Answer:

The star system:
1. Prioritizes star power over talent or script quality.
2. Increases production costs, limiting opportunities for new actors.
3. Encourages repetitive roles, stifling creativity.

Question 8:
What is the consequence of poor scriptwriting in Indian films?
Answer:

Poor scriptwriting results in:

  • Predictable and illogical plots.
  • Weak character arcs and unresolved storylines.
  • Audience disengagement and criticism.

Question 9:
How does regional cinema differ from mainstream Indian films in quality?
Answer:

Regional cinema often:
1. Focuses on authentic storytelling and local culture.
2. Takes creative risks with minimal star dependence.
3. Addresses niche or ignored social issues effectively.

Question 10:
What steps can filmmakers take to improve Indian cinema?
Answer:

Steps include:

  • Investing in original scripts and diverse genres.
  • Reducing reliance on stereotypes and formulaic plots.
  • Balancing entertainment with meaningful content.

Short Answer (3 Marks) – with Solutions (CBSE Pattern)

These 3-mark questions require brief explanations and help assess understanding and application of concepts.

Question 1:
According to the chapter, what is the primary reason for the lack of originality in Indian films?
Answer:

The primary reason for the lack of originality in Indian films is the excessive reliance on formulaic storytelling and remakes. Many filmmakers prefer to copy successful Western or regional films instead of creating unique narratives. This leads to repetitive plots and characters, reducing creativity.

Additionally, commercial pressures and the fear of box-office failure discourage experimentation. Producers often favor safe, mass-appealing content over innovative ideas.

Question 2:
What role does commercialization play in the quality of Indian films, as per the chapter?
Answer:

Commercialization heavily influences the quality of Indian films by prioritizing profit over artistry. Filmmakers often include unnecessary song sequences, over-the-top action, and star power to attract audiences, sacrificing meaningful storytelling.

This focus on box-office success leads to a lack of risk-taking and originality, resulting in films that cater to the lowest common denominator rather than offering thought-provoking content.

Question 3:
Why does the chapter argue that Indian films lack realistic dialogue?
Answer:

The chapter argues that Indian films lack realistic dialogue because writers often rely on melodramatic and exaggerated language to create emotional impact. Dialogues are written to please the masses rather than reflect authentic conversations.

Additionally, the influence of regional stereotypes and cliched expressions further distances the dialogue from realism. This makes characters seem less relatable and the narratives less believable.

Question 4:
How does the chapter suggest Indian films can improve their storytelling?
Answer:

The chapter suggests that Indian films can improve storytelling by focusing on original scripts and character development. Writers should draw inspiration from real-life issues and diverse cultures to create fresh narratives.

Filmmakers should also reduce reliance on formulaic tropes and invest in meaningful dialogues and subtle performances. Encouraging independent cinema and supporting new talent can also bring innovation to the industry.

Question 5:
What criticism does the chapter have about the use of music in Indian films?
Answer:

The chapter criticizes the use of music in Indian films for being excessive and irrelevant to the plot. Songs are often inserted purely for entertainment value, disrupting the flow of the story.

While music is a cultural strength, its overuse as a commercial tool rather than a narrative device weakens the film's impact. The chapter suggests integrating songs more organically to enhance the storytelling.

Question 6:
According to the chapter, what is the primary issue with the portrayal of women in Indian films?
Answer:

The primary issue with the portrayal of women in Indian films is their stereotypical representation. Women are often shown in limited roles, such as the dutiful wife, sacrificing mother, or glamorous love interest, which reinforces outdated gender norms. This lack of diverse and strong female characters fails to reflect the real-life contributions and complexities of women in society.

Question 7:
How does the chapter describe the influence of commercialism on Indian films?
Answer:

The chapter highlights that commercialism has led to a focus on box office success rather than artistic quality. Films often include unnecessary song-and-dance sequences, over-the-top action, and melodrama to attract audiences, sacrificing meaningful storytelling. This trend prioritizes profit over creativity, resulting in repetitive and shallow content.

Question 8:
What criticism does the chapter raise about the depiction of social issues in Indian films?
Answer:

The chapter criticizes the superficial treatment of social issues in Indian films. Instead of addressing problems like poverty, caste discrimination, or corruption with depth, filmmakers often oversimplify or glamorize them for dramatic effect. This approach fails to educate or inspire meaningful change among viewers.

Question 9:
Explain the chapter's view on the lack of originality in Indian films.
Answer:

The chapter points out that many Indian films rely on remakes, copying from other industries, or recycling old plots, showing a lack of original storytelling. This trend stifles creativity and prevents the exploration of unique narratives. The chapter emphasizes the need for fresh ideas and innovative filmmaking techniques to break this cycle.

Question 10:
How does the chapter suggest Indian films can improve their global appeal?
Answer:

The chapter suggests that Indian films can improve their global appeal by focusing on universal themes and high production values. Reducing reliance on cultural clichés and embracing authentic storytelling can make films more relatable to international audiences. Additionally, investing in technical excellence and diverse genres can enhance their competitiveness worldwide.

Question 11:
What role does the chapter attribute to filmmakers in shaping societal values through cinema?
Answer:

The chapter states that filmmakers have a significant responsibility in shaping societal values through cinema. By portraying progressive ideas, inclusive characters, and realistic scenarios, they can influence public opinion and promote positive change. The chapter urges filmmakers to use their platform to address pressing issues and inspire audiences thoughtfully.

Long Answer (5 Marks) – with Solutions (CBSE Pattern)

These 5-mark questions are descriptive and require detailed, structured answers with proper explanation and examples.

Question 1:
Discuss how stereotypical characters and predictable plots weaken Indian films. Support your answer with examples.
Answer:
Introduction

Indian films often rely on stereotypical characters and predictable plots, reducing creativity. Our textbook shows this limits audience engagement.


Argument 1
  • Heroes are always flawless, villains overly dramatic.
  • Example: In many masala films, the hero defeats 20 goons alone.

Argument 2
  • Love stories follow the same boy-meets-girl pattern.
  • Example: Kuch Kuch Hota Hai repeats clichés like love triangles.

Conclusion

Such repetition makes films monotonous. Breaking stereotypes, like Dangal, can bring freshness.

Question 2:
Explain how excessive song sequences disrupt the narrative flow in Indian films. Provide NCERT-relevant examples.
Answer:
Introduction

Excessive song sequences often break the story’s flow. Our textbook mentions this as a common flaw.


Argument 1
  • Songs inserted without relevance to the plot.
  • Example: Dilwale Dulhania Le Jayenge has unnecessary foreign location songs.

Argument 2
  • Disrupts emotional buildup in serious scenes.
  • Example: A tragic moment in Kabhi Khushi Kabhie Gham is followed by a dance.

Conclusion

Films like A Wednesday prove minimal songs enhance storytelling.

Question 3:
Analyze the impact of over-the-top action sequences on the realism of Indian films. Use examples from NCERT discussions.
Answer:
Introduction

Over-the-top action makes Indian films unrealistic. We studied how this reduces relatability.


Argument 1
  • Physics-defying stunts break immersion.
  • Example: In Rowdy Rathore, the hero single-handedly fights 100 men.

Argument 2
  • Reduces emotional depth of conflicts.
  • Example: Baahubali’s exaggerated war scenes overshadow its story.

Conclusion

Films like Shahid show realistic action can be impactful.

Question 4:
How does lack of originality in scripts affect the quality of Indian cinema? Cite NCERT examples.
Answer:
Introduction

Lack of originality leads to repetitive stories. Our textbook highlights this as a major issue.


Argument 1
  • Remakes and copied plots dominate.
  • Example: Judwaa 2 reused the same twin concept as the original.

Argument 2
  • Few films explore unique social themes.
  • Example: Taare Zameen Par stood out for its fresh take on dyslexia.

Conclusion

Original scripts, like Paan Singh Tomar, elevate Indian cinema.

Question 5:
Evaluate the role of commercial pressures in compromising artistic integrity in Indian films. Reference NCERT content.
Answer:
Introduction

Commercial pressures force filmmakers to prioritize profits over art. We studied this trade-off.


Argument 1
  • Star power overshadows script quality.
  • Example: Big stars like Salman Khan get roles despite weak scripts.

Argument 2
  • Formulaic templates ensure box-office success.
  • Example: Most Rohit Shetty films rely on comedy-action mix.

Conclusion

Films like Masaan prove artistic risks can pay off.

Question 6:
Why do poor female character portrayals weaken Indian films? Support with NCERT-relevant instances.
Answer:
Introduction

Poor female portrayals reduce the depth of Indian films. Our textbook criticizes this trend.


Argument 1
  • Women are often sidelined as love interests.
  • Example: In Simmba, the heroine has no significant role.

Argument 2
  • Lack of agency in decision-making.
  • Example: Kabir Singh’s female lead silently tolerates abuse.

Conclusion

Strong roles like in Queen show the potential for change.

Question 7:
Discuss the lack of originality in Indian films. How does this affect their global appeal?
Answer:
Introduction

Indian films often rely on remakes or copied plots, reducing their uniqueness. Our textbook shows how this limits creativity.


Argument 1
  • Many Bollywood movies are remakes of Hollywood or South Indian films, like Kabir Singh (remake of Arjun Reddy).

Argument 2
  • Lack of fresh stories makes Indian films predictable, as seen in repetitive romantic dramas.

Conclusion

Originality is key for global recognition, which Indian cinema often misses.

Question 8:
Explain how over-dramatization weakens the storytelling in Indian films.
Answer:
Introduction

Indian films exaggerate emotions and situations, making them unrealistic. We studied this in our NCERT chapter on media.


Argument 1
  • Unnecessary song sequences disrupt the flow, like in Dabangg.

Argument 2
  • Overacting in emotional scenes, as seen in daily soaps, reduces relatability.

Conclusion

Balanced storytelling would make Indian films more engaging and credible.

Question 9:
Analyze the stereotypical portrayal of women in Indian cinema. Provide examples.
Answer:
Introduction

Indian films often show women in limited roles, reinforcing stereotypes. Our textbook highlights this issue.


Argument 1
  • Women are often depicted as helpless or overly glamorous, like in Goliyon Ki Raasleela Ram-Leela.

Argument 2
  • Few films like Pink challenge these norms, but they are exceptions.

Conclusion

Diverse female roles are needed for progressive storytelling.

Question 10:
Why do Indian films struggle with logical inconsistencies? Give two reasons.
Answer:
Introduction

Many Indian films ignore logic for entertainment, as we learned in our media studies chapter.


Argument 1
  • Unrealistic action scenes, like gravity-defying stunts in Baahubali, break immersion.

Argument 2
  • Illogical plot twists, such as sudden character transformations, confuse viewers.

Conclusion

Stronger scripts would improve the quality of Indian cinema.

Question 11:
Discuss the major criticisms of Indian films as highlighted in the chapter What is Wrong with Indian Films. Provide examples to support your answer.
Answer:

The chapter What is Wrong with Indian Films critiques several aspects of Indian cinema that hinder its artistic and intellectual growth. The major criticisms include:

  • Over-reliance on formulaic plots: Many Indian films follow predictable storylines, often revolving around romance, action, or family drama, leaving little room for innovation. For example, most commercial films feature a hero-villain conflict with a forced happy ending.
  • Lack of realism: Indian films often exaggerate emotions and situations, making them unrealistic. Scenes like the hero fighting dozens of villains single-handedly or sudden musical sequences break the narrative flow.
  • Poor representation of social issues: While some films attempt to address social problems, they often oversimplify or dramatize them for entertainment. For instance, poverty or gender issues are sometimes portrayed superficially.

To improve, filmmakers should focus on original storytelling, realistic portrayals, and meaningful social commentary.

Question 12:
How does the chapter What is Wrong with Indian Films suggest Indian cinema can evolve to match global standards? Explain with relevant points.
Answer:

The chapter suggests several ways for Indian cinema to evolve and compete globally:

  • Emphasizing strong scripts: Films should prioritize well-written scripts with depth and originality, moving away from clichés. For example, movies like Pather Panchali showcase how simple yet powerful storytelling can create an impact.
  • Improving technical quality: Better cinematography, sound design, and editing can elevate the viewing experience. Global films often use advanced technology, which Indian cinema should adopt.
  • Exploring diverse genres: Instead of sticking to commercial formulas, filmmakers should experiment with genres like sci-fi, noir, or psychological thrillers, which are popular worldwide.

By focusing on these areas, Indian films can gain international recognition and artistic credibility.

Question 13:
Analyze the criticisms raised by the author in the chapter What is Wrong with Indian Films regarding the portrayal of Indian culture and societal issues in mainstream cinema. Support your answer with relevant examples from the text.
Answer:

The author highlights several flaws in Indian films, particularly their unrealistic portrayal of Indian culture and societal issues. Key criticisms include:

  • Over-glamorization: Films often exaggerate wealth, romance, and drama, creating a distorted image of reality. For example, lavish weddings and larger-than-life heroes misrepresent ordinary Indian life.
  • Stereotyping: Characters are frequently reduced to clichés, such as the 'evil mother-in-law' or the 'helpless heroine,' reinforcing harmful societal norms.
  • Neglect of Social Issues: Serious topics like poverty, caste discrimination, or gender inequality are either ignored or trivialized for entertainment.

The author argues that this lack of authenticity prevents films from being a true reflection of Indian society. Instead, they cater to commercial interests, sacrificing meaningful storytelling.

Question 14:
Analyze the portrayal of social issues in Indian films as discussed in the chapter What is Wrong with Indian Films. Support your answer with examples and suggest how films can better address these issues. (5 marks)
Answer:

The chapter What is Wrong with Indian Films highlights how Indian cinema often glamorizes or oversimplifies serious social issues like poverty, gender inequality, and corruption. Instead of deep analysis, films tend to use these issues as mere plot devices for drama or entertainment.

For example, many films show poverty in a romanticized way, focusing on the resilience of the poor rather than systemic causes. Similarly, gender roles are often stereotyped, with women playing secondary roles or being objectified.

  • Solution: Films should adopt a more realistic and nuanced approach. For instance, movies like Peepli Live (farmer suicides) and Pink (consent) handle social issues with depth and sensitivity.
  • Impact: Such films can raise awareness and inspire change by presenting issues authentically, encouraging audiences to think critically.

By focusing on authentic storytelling and avoiding commercial tropes, Indian cinema can become a powerful tool for social reform.

Question 15:
Analyze the criticisms raised by the author in the chapter What is Wrong with Indian Films regarding the portrayal of Indian culture in mainstream cinema. Support your answer with examples from the text.
Answer:

The author highlights several flaws in the portrayal of Indian culture in mainstream films, emphasizing how they often distort reality for commercial gain. Stereotyping is a major issue, where characters are reduced to clichés, such as the angry young man or the self-sacrificing mother, which oversimplifies human emotions and societal roles.

Another criticism is the misrepresentation of traditions. For instance, weddings in films are shown as grand, extravagant affairs, ignoring the diversity and simplicity of real Indian weddings. The author also points out the excessive focus on melodrama and unrealistic plots, which detach audiences from genuine cultural narratives.

Examples from the text include the glorification of violence as a solution to problems, which misleads the youth, and the underrepresentation of rural India, creating a skewed perception of the country's diversity. The author urges filmmakers to adopt more authentic storytelling to preserve and respect India's rich cultural heritage.

Question 16:
Analyze the criticisms raised by the author in the chapter What is Wrong with Indian Films regarding the portrayal of social issues in Indian cinema. Support your answer with examples from the text.
Answer:

The author highlights several flaws in the portrayal of social issues in Indian films, emphasizing how they often lack depth and realism. One major criticism is the glorification of stereotypes, where characters are reduced to clichés rather than being nuanced representations of real-life struggles. For example, poverty is frequently depicted in an exaggerated or melodramatic manner, losing its authenticity.

Another issue is the oversimplification of complex problems. Films tend to provide quick, unrealistic solutions to deep-rooted issues like caste discrimination or gender inequality, which misleads the audience. The chapter cites instances where a single heroic speech or action miraculously resolves decades of oppression, which is far from reality.

Additionally, the author points out the commercialization of social messages. Many films use social issues as a backdrop for entertainment rather than raising genuine awareness. For instance, songs and dance sequences are often inserted into serious narratives, diluting the intended message.

To score full marks, a student should also mention how these criticisms reflect a need for more responsible storytelling in Indian cinema, where filmmakers balance entertainment with meaningful social commentary.

Question 17:
Analyze the criticisms raised by the author in the chapter What is Wrong with Indian Films regarding the portrayal of Indian culture and societal issues in mainstream cinema. Support your answer with examples from the text.
Answer:

The author in What is Wrong with Indian Films highlights several key criticisms about how mainstream Indian cinema misrepresents Indian culture and societal issues. The primary concerns include:

  • Over-dramatization: Films often exaggerate emotions and situations, making them unrealistic. For example, family conflicts are blown out of proportion, creating a distorted view of Indian family values.
  • Stereotyping: Characters are frequently reduced to clichés, such as the 'evil mother-in-law' or the 'sacrificial heroine,' which do not reflect the diversity of Indian society.
  • Neglect of Real Issues: Serious topics like poverty, caste discrimination, or gender inequality are either ignored or superficially addressed, focusing instead on escapist entertainment.

The author argues that this lack of authenticity not only misleads audiences but also fails to use cinema as a tool for social change. For instance, instead of showcasing nuanced discussions on gender roles, films often reinforce regressive stereotypes. By addressing these flaws, Indian cinema could better reflect the true essence of Indian culture and contribute meaningfully to societal progress.

Question 18:
Based on the chapter What is Wrong with Indian Films, discuss in detail the major criticisms of Indian cinema as highlighted by the author. Support your answer with relevant examples. (5 marks)
Answer:

The chapter What is Wrong with Indian Films critiques Indian cinema for several key issues. The author highlights the following major criticisms:

  • Lack of Originality: Many Indian films rely heavily on clichéd plots, remakes, or copied storylines from foreign films, lacking creative originality. For example, numerous Bollywood movies are direct adaptations of Hollywood or South Korean films without adding unique cultural depth.
  • Overuse of Melodrama: Indian films often exaggerate emotions, dialogues, and situations, making them unrealistic. Scenes with excessive crying, over-the-top action, or illogical romance dominate the narrative, reducing the quality of storytelling.
  • Stereotypical Portrayals: Characters are frequently one-dimensional, such as the 'ideal heroine' or the 'angry young man,' reinforcing outdated social norms. Women, in particular, are often shown in limited roles, focusing on beauty rather than substance.
  • Excessive Focus on Music and Dance: While songs and dances are culturally significant, their forced inclusion disrupts the flow of the story. For instance, a serious scene may abruptly shift to a festive song sequence, breaking the audience's immersion.
  • Neglect of Meaningful Themes: Commercial films prioritize entertainment over thought-provoking content. Social issues, historical events, or realistic human struggles are rarely explored in depth, unlike in parallel or regional cinema.

To improve, Indian cinema should focus on authentic storytelling, diverse character representation, and balanced entertainment, drawing inspiration from meaningful films like Pather Panchali or Taare Zameen Par.

Question 19:
Analyze the portrayal of social issues in Indian films as discussed in the chapter What is Wrong with Indian Films. Provide examples to support your answer.
Answer:

The chapter What is Wrong with Indian Films critically examines how Indian cinema often misrepresents or oversimplifies social issues. Many films tend to focus on entertainment rather than addressing real-life problems with depth. For instance, poverty is frequently glamorized, and complex issues like caste discrimination or gender inequality are reduced to dramatic dialogues or song sequences.

Examples include:

  • Films showing poverty as a backdrop for romance, ignoring the harsh realities faced by the poor.
  • Portrayal of women as secondary characters, often limited to stereotypical roles like the sacrificing mother or the love interest.

However, some recent films like Article 15 and Pink have attempted to address social issues more responsibly, showcasing the need for change in Indian cinema.

Question 20:
Discuss the impact of commercialization on the quality of Indian films, as highlighted in the chapter What is Wrong with Indian Films. How does it affect storytelling?
Answer:

The chapter emphasizes that commercialization has led to a decline in the artistic quality of Indian films. Producers often prioritize box office success over meaningful storytelling, resulting in formulaic plots, excessive song-and-dance sequences, and over-the-top action scenes.

Key impacts include:

  • Lack of originality: Many films follow the same predictable templates to ensure commercial success.
  • Superficial content: Deep narratives are replaced with masala entertainment to attract larger audiences.

For example, films like Dabangg focus more on star power and entertainment than on a compelling storyline. This shift discourages filmmakers from experimenting with bold or unconventional themes, ultimately limiting the growth of Indian cinema as an art form.

Case-based Questions (4 Marks) – with Solutions (CBSE Pattern)

These 4-mark case-based questions assess analytical skills through real-life scenarios. Answers must be based on the case study provided.

Question 1:
Based on the chapter What is Wrong with Indian Films, explain why the author criticizes Indian films for lacking originality. Support your answer with two examples from the text.
Answer:
Case Summary

The author highlights how Indian films often copy Western plots without adding cultural depth.

Analysis
  • Films rely on stereotypical tropes like exaggerated drama.
  • Example 1: Blindly remaking Hollywood movies without local context.
  • Example 2: Repeating the same love triangle plots for decades.
Conclusion

Our textbook shows this limits creativity and fails to represent India's diversity (2m comprehension + 2m examples).

Question 2:
How does the chapter What is Wrong with Indian Films connect commercialization to poor storytelling? Use two arguments from the text.
Answer:
Case Summary

Films prioritize profit over meaningful narratives.

Analysis
  • Studios force item songs to attract audiences, disrupting plots.
  • Example 1: Adding unnecessary fight scenes for box-office success.
  • Example 2: Overusing stars instead of focusing on scripts.
Conclusion

We studied how this reduces artistic value, as seen in NCERT examples (2m analysis + 2m application).

Question 3:
The chapter mentions Indian films often misrepresent social issues. Analyze this with two instances discussed in the text.
Answer:
Case Summary

Films oversimplify complex problems like poverty or caste.

Analysis
  • Example 1: Villains are shown as stereotypically 'evil' without backstories.
  • Example 2: Farmers' struggles are romanticized rather than explored.
Conclusion

Our textbook argues this spreads misinformation (2m content + 2m examples).

Question 4:
Why does the author argue that Indian films neglect technical excellence? Provide two reasons from the chapter.
Answer:
Case Summary

Films ignore cinematography and editing quality.

Analysis
  • Example 1: Poor sound mixing in songs distracts viewers.
  • Example 2: Overuse of green screens makes scenes unrealistic.
Conclusion

We studied how this lowers global standards (2m explanation + 2m evidence).

Question 5:
The chapter blames lack of experimentation for stagnant Indian cinema. Justify with two text references.
Answer:
Case Summary

Directors avoid risks by repeating formulas.

Analysis
  • Example 1: Biopics alter facts to fit dramatic templates.
  • Example 2: Few films explore genres like sci-fi or noir.
Conclusion

NCERT shows this limits growth (2m conceptual + 2m applied).

Question 6:
Based on the chapter What is Wrong with Indian Films, explain how lack of originality affects Indian cinema. Support your answer with examples.
Answer:
Case Summary

Indian films often rely on remakes or copied plots, reducing creativity. Our textbook shows how this limits storytelling.

Analysis
  • Many films reuse South Indian or Hollywood scripts (e.g., Kabir Singh copied from Arjun Reddy).
  • Original concepts like Taare Zameen Par are rare but impactful.
Conclusion

Lack of originality makes films predictable, but exceptions prove innovation works.

Question 7:
How does excessive melodrama weaken the quality of Indian films as discussed in the chapter? Provide two effects.
Answer:
Case Summary

Overuse of melodrama makes films unrealistic. We studied how this pushes audiences away.

Analysis
  • Unnatural dialogues (e.g., K3G's exaggerated emotions).
  • Forced conflicts reduce relatability (e.g., Dabangg action scenes).
Conclusion

Melodrama overshadows genuine storytelling, but balanced films like Queen succeed.

Question 8:
Analyze the impact of item songs on Indian cinema’s narrative depth with textbook references.
Answer:
Case Summary

Item songs disrupt plot flow. Our textbook mentions their commercial but shallow appeal.

Analysis
  • Unnecessary additions (e.g., Munni Badnaam in Dabangg).
  • Films like Pink prove stories can thrive without them.
Conclusion

While item songs attract viewers, they often dilute serious themes.

Question 9:
Why does the chapter criticize stereotypical characters in Indian films? Give two examples.
Answer:
Case Summary

Stereotypes limit representation. We studied how they reinforce clichés.

Analysis
  • Villains with scars (e.g., Sholay’s Gabbar).
  • Helpless heroines (e.g., DDLJ’s Simran).
Conclusion

Breaking stereotypes, as in Dangal, creates richer narratives.

Question 10:
Based on the chapter What is Wrong with Indian Films, explain why the author criticizes the lack of originality in Indian cinema. Support your answer with examples.
Answer:
Case Summary

The author highlights how Indian films often copy Western plots without adding originality. This limits creativity and cultural representation.

Analysis
  • Many films reuse Hollywood stories (e.g., Kaante copies Reservoir Dogs).
  • Our textbook shows how original stories like Pather Panchali stand out.
Conclusion

Original storytelling preserves cultural identity and engages audiences better.

Question 11:
How does the chapter What is Wrong with Indian Films describe the impact of commercialization on film quality? Provide two effects.
Answer:
Case Summary

Excessive focus on profits reduces artistic value in films.

Analysis
  • Films prioritize star power over scripts (e.g., Race 3).
  • Our textbook mentions how meaningful films like Do Bigha Zamin struggle for funding.
Conclusion

Balancing commerce and creativity is essential for quality cinema.

Question 12:
According to the chapter, why does stereotyping harm Indian films? Give two examples from the text.
Answer:
Case Summary

Stereotypes limit character depth and reinforce biases.

Analysis
  • Villains often have dark skin (e.g., Krissh).
  • Our textbook cites how Mother India broke stereotypes of women.
Conclusion

Diverse portrayals make films more realistic and inclusive.

Question 13:
Explain how song-and-dance sequences affect storytelling in Indian films, as per the chapter. Support with examples.
Answer:
Case Summary

Unnecessary songs disrupt narrative flow.

Analysis
  • Forced songs lengthen films (e.g., Dabangg).
  • Our textbook praises A Wednesday for minimal songs.
Conclusion

Songs should enhance, not distract from, the story.

Question 14:

Read the following excerpt from the chapter What is Wrong with Indian Films:

"Indian films often rely on exaggerated emotions, unrealistic plots, and stereotypical characters, which detract from meaningful storytelling."

Based on the excerpt, analyze how these elements impact the audience's perception of Indian cinema. Support your answer with examples from the chapter.

Answer:

The exaggerated emotions, unrealistic plots, and stereotypical characters in Indian films create a disconnect between cinema and real-life experiences. Here’s how they impact the audience:

  • Exaggerated Emotions: Over-the-top reactions make the narrative seem melodramatic, reducing relatability. For example, excessive crying or anger in scenes often feels artificial.
  • Unrealistic Plots: Films with implausible storylines (e.g., sudden wealth or miraculous solutions) fail to engage the audience intellectually, as they lack logical progression.
  • Stereotypical Characters: Repeated use of clichéd roles (e.g., the 'evil mother-in-law' or 'helpless heroine') limits creativity and reinforces outdated social norms.

These elements collectively diminish the artistic value of Indian cinema, making it less appealing to discerning viewers who seek depth and authenticity.

Question 15:

In the chapter What is Wrong with Indian Films, the author critiques the lack of originality in Indian cinema. Discuss how this issue affects the global perception of Indian films and suggest one way filmmakers can improve originality, citing examples from the chapter.

Answer:

The lack of originality in Indian films harms their global reputation, as they are often seen as imitations of Western or regional cinema rather than unique creations. Here’s why:

  • Global Perception: Copying plots or styles from Hollywood or other industries makes Indian films appear unoriginal, reducing their appeal internationally.
  • Cultural Misrepresentation: Overuse of clichés (e.g., song-and-dance sequences in every film) reinforces stereotypes about Indian culture being overly dramatic.

Solution: Filmmakers should draw inspiration from India’s rich literary and historical heritage to create fresh narratives. For example, adapting lesser-known folk tales or historical events (as mentioned in the chapter) can add authenticity and depth.

By focusing on original storytelling, Indian cinema can gain respect globally while staying true to its roots.

Question 16:

Read the following case study and answer the question that follows:

Rahul, a 10th-grade student, watched a popular Indian film and noticed that it heavily relied on stereotypical characters, exaggerated emotions, and lacked a strong storyline. His teacher explained that many Indian films suffer from these issues, as discussed in the chapter 'What is Wrong with Indian Films'.

Question: Based on the chapter, analyze two major flaws in Indian films highlighted by Rahul's observation and suggest how filmmakers can improve these aspects to create more meaningful cinema.

Answer:

Answer:

The two major flaws observed in Indian films, as per the chapter, are:

  • Stereotypical Characters: Many Indian films rely on clichéd roles (e.g., the hero always being flawless or the villain being overly dramatic). This limits creativity and fails to represent real-life diversity.
  • Exaggerated Emotions and Weak Storylines: Over-the-top dialogues and unrealistic situations often overshadow meaningful narratives, making films less relatable.

Suggestions for Improvement:

  • Filmmakers should focus on character development, creating multi-dimensional roles that reflect real people.
  • They should prioritize strong scripts with logical plots and subtle emotions to engage the audience intellectually.

By addressing these flaws, Indian cinema can evolve into a more thoughtful and impactful medium.

Question 17:

Read the following case study and answer the question that follows:

Priya attended a film festival where international movies were screened alongside Indian films. She observed that while foreign films often emphasized realism and subtle storytelling, Indian films tended to focus more on songs, dance, and melodrama. This made her wonder why Indian films differ so much in their approach.

Question: Referring to the chapter 'What is Wrong with Indian Films', explain two reasons behind the dominance of songs, dance, and melodrama in Indian cinema. Also, discuss how this affects the global perception of Indian films.

Answer:

Answer:

The dominance of songs, dance, and melodrama in Indian films can be attributed to:

  • Cultural Tradition: Indian cinema has deep roots in theatrical and musical traditions like folk dramas and classical dance forms, making songs and dance integral to storytelling.
  • Commercial Appeal: Mass audiences often associate entertainment with grandeur, leading filmmakers to prioritize spectacle over substance to ensure box-office success.

Impact on Global Perception:

While these elements make Indian films unique, they sometimes reinforce the stereotype that Indian cinema lacks depth. International audiences may perceive them as overly dramatic or unrealistic, limiting their appeal in global markets that prefer nuanced narratives.

However, balancing entertainment with meaningful content could help Indian films gain wider recognition while preserving their cultural identity.

Question 18:
Read the following excerpt from the chapter What is Wrong with Indian Films:

'Indian films often rely on exaggerated emotions and unrealistic plots, which detract from meaningful storytelling.'

Based on this, analyze how such elements impact the audience's perception of cinema and suggest one way filmmakers can improve narrative quality.
Answer:

The reliance on exaggerated emotions and unrealistic plots in Indian films creates a disconnect between the audience and the story. This often leads to viewers perceiving cinema as mere entertainment rather than a medium for meaningful messages or social commentary. Such films may also reinforce stereotypes and fail to challenge the audience intellectually.

To improve narrative quality, filmmakers should focus on realistic storytelling by:

  • Incorporating relatable characters and situations
  • Balancing entertainment with thought-provoking themes

This shift can elevate Indian cinema's global standing and foster a deeper appreciation for the art form.

Question 19:
A group of students debated whether Indian films prioritize commercial success over artistic value, as discussed in the chapter What is Wrong with Indian Films. Evaluate both sides of the argument and justify which aspect should be given more importance for the growth of Indian cinema.
Answer:

Commercial success ensures the financial viability of films, allowing the industry to thrive and reach wider audiences. However, excessive focus on profit often leads to formulaic storytelling, item numbers, and star-driven projects that lack depth.

On the other hand, artistic value brings creativity, innovation, and cultural significance to cinema. Films with strong artistic merit can:

  • Showcase India's diverse stories authentically
  • Gain international recognition
  • Inspire meaningful conversations

While both aspects are important, artistic value should be prioritized as it fosters long-term growth, elevates standards, and preserves cinema's cultural importance. A balance can be achieved by supporting independent filmmakers and encouraging experimental narratives within mainstream cinema.

Question 20:
Read the following excerpt from the chapter What is Wrong with Indian Films:

"Indian films often rely on exaggerated emotions and melodrama, which distances them from reality. The focus on song-and-dance sequences, though entertaining, often disrupts the narrative flow."

Based on this, analyze how the overuse of melodrama and song sequences affects the quality of Indian films. Support your answer with examples.
Answer:

The overuse of melodrama and song sequences in Indian films often compromises their artistic and narrative quality. Here’s how:

  • Melodrama: Excessive emotional exaggeration makes characters and situations unrealistic, reducing relatability. For example, prolonged crying scenes or sudden outbursts of anger feel forced and lack subtlety.
  • Song Sequences: While entertaining, they often break the storyline’s continuity. For instance, a serious scene transitioning into a festive song disrupts the audience’s engagement with the plot.

Such elements prioritize commercial appeal over storytelling, making films less impactful. A balanced approach, like in movies such as Taare Zameen Par, where emotions are nuanced and songs complement the narrative, showcases better filmmaking.

Question 21:
The chapter What is Wrong with Indian Films highlights the lack of original storytelling in Indian cinema. Imagine you are a film critic. Write a short analysis comparing an original Indian film (e.g., Udaan) with a typical masala film, focusing on how originality enhances cinematic value.
Answer:

Original storytelling, as seen in films like Udaan, elevates cinematic value by offering depth and authenticity. Here’s a comparison:

  • Original Film (Udaan): It explores relatable themes like parental pressure and dreams with realistic characters and minimal clichés. The absence of unnecessary songs or over-the-top drama keeps the narrative tight and emotionally resonant.
  • Masala Film: Relies on recycled plots, exaggerated action, and formulaic song sequences. For example, many commercial films reuse the "lost-and-found" trope, sacrificing originality for mass appeal.

Original films like Udaan prove that substance over style creates lasting impact, while masala films often prioritize temporary entertainment over meaningful storytelling.

Question 22:
Read the following excerpt from the chapter What is Wrong with Indian Films:

'Indian films often rely on exaggerated emotions and melodrama, which distances them from realistic storytelling.'

Based on this, analyze how the overuse of melodrama affects the quality of Indian films and suggest one way filmmakers can improve this aspect.
Answer:

The overuse of melodrama in Indian films often makes them unrealistic and less relatable to audiences. Exaggerated emotions and dramatic sequences can overshadow meaningful storytelling, reducing the film's impact.


To improve, filmmakers can focus on subtlety and natural performances, drawing inspiration from real-life situations. For example, using understated dialogues and authentic character reactions can enhance realism.


Additionally, incorporating social themes with a balanced emotional approach can make films more engaging and thought-provoking.

Question 23:
In the chapter What is Wrong with Indian Films, the author criticizes the lack of originality in scripts. Imagine you are a filmmaker. Propose two strategies to encourage original storytelling in Indian cinema while keeping cultural relevance intact.
Answer:

As a filmmaker, I would adopt the following strategies to promote original storytelling:

  • Encourage New Writers: Host scriptwriting competitions or workshops to discover fresh talent with unique perspectives.
  • Blend Tradition with Innovation: Use folk tales or regional stories as inspiration but present them in modern, unconventional ways to appeal to younger audiences.

By valuing creativity and cultural roots, Indian cinema can produce more authentic and engaging content.

Chat on WhatsApp