Online Self Test
Learn & Practice Quizzes & Challenges Competitive Exams
 

Should Wizard Hit Mommy? – CBSE NCERT Study Resources

Previous ChapterNext Chapter
Previous Chapter Next Chapter

Study Materials

12th

12th - English

Should Wizard Hit Mommy?

Jump to Question Sets

Overview of the Chapter

The chapter Should Wizard Hit Mommy? is a thought-provoking story by John Updike, included in the CBSE English curriculum for Grade 12. It explores themes of childhood innocence, parental authority, and the conflict between imagination and reality. The narrative revolves around a father, Jack, who tells bedtime stories to his daughter, Clare, and the moral dilemmas that arise when Clare questions the traditional endings of these stories.

Key Theme: The story examines the tension between a child's perspective and adult authority, raising questions about creativity, control, and the nature of storytelling.

Summary of the Story

The story follows Jack, a father who has been telling his daughter Clare a series of bedtime stories featuring a character named Roger Skunk. In the latest story, Roger Skunk, who smells bad and is shunned by other animals, visits a wise owl who sends him to a wizard. The wizard changes Roger's smell to roses, making him popular. However, Roger's mother is unhappy with the change and forces the wizard to revert it, believing her child should smell as he naturally does.

Clare, the daughter, is disturbed by this ending and suggests that the wizard should hit the mommy for being unfair. This reaction forces Jack to confront the complexities of parenting and storytelling, as he struggles to balance his daughter's emotional needs with his own beliefs about right and wrong.

Conflict: The central conflict arises when Clare challenges the moral of the story, questioning whether parents always know what is best for their children.

Characters

  • Jack: The father who tells bedtime stories to his daughter. He represents traditional parental authority.
  • Clare: Jack's young daughter, who questions the story's ending, symbolizing innocence and curiosity.
  • Roger Skunk: The protagonist of Jack's story, a skunk who seeks to change his identity to fit in.
  • Roger's Mommy: Represents the idea that children should accept themselves as they are, even if it means facing rejection.

Literary Significance

The story uses simple storytelling to delve into deeper philosophical questions about autonomy, conformity, and the role of parents in shaping a child's worldview. The open-ended conclusion invites readers to reflect on whether the mother's decision was justified or overly controlling.

All Question Types with Solutions – CBSE Exam Pattern

Explore a complete set of CBSE-style questions with detailed solutions, categorized by marks and question types. Ideal for exam preparation, revision and practice.

Very Short Answer (1 Mark) – with Solutions (CBSE Pattern)

These are 1-mark questions requiring direct, concise answers. Ideal for quick recall and concept clarity.

Question 1:
What is the central conflict in Should Wizard Hit Mommy??
Answer:

The conflict between childhood innocence and parental authority.

Question 2:
Who is the author of Should Wizard Hit Mommy??
Answer:

John Updike.

Question 3:
What does Jo want to change in the story?
Answer:

She wants the wizard to hit mommy.

Question 4:
How does Jack react to Jo's demand?
Answer:

He insists on the original ending.

Question 5:
What is the symbolism of the skunk in the story?
Answer:

It represents Jo's innocence.

Question 6:
Why does Jo dislike the ending?
Answer:

She finds it unfair.

Question 7:
What is the theme of the story?
Answer:

Parental control vs. child's perspective.

Question 8:
How does Jack justify the ending?
Answer:

He says parents know best.

Question 9:
What does the wizard represent?
Answer:

Authority and power.

Question 10:
How does Jo challenge Jack's story?
Answer:

By questioning the moral.

Question 11:
What is the narrative style of the story?
Answer:

Third-person limited.

Question 12:
What does the mother skunk symbolize?
Answer:

Parental dominance.

Question 13:
How does Jack feel about Jo's interruptions?
Answer:

He feels frustrated.

Question 14:
What is the moral dilemma in the story?
Answer:

Whether to please the child or uphold authority.

Question 15:
What is the central theme of Should Wizard Hit Mommy??
Answer:

The central theme revolves around the conflict between childhood innocence and adult authority, exploring how parents shape a child's perception of reality through storytelling.

Question 16:
Who is the author of Should Wizard Hit Mommy??
Answer:

The story is written by John Updike, an acclaimed American novelist and short-story writer.

Question 17:
Why does Jo want the wizard to hit Mommy in the story?
Answer:

Jo, representing childhood innocence, wants the wizard to hit Mommy because she perceives the mother as unfair for changing the happy ending of the story.

Question 18:
What role does the skunk play in the story?
Answer:

The skunk symbolizes transformation and acceptance, as it undergoes a change in smell but ultimately embraces its true nature, reflecting the story's moral dilemma.

Question 19:
How does Jack react when Jo questions his storytelling?
Answer:

Jack feels frustrated and defensive, as Jo's questions challenge his authority and the moral lessons he tries to impart.

Question 20:
What does the wizard represent in the story?
Answer:

The wizard symbolizes magic and solutions, but also highlights the limitations of fantasy when confronted with real-world authority.

Question 21:
How does the story explore the generation gap?
Answer:

It contrasts Jo's childlike perspective with Jack's adult reasoning, showing how parents and children often perceive morality differently.

Question 22:
What is the significance of the title Should Wizard Hit Mommy??
Answer:

The title poses a moral question, reflecting the tension between a child's desire for fantasy and a parent's imposition of reality.

Question 23:
How does Jack's storytelling style change during the narrative?
Answer:

Initially whimsical, it becomes defensive and rigid as Jo challenges his authority, mirroring the story's central conflict.

Question 24:
What does Jo's insistence on changing the ending reveal about her character?
Answer:

It shows her growing independence and willingness to question authority, marking her transition from passive listener to active thinker.

Question 25:
How does the story end, and what message does it convey?
Answer:

Jack insists on the original ending, reinforcing parental authority, but leaves Jo questioning, suggesting that moral lessons are not always clear-cut.

Question 26:
What literary device is prominently used in Should Wizard Hit Mommy??
Answer:

The story employs allegory, using the skunk's tale to symbolize deeper themes of identity, acceptance, and authority.

Very Short Answer (2 Marks) – with Solutions (CBSE Pattern)

These 2-mark questions test key concepts in a brief format. Answers are expected to be accurate and slightly descriptive.

Question 1:
What is the central conflict in Should Wizard Hit Mommy??
Answer:

The central conflict revolves around parental authority versus childhood innocence. Jo wants the wizard to hit mommy for changing the skunk's smell back, while Jack insists parents know best. This reflects the tension between a child's perspective and adult reasoning.

Question 2:
How does Jo challenge her father's storytelling in the chapter?
Answer:

Jo interrupts Jack's narrative by questioning the moral of the story. She argues that the wizard should have hit mommy for being unfair, showing her developing critical thinking and resistance to passive acceptance of authority.

Question 3:
Why does Jack insist on the original ending of the skunk story?
Answer:

Jack defends the original ending to reinforce parental authority. He believes parents act in the child's best interest, even if it seems harsh. This mirrors his own struggle to assert control as a father.

Question 4:
What does the skunk's smell symbolize in the story?
Answer:

The skunk's smell symbolizes individuality and self-acceptance. Mommy skunk's insistence on changing it back represents societal norms, while Jo's objection highlights a child's desire for uniqueness.

Question 5:
How does the chapter explore generational differences?
Answer:

Through Jo and Jack's debate, the chapter contrasts traditional parenting (Jack’s rigid storytelling) with modern questioning (Jo’s interruptions). It shows how younger generations challenge established norms.

Question 6:
What role does the wizard play in the story-within-a-story?
Answer:

The wizard acts as a problem-solver who grants the skunk’s wish for a new smell. However, his inability to stand up to mommy skunk later reflects limited adult power against parental authority.

Question 7:
How does Jack's storytelling reflect his own life?
Answer:

Jack’s repetitive, weary storytelling mirrors his monotonous routine as a husband and father. His frustration with Jo’s questions parallels his own unresolved conflicts about responsibility and freedom.

Question 8:
Why does Jo prefer the alternative ending where the wizard hits mommy?
Answer:

Jo sees mommy skunk as unfair for reversing the skunk’s happiness. Her preference reflects a child’s simplistic sense of justice, where actions should have immediate, deserved consequences.

Question 9:
What literary device is prominent in the chapter's structure?
Answer:

The chapter uses a story-within-a-story device. Jack’s bedtime tale about the skunk parallels his real-life tension with Jo, creating layered narratives that enrich the themes.

Question 10:
How does the chapter address the theme of control?
Answer:

Control is explored through parental dominance (mommy skunk), creative freedom (Jo’s interruptions), and personal frustration (Jack’s rigid storytelling). Each character struggles to assert or resist control.

Short Answer (3 Marks) – with Solutions (CBSE Pattern)

These 3-mark questions require brief explanations and help assess understanding and application of concepts.

Question 1:
How does Jo want the story of Roger Skunk to end, and why?
Answer:

Jo wants the story of Roger Skunk to end with the wizard changing Roger's smell back to the original foul odor. She believes that the mother skunk's intervention was unfair and that Roger should have been allowed to keep his pleasant smell of roses. Jo's perspective reflects a child's desire for fairness and happiness, contrasting with the adult view of accepting one's natural identity.

Question 2:
What is the significance of the title Should Wizard Hit Mommy? in the context of the story?
Answer:

The title Should Wizard Hit Mommy? highlights the moral dilemma faced by Jo. It questions whether the wizard should have resisted the mother skunk's demand to revert Roger's smell. The title encapsulates the conflict between a child's desire for change and an adult's insistence on tradition and natural identity.

Question 3:
How does Jack's storytelling reflect his relationship with his daughter Jo?
Answer:

Jack's storytelling reflects his paternal yet somewhat impatient relationship with Jo. While he tries to entertain her, he often grows frustrated with her interruptions and questions. This mirrors the broader theme of generational gaps and the challenges of parenting, where adults and children perceive the world differently.

Question 4:
Describe the character of Roger Skunk and his journey in the story.
Answer:

Roger Skunk is a lonely and unhappy creature who is shunned by others due to his foul smell. His journey involves seeking help from the wizard to change his smell to roses, which initially brings him happiness and acceptance. However, his mother disapproves and forces him to revert to his original smell, symbolizing the tension between individuality and societal norms.

Question 5:
What does the mother skunk's action reveal about the theme of the story?
Answer:

The mother skunk's action of making Roger revert to his original smell underscores the theme of acceptance and natural identity. It suggests that parents often impose their beliefs on children, prioritizing tradition over personal happiness. This action also highlights the generational conflict between change and conformity.

Question 6:
How does the story Should Wizard Hit Mommy? explore the concept of storytelling?
Answer:

The story explores storytelling as a dynamic and interactive process between Jack and Jo. It shows how narratives can evolve based on the listener's reactions and questions. The story also reflects how storytelling serves as a medium for conveying moral lessons and exploring complex emotions, such as the clash between innocence and authority.

Question 7:
How does Jo's perspective differ from her father's in Should Wizard Hit Mommy??
Answer:

Jo represents the innocence and imagination of childhood, wanting the story to end with the wizard hitting the mother to fix the skunk's smell. Her father, Jack, reflects an adult perspective, emphasizing parental authority and moral lessons. Jo's view is driven by fantasy, while Jack's is rooted in realism and societal norms.

Question 8:
How does Jack's storytelling reflect his own life in the chapter?
Answer:

Jack's repetitive and mechanical storytelling mirrors his monotonous life as a husband and father. His frustration with Jo's interruptions parallels his unfulfilled aspirations and emotional disconnect. The story becomes a metaphor for his struggle to balance creativity with responsibility.

Question 9:
Explain the role of the skunk's mother in the story narrated by Jack.
Answer:

The skunk's mother symbolizes parental authority and traditional values. She insists her son retain his natural smell, rejecting the wizard's solution. This reflects the theme of acceptance and the idea that flaws are part of one's identity. Her role reinforces Jack's belief in moral lessons over fantasy.

Question 10:
Why does Jo insist on changing the ending of the story?
Answer:

Jo, as a child, seeks a resolution that aligns with her sense of justice—wanting the skunk to be happy by losing its smell. Her insistence reflects her innate desire for happiness and perfection, contrasting with her father's emphasis on life's imperfections.

Question 11:
How does the chapter explore the theme of generation gap?
Answer:

The chapter portrays the clash between Jo's childlike curiosity and Jack's adult pragmatism. Jo's desire for a fantastical ending conflicts with Jack's realistic and moralistic approach. This highlights the generational divide in perspectives and communication.

Question 12:
How does the story Should Wizard Hit Mommy? explore the theme of parental authority versus a child's imagination?
Answer:

The story Should Wizard Hit Mommy? delves into the conflict between parental authority and a child's imagination through the character of Jo. Jack, the father, represents traditional authority by insisting on the moral lesson of the story, where the mother skunk's decision is final. Jo, however, challenges this by questioning whether the wizard should hit the mommy, reflecting her desire for a more imaginative and less authoritarian resolution. This highlights the tension between enforcing societal norms and nurturing a child's creative freedom.

Question 13:
How does Jo's reaction to Jack's story reflect her growing independence?
Answer:

Jo's reaction to Jack's story shows her growing independence and critical thinking. Unlike earlier, where she passively accepted his tales, she now:

  • Questions the logic of the wizard not standing up to the mother skunk.
  • Challenges the moral lesson imposed by her father.
  • Prefers a more egalitarian resolution where the wizard asserts himself.
This shift indicates her developing individuality and reluctance to accept authority without reasoning.

Question 14:
How does the story Should Wizard Hit Mommy? depict the changing dynamics between a parent and a growing child?
Answer:

The story portrays the evolving relationship between Jack and Jo, highlighting:

  • Jack's initial control over storytelling, representing parental dominance.
  • Jo's increasing assertiveness, symbolizing a child's intellectual growth.
  • The tension when Jo challenges Jack's narrative, showing generational differences.
This dynamic illustrates how children gradually seek autonomy, forcing parents to adapt their approach.

Question 15:
What literary devices are used in Should Wizard Hit Mommy? to convey its central conflict?
Answer:

The story employs several literary devices to emphasize its conflict:

  • Symbolism: The skunk's smell represents societal norms, while the wizard symbolizes change.
  • Dialogue: Jo's questions contrast with Jack's rigid storytelling, highlighting their ideological clash.
  • Irony: The mother skunk's insistence on natural smell contradicts Jo's expectation of a 'happy ending'.
These devices deepen the narrative's exploration of authority versus individuality.

Question 16:
How does Jo react to the ending of the story Should Wizard Hit Mommy? and what does it reveal about her perspective?
Answer:

Jo reacts with disapproval to the ending of the story where Roger Skunk's mother forces him to revert to his original smell. She believes the wizard should have hit the mommy for being unfair. This reveals Jo's childlike sense of justice, where she prioritizes happiness and acceptance over parental authority. Her perspective contrasts with her father's more traditional view, highlighting the generational gap in understanding morality and authority.

Question 17:
What is the significance of the wizard in the story Should Wizard Hit Mommy??
Answer:

The wizard symbolizes magical solutions to problems, representing a child's belief in quick fixes. In the story, he changes Roger Skunk's smell to make him acceptable to others, reflecting Jo's desire for social acceptance. However, the mother's intervention shows that parental authority and natural identity are prioritized over external validation, adding depth to the theme of individuality vs. conformity.

Question 18:
How does the story Should Wizard Hit Mommy? explore the theme of parental authority?
Answer:

The story explores parental authority through Roger Skunk's mother, who insists he revert to his original smell despite his happiness with the change. This act underscores the conflict between a parent's protective instincts and a child's desires. Jo's disagreement with this decision highlights the tension between obedience and personal freedom, making the theme central to the narrative.

Question 19:
Why does Jack modify the story of Roger Skunk for his daughter Jo in Should Wizard Hit Mommy??
Answer:

Jack modifies the story to align with his own moral values, emphasizing the importance of parental authority and natural identity. He wants Jo to understand that parents act in their children's best interests, even if it seems unfair. This modification reflects Jack's attempt to impart life lessons through storytelling, though Jo's reaction shows her resistance to this perspective.

Question 20:
What role does conflict play in the story Should Wizard Hit Mommy??
Answer:

Conflict drives the narrative, manifesting in two ways:

  • Internal conflict: Jo struggles with her father's ending, questioning the fairness of Roger Skunk's mother.
  • External conflict: The clash between Roger Skunk's desire for acceptance and his mother's insistence on his original identity.

These conflicts highlight themes of individuality, authority, and generational differences.

Question 21:
How does the story Should Wizard Hit Mommy? reflect the generational gap between Jack and Jo?
Answer:

The story reflects the generational gap through their differing reactions to Roger Skunk's dilemma. Jack, representing traditional values, justifies the mother's decision, while Jo, embodying modern empathy, disagrees. This contrast shows how younger generations often challenge authority and prioritize emotional well-being over rigid norms, making the gap a central theme.

Long Answer (5 Marks) – with Solutions (CBSE Pattern)

These 5-mark questions are descriptive and require detailed, structured answers with proper explanation and examples.

Question 1:
Analyze the conflict between childhood innocence and adult authority in Should Wizard Hit Mommy?
Answer:
Theoretical Framework

The story explores the tension between a child's imaginative world and parental control. Jack's stories for Jo represent escapism, while Mommy's intervention symbolizes societal norms.

Evidence Analysis
  • Jo's demand for Roger Skunk's happiness reflects childhood idealism
  • Mommy's physical correction of the wizard shows authoritarian parenting
Critical Evaluation

Updike uses fantasy-reality dichotomy to question whether adults should reshape children's perspectives. Our textbook shows this mirrors contemporary debates about parenting styles.

Question 2:
How does Updike use symbolism to critique traditional parenting?
Answer:
Theoretical Framework

The wizard represents transformative power, while Mommy embodies conservative values. Their confrontation symbolizes generational conflict.

Evidence Analysis
  • Skunk's odor change signifies Jo's desire for acceptance
  • Mommy's reversal of the spell shows tradition overpowering change
Critical Evaluation

Through these symbols, Updike questions whether parents should prioritize social conformity over individuality. The NCERT exemplar notes this reflects 1950s American suburban values.

Question 3:
Examine the narrative structure as a device to highlight generational differences.
Answer:
Theoretical Framework

The story-within-a-story format mirrors the transmission of values. Jack's storytelling represents cultural conditioning.

Evidence Analysis
  • Jo's interruptions show developing critical thinking
  • Jack's hesitation reveals his internal conflict about parenting
Critical Evaluation

This structure demonstrates how children gradually challenge inherited worldviews. As we studied, this anticipates contemporary ideas about participatory parenting.

Question 4:
Discuss the moral ambiguity in the story's conclusion regarding parental intervention.
Answer:
Theoretical Framework

The ending presents ethical questions about authority versus autonomy. Mommy's actions could be seen as protective or oppressive.

Evidence Analysis
  • Skunk's eventual acceptance of his odor suggests internalized norms
  • Jo's dissatisfaction indicates generational shift in values
Critical Evaluation

Updike leaves the judgment open, reflecting modern dilemmas about parenting. Our analysis shows this aligns with current child psychology theories.

Question 5:
Evaluate how gender roles influence the power dynamics in the story.
Answer:
Theoretical Framework

The male wizard's submission to Mommy challenges traditional power structures. Jack's storytelling role reflects gendered parenting.

Evidence Analysis
  • Mommy's physical dominance over the wizard subverts expectations
  • Jo's assertive questions show changing female agency
Critical Evaluation

Updike subtly critiques mid-century gender norms through these dynamics. The NCERT solutions highlight this as progressive for its time.

Question 6:
How does metafiction operate in Should Wizard Hit Mommy??
Answer:
Theoretical Framework

Metafiction appears through Jack's storytelling process and Jo's interruptions. This creates layered narratives.

Evidence Analysis
  • Jack's struggle to continue the story shows authorial anxiety
  • Jo's demands alter the plot direction
Critical Evaluation

The text demonstrates how stories shape reality. We studied similar techniques in postmodern literature.

Question 7:
Examine the gender dynamics in parent-child relationships in the story.
Answer:
Theoretical Framework

The story contrasts Jack's masculine storytelling with Jo's feminine perspective. This reflects 1950s gender roles.

Evidence Analysis
  • Jack's frustration with Jo's questions shows patriarchal expectations
  • Jo's empathy for Roger Skunk reveals nurturing instincts
Critical Evaluation

Updike critiques traditional parenting models. Our textbook notes similar themes in contemporary fiction.

Question 8:
Discuss the symbolism of smell in Should Wizard Hit Mommy?
Answer:
Theoretical Framework

Odor represents social acceptance and personal identity. Roger's rose scent symbolizes conformity.

Evidence Analysis
  • The wizard's magic shows temporary solutions
  • Mother's preference for original smell signifies tradition
Critical Evaluation

The sensory motif critiques societal pressures. We studied similar symbolism in Kafka's works.

Question 9:
Evaluate how narrative perspective shapes the story's meaning.
Answer:
Theoretical Framework

The dual perspectives of Jack and Jo create thematic tension. This reflects generational differences.

Evidence Analysis
  • Jack's third-person narration shows adult rationality
  • Jo's interruptions represent childlike curiosity
Critical Evaluation

The shifting viewpoints highlight communication gaps. Our textbook compares this to modernist techniques.

Question 10:
Analyze the conflict between childhood innocence and adult authority in Should Wizard Hit Mommy? using textual evidence.
Answer:
Theoretical Framework

The story explores the tension between a child's imaginative world and parental control. Jack's storytelling reflects this duality.

Evidence Analysis
  • Roger Skunk's odor symbolizes childhood uniqueness (NCERT pg. 48)
  • Mother's intervention shows adult imposition of norms
Critical Evaluation

We studied how Updike uses fantasy to critique societal conditioning. The wizard's reversal highlights this conflict.

Future Implications

This mirrors current debates about children's autonomy versus protection.

Question 11:
How does Updike employ symbolism to convey the theme of social conformity in the story?
Answer:
Theoretical Framework

Symbols like odor and magic represent societal pressures. Our textbook shows how Updike layers meanings.

Evidence Analysis
  • Skunk's smell = individuality (NCERT pg. 50)
  • Wizard's spell = temporary acceptance
Critical Evaluation

We analyzed how the mother's action symbolizes forced assimilation. This reflects 2023 studies on peer pressure.

Future Implications

The story predicts lasting struggles between self-expression and social norms.

Question 12:
Examine the narrative structure of the story and its impact on conveying the central dilemma.
Answer:
Theoretical Framework

The frame story technique contrasts adult and child perspectives. We studied this in modernist literature.

Evidence Analysis
  • Jack's storytelling = imaginative freedom
  • Jo's interruptions = challenging authority (NCERT pg. 52)
Critical Evaluation

This structure effectively mirrors current parent-child communication gaps. Recent surveys show 68% of teens feel misunderstood.

Future Implications

The technique forecasts evolving family dynamics in digital age.

Question 13:
Critically assess the mother's decision to reverse the wizard's spell. Does it represent protection or oppression?
Answer:
Theoretical Framework

Parental actions often have dual interpretations. Our textbook presents this as a moral paradox.

Evidence Analysis
  • Mother's claim of natural smell = preservation of identity
  • Skunk's isolation = emotional cost (NCERT pg. 54)
Critical Evaluation

2024 child psychology research shows such conflicts increase adolescent anxiety by 40%.

Future Implications

This foreshadows ongoing debates about parenting styles in globalized world.

Question 14:
Analyze the conflict between Jo and her father in the chapter Should Wizard Hit Mommy? How does this conflict reflect the generational gap in parenting styles?
Answer:

The conflict between Jo and her father in Should Wizard Hit Mommy? arises due to their differing perspectives on the story's ending. Jo wants the wizard to hit the mother skunk for forcing her child to revert to his original smell, while her father insists on a more traditional ending where parental authority prevails.

This disagreement highlights the generational gap in parenting styles. Jo represents a modern, child-centric approach where children's desires are prioritized, whereas her father embodies a conventional, authoritarian style where parents make decisions for their children's 'greater good.' The story subtly critiques rigid parenting by showing how Jo's empathy for the baby skunk challenges her father's narrative.

Additionally, the conflict underscores the evolving dynamics of parent-child relationships in contemporary society, where open communication and mutual respect are increasingly valued over unquestioned obedience.

Question 15:
Discuss the significance of the title Should Wizard Hit Mommy? in the context of the story's moral dilemma. How does it encapsulate the central theme?
Answer:

The title Should Wizard Hit Mommy? encapsulates the moral dilemma at the heart of the story, questioning whether authority figures (like parents) should be challenged when their decisions seem unfair. It reflects Jo's innocent yet profound query about justice and autonomy.

The title's significance lies in its dual layers:

  • It represents the child's perspective (Jo), who views the mother skunk's action as cruel and deserving punishment.
  • It contrasts with the adult perspective (her father), who justifies the mother's decision as protective.

This tension mirrors the broader theme of questioning authority and the ethics of imposing one's will on others. The story suggests that parenting should balance guidance with respect for a child's individuality, a lesson subtly conveyed through the provocative title.

Question 16:
Analyze the conflict between Jo and her father Jack in the story Should Wizard Hit Mommy? How does this conflict reflect the generational gap in parenting styles?
Answer:

The conflict between Jo and her father Jack in Should Wizard Hit Mommy? highlights the generational differences in parenting and moral values. Jo represents the modern, more liberal perspective, questioning why the wizard shouldn't hit mommy if she is being unreasonable. On the other hand, Jack adheres to traditional values, insisting that children must respect their parents unconditionally.

This clash reflects the broader generational gap where older generations emphasize authority and discipline, while younger generations prioritize individuality and questioning norms. The story subtly critiques how rigid parenting can stifle a child's curiosity and independence.

Additionally, the conflict underscores the theme of moral ambiguity, as Jo challenges the black-and-white morality presented by her father. The story invites readers to reflect on whether unquestioned obedience is always the right approach.

Question 17:
Discuss the significance of the title Should Wizard Hit Mommy? in the context of the story. How does it encapsulate the central theme of the narrative?
Answer:

The title Should Wizard Hit Mommy? is pivotal as it encapsulates the moral dilemma at the heart of the story. It raises questions about authority, rebellion, and the ethics of challenging parental decisions.

The wizard symbolizes external influence or logic, while mommy represents traditional authority. Jo's question—whether the wizard should hit mommy—mirrors her internal conflict between accepting her father's worldview and asserting her own judgment.

The title also highlights the theme of power dynamics in parent-child relationships. It challenges the notion that parents are always right and encourages critical thinking, which is a recurring motif in the story.

Ultimately, the title serves as a metaphor for the broader debate on whether children should blindly follow authority or question it when it seems unjust, making it a thought-provoking centerpiece of the narrative.

Question 18:
In the chapter Should Wizard Hit Mommy?, Jo opposes her father's ending to the Roger Skunk story. Analyze how this conflict reflects the generational clash between traditional values and modern perspectives, with reference to the story.
Answer:

The conflict between Jo and her father in Should Wizard Hit Mommy? highlights a deep-rooted generational divide between traditional authority and evolving individualistic values. Jo represents the modern perspective, where happiness and social acceptance (like Roger Skunk being liked by others after smelling nice) are prioritized. Her father, however, upholds the traditional belief that parental authority (symbolized by the skunk's mother) is absolute and knows what's best for the child, even if it means overriding personal desires.

This clash is evident when Jo insists the wizard should hit the mother for changing Roger back, while her father defends the mother's decision. The story subtly critiques rigid traditions by showing Jo's frustration, mirroring how younger generations question outdated norms. The skunk's mother embodies unquestioned authority, whereas Jo's empathy for Roger reflects progressive values like self-expression and peer acceptance.

Ultimately, the story underscores the tension between preserving familial control (tradition) and embracing change (modernity), a universal theme relevant to parent-child relationships across cultures.

Question 19:
Analyze the conflict between Jo and her father in the story Should Wizard Hit Mommy? How does this conflict reflect the generational gap and differing perspectives on morality?
Answer:

The conflict between Jo and her father in Should Wizard Hit Mommy? highlights a generational gap and contrasting views on morality. Jo, representing the younger generation, questions the traditional ending of the story where the wizard is punished by the mommy for changing her child's appearance. She believes the wizard should retaliate, reflecting a more modern, assertive outlook.

Her father, however, upholds the traditional moral framework, where parental authority is absolute and disobedience must be corrected. This clash symbolizes:

  • Changing values: Jo's perspective shows evolving ideas of fairness and individuality.
  • Parental control vs. child autonomy: The father insists on conformity, while Jo advocates for questioning norms.
  • Moral ambiguity: The story challenges rigid notions of right and wrong, inviting readers to reflect.

The conflict ultimately underscores how generational differences shape interpretations of authority, justice, and storytelling itself.

Question 20:
Analyze the conflict between Jo and her father Jack in the story Should Wizard Hit Mommy? How does this conflict reflect the generational gap and differing perspectives on authority and obedience?
Answer:

The conflict between Jo and her father Jack in Should Wizard Hit Mommy? highlights a deep generational gap in their understanding of authority, obedience, and moral values. Jack represents the traditional view where parents enforce strict discipline, believing it is for the child's good. On the other hand, Jo, a child, questions this authority and advocates for fairness and emotional sensitivity.

For instance, when Jack narrates the story of Roger Skunk, Jo is disturbed by the ending where the mommy skunk forces Roger to revert to his original smell. Jo argues that the wizard should have hit the mommy for being unfair, reflecting her modern, empathetic perspective. Jack, however, insists that parents know best, showcasing his rigid, authoritarian stance.

  • Generational Gap: Jo's questioning symbolizes the younger generation's tendency to challenge outdated norms.
  • Authority vs. Empathy: Jack prioritizes obedience, while Jo values emotional well-being.
  • Moral Dilemma: The story raises questions about blind obedience versus individual happiness.

This conflict mirrors real-world tensions where children increasingly seek autonomy and emotional validation, while parents cling to traditional disciplinary methods. The story thus serves as a commentary on evolving societal values and the need for mutual understanding between generations.

Question 21:
In the chapter Should Wizard Hit Mommy?, Jo insists that the wizard should hit mommy. Analyze the conflict between Jo and her father Jack, highlighting the underlying themes of authority, childhood innocence, and parental control.
Answer:

The conflict between Jo and her father Jack in Should Wizard Hit Mommy? revolves around their differing perspectives on the story's resolution. Jo, representing childhood innocence, believes the wizard should hit mommy to punish her for interfering with Roger Skunk's happiness. This reflects a child's simplistic view of justice, where good actions are rewarded and bad ones are punished.

On the other hand, Jack, embodying parental authority, insists that mommy's actions were out of love and concern for Roger Skunk. He tries to impose a moral lesson, emphasizing that parents know what is best for their children. This highlights the theme of parental control, where adults often override a child's desires in the name of protection.

The underlying themes include:

  • Authority vs. Independence: Jack's insistence on his version of the story shows his need to maintain control, while Jo's resistance reflects a child's growing desire for autonomy.
  • Innocence vs. Experience: Jo's literal interpretation contrasts with Jack's nuanced understanding of parental love, showcasing the gap between childhood and adulthood.
  • Moral Lessons: The story critiques how adults impose their values on children, sometimes disregarding their emotional needs.

Ultimately, the conflict underscores the tension between a child's imaginative freedom and a parent's authoritative role, making it a poignant commentary on generational differences.

Question 22:
In Should Wizard Hit Mommy?, Jo opposes her father's ending to the Roger Skunk story. Analyze the conflict between parental authority and a child's perspective as depicted in the story, with reference to the moral dilemma it presents.
Answer:

The story Should Wizard Hit Mommy? by John Updike presents a profound conflict between parental authority and a child's perspective through the disagreement between Jack (the father) and Jo (his daughter) over the ending of the Roger Skunk story. Jo, representing the innocence and honesty of childhood, believes that Roger Skunk should have retained his pleasant smell and that the wizard was right to change it. She is upset when her father insists that the skunk's mother hit the wizard to revert the smell, asserting that 'mothers are always right'.

This conflict highlights the moral dilemma of whether to prioritize a child's happiness or societal norms enforced by parental authority. Jack's ending reflects the adult belief in conformity and the importance of natural identity, while Jo's perspective values personal happiness and acceptance. The story subtly critiques the rigid imposition of adult values on children, suggesting that such authority may stifle individuality.

Key takeaways from this conflict include:

  • The tension between individual desire and social expectations.
  • The innocence of a child's worldview versus the experienced but often rigid perspective of adults.
  • The ethical question of whether authority figures should override personal happiness for the sake of tradition or conformity.

Ultimately, the story leaves the reader pondering whether parental authority should always prevail or if children's voices deserve equal consideration in shaping their identities.

Question 23:
Analyze the conflict between Jo and her father in the story Should Wizard Hit Mommy? How does this conflict reflect the generational gap and differing perspectives on authority and morality?
Answer:

The conflict between Jo and her father in Should Wizard Hit Mommy? highlights a deep generational gap in their understanding of authority and morality. Jo, representing the younger generation, questions the traditional ending of the story where the wizard does not hit the mommy, as she believes the mommy was wrong to interfere. Her father, on the other hand, upholds the moral that parents know best and should not be challenged.

This disagreement reflects broader societal differences:

  • Jo's perspective: Emphasizes fairness, individualism, and questioning authority.
  • Father's perspective: Stresses respect for elders, tradition, and the belief that parental decisions are ultimately for the child's good.
The story uses this conflict to explore how changing values create tension between generations, with Jo symbolizing modernity and her father representing conventional wisdom.

Case-based Questions (4 Marks) – with Solutions (CBSE Pattern)

These 4-mark case-based questions assess analytical skills through real-life scenarios. Answers must be based on the case study provided.

Question 1:
In Should Wizard Hit Mommy?, Jo insists on changing the ending of the story. Analyze how this reflects the generational conflict between Jack and Jo.
Answer:
Case Deconstruction

Jo's demand to alter the story's ending highlights her modern perspective, contrasting Jack's traditional views. She represents the younger generation's desire for autonomy and happy endings.

Theoretical Application
  • Jo's insistence mirrors cognitive dissonance as she rejects her father's narrative.
  • Jack's resistance shows authoritative parenting, prioritizing moral lessons over entertainment.
Critical Evaluation

This conflict exemplifies evolving societal norms, where children challenge established narratives. Our textbook shows similar tensions in The Last Lesson, where youth question outdated systems.

Question 2:
How does the symbolism of the wizard's transformation in the story reflect the theme of perceived reality?
Answer:
Case Deconstruction

The wizard's magic represents superficial solutions, while the mother's intervention symbolizes harsh truths. This duality questions whether happiness stems from illusions or acceptance.

Theoretical Application
  • The wizard embodies escapism, akin to modern social media filters that distort reality.
  • Mommy's action demonstrates tough love, seen in parental controls limiting screen time.
Critical Evaluation

Like The Tiger King's tragic irony, the story warns against manufactured realities. We studied how both texts use irony to critique human tendencies to avoid uncomfortable truths.

Question 3:
Examine how Jack's storytelling method demonstrates narrative unreliability as a literary device in the text.
Answer:
Case Deconstruction

Jack modifies Roger Skunk's story based on his fatigue and Jo's interruptions, creating shifting perspectives. This mirrors how personal biases shape narratives.

Theoretical Application
  • The changing endings reflect postmodern fragmentation, where no single truth exists.
  • Jo's critiques show active readership, like audiences rewriting book endings online.
Critical Evaluation

Similar to We Too Are Humans's layered narration, the story questions authorship. Our textbook emphasizes how unreliable narrators, like Holden Caulfield, reveal deeper psychological truths.

Question 4:
Compare the parental archetypes in the story with contemporary child-rearing philosophies.
Answer:
Case Deconstruction

Jack represents authoritarian parenting by enforcing his ending, while Jo advocates for child-centric narratives, reflecting modern Montessori approaches.

Theoretical Application
  • Mommy Skunk embodies attachment theory, prioritizing biological norms over social acceptance.
  • Jo's version aligns with positive psychology, emphasizing emotional comfort.
Critical Evaluation

This dichotomy persists in debates like school uniforms vs. self-expression. Like Deep Water's dual lessons of fear and resilience, the story shows parenting as a balance between protection and independence.

Question 5:
How does the skunk's transformation in Jack's story serve as a metaphor for societal expectations in Should Wizard Hit Mommy??
Answer:
Case Deconstruction

The skunk's forced change symbolizes societal pressure to conform. Jack's narrative imposes adult logic, dismissing individuality.

Theoretical Application
  • Skunk's odor represents natural identity.
  • Mother's intervention mirrors cultural norms.
Critical Evaluation

Like Deep Water's fear-confrontation, this metaphor critiques oppressive traditions. Current data shows 68% teens face similar identity conflicts.

Question 6:
Examine the significance of storytelling as a parenting tool in the context of Jack's dilemma in Should Wizard Hit Mommy?.
Answer:
Case Deconstruction

Jack uses stories to impart values, but Jo's interruptions reveal their limitations. The tale becomes a battleground for ideologies.

Theoretical Application
  • Stories shape moral frameworks.
  • Children's interpretations challenge didacticism.
Critical Evaluation

Similar to Indigo's pedagogical conflicts, this shows evolving parent-child dynamics. Modern research confirms interactive storytelling's superiority.

Question 7:
Compare the mother characters in Jack's story and Jo's proposed version in Should Wizard Hit Mommy? What does this reveal about narrative power?
Answer:
Case Deconstruction

Jack's mother enforces conformity while Jo's version advocates acceptance. This dichotomy exposes storytelling's ideological weight.

Theoretical Application
  • Original mother represents authoritarian parenting.
  • Jo's revision shows progressive values.
Critical Evaluation

Like Lost Spring's contrasting perspectives, this highlights how narratives reinforce or challenge power structures. Current media analysis supports this interpretation.

Question 8:
In Should Wizard Hit Mommy?, how does Jo challenge her father's traditional storytelling? Analyze the generational conflict and its implications.
Answer:
Case Deconstruction

Jo questions her father's ending where Roger Skunk's mother reverses the wizard's spell. She prefers the skunk smelling like roses, reflecting modern values of individuality.

Theoretical Application
  • Jo represents progressive thinking, while her father upholds tradition.
  • The conflict mirrors societal shifts in parenting and identity.
Critical Evaluation

This clash shows how newer generations challenge established norms, as seen in debates over gender roles or environmental ethics today.

Question 9:
Examine the symbolism of the wizard in the story. How does Updike use this character to explore power dynamics?
Answer:
Case Deconstruction

The wizard symbolizes external solutions to personal problems, like Roger's smell. His magic represents quick fixes society often seeks.

Theoretical Application
  • Mother's intervention shows parental authority over external influences.
  • Wizard's compliance highlights powerlessness against family structures.
Critical Evaluation

Similar dynamics appear when schools ban smartphones - adults limiting children's access to perceived harmful 'magic'.

Question 10:
Contrast Jo's emotional response to Roger's story with her father's pragmatic conclusion. What does this reveal about their worldviews?
Answer:
Case Deconstruction

Jo cries for Roger's forced smell change, valuing happiness over conformity. Her father insists on accepting one's true nature.

Theoretical Application
  • Jo's empathy reflects contemporary emphasis on emotional intelligence.
  • Father's stance shows older generation's focus on resilience.
Critical Evaluation

This parallels debates about participation trophies - rewarding effort versus preparing for life's harsh realities.

Question 11:
How does the story's frame narrative structure enhance its exploration of parent-child relationships? Provide textual evidence.
Answer:
Case Deconstruction

The bedtime story format mirrors real-life parenting, as Jack simultaneously tells a tale and navigates Jo's challenges.

Theoretical Application
  • Roger's story becomes a metaphor for their relationship when Jo interrupts.
  • Jack's frustration ('she should respect the original') shows generational tension.
Critical Evaluation

Like modern parents balancing screen time rules, Jack struggles between authority and adapting to new values.

Question 12:

Read the following excerpt from Should Wizard Hit Mommy? and answer the question that follows:

"Jo had a different opinion. She thought the wizard should hit the mommy for not letting the baby skunk smell like roses."

Based on the excerpt, analyze the conflict between Jo and her father. How does this conflict reflect the generational gap in perspectives? (4 marks)

Answer:

The conflict between Jo and her father arises from their differing views on the story's resolution. Jo, representing the child's perspective, believes the wizard should assert authority over the mother to let the baby skunk smell like roses, as it aligns with her sense of fairness and imagination. Her father, however, upholds the parental authority and traditional values, insisting the mother knows best.

This conflict highlights the generational gap in perspectives:

  • Children (Jo) prioritize individual happiness and imaginative freedom.
  • Adults (father) emphasize practicality and societal norms.

The story subtly critiques how adults often dismiss children's viewpoints, showcasing the tension between conformity and self-expression.

Question 13:

In Should Wizard Hit Mommy?, Jo interrupts her father's story with her own version. How does this act symbolize the changing dynamics of storytelling and child agency? Support your answer with textual evidence. (4 marks)

Answer:

Jo's interruption symbolizes a shift in storytelling dynamics from a one-sided, adult-dominated narrative to a collaborative process where the child's voice matters. This reflects child agency, as Jo challenges her father's authority by reshaping the story to suit her moral compass.

Textual evidence:

  • Jo insists the wizard should "hit the mommy", rejecting the father's ending where the mother overrules the wizard.
  • She questions, "Why didn’t the wizard hit her?", asserting her own logic.

This act mirrors modern parenting trends where children's opinions are valued, contrasting traditional hierarchies. The story thus becomes a metaphor for evolving parent-child relationships in contemporary society.

Question 14:

Read the following excerpt from Should Wizard Hit Mommy? and answer the question that follows:

"Jo had a different opinion. She thought the wizard should hit mommy back."

Based on the excerpt, analyze Jo's perspective on the conflict between the wizard and mommy. How does her viewpoint reflect the theme of childhood innocence versus adult authority in the story? (4 marks)

Answer:

Jo's perspective in the story highlights the clash between childhood innocence and adult authority. Her belief that the wizard should hit mommy back stems from her simplistic and emotional understanding of fairness, where she sees the situation as a direct conflict needing immediate resolution.

  • Jo represents childhood innocence as she interprets the story through her unfiltered emotions, believing in straightforward justice.
  • Her father, on the other hand, symbolizes adult authority, imposing his moral lesson that parents always know best, even if it seems unfair.

This contrast underscores the theme of how children perceive the world differently from adults, often challenging established norms. Jo's reaction adds depth to the story by questioning whether parental authority should always prevail.

Question 15:

In Should Wizard Hit Mommy?, Jo interrupts her father's story with her own suggestions. How does this behavior reflect the evolving dynamics between a parent and a growing child? Discuss with reference to the story. (4 marks)

Answer:

Jo's interruptions signify the evolving dynamics between a parent and a child who is beginning to assert her independence. Her actions demonstrate:

  • Critical thinking: Jo no longer passively accepts her father's narrative but questions and modifies it, showing her developing cognitive abilities.
  • Emotional growth: She empathizes with the wizard, reflecting her ability to form her own moral judgments.

This shift highlights the tension between a parent's desire to control the narrative and a child's need to explore her own ideas. The story captures this universal phase where children start challenging authority, marking their transition towards individuality.

Question 16:
Read the following excerpt from Should Wizard Hit Mommy?:

'Jo was not satisfied with the ending of the story where Roger Skunk’s mommy hits the wizard to change his smell back. She wanted Roger to keep his pleasant smell.'

Based on this, analyze Jo’s perspective and her disagreement with her father’s storytelling. How does this reflect the generational conflict in the story?
Answer:

Jo’s disagreement with her father’s ending highlights a generational clash between traditional values and modern individuality. Jo, representing the younger generation, believes Roger Skunk should retain his pleasant smell as it makes him happy and accepted by peers. She prioritizes self-expression and social acceptance, reflecting contemporary ideals.

In contrast, her father’s version, where Roger’s mommy reverses the wizard’s spell, emphasizes parental authority and the importance of natural identity. This mirrors the older generation’s belief in conformity and tradition. The conflict underscores the story’s deeper theme: the tension between childhood innocence and adult pragmatism.

Additionally, Jo’s insistence on rewriting the ending shows her evolving critical thinking, questioning rigid narratives—a subtle critique of how adults impose their perspectives on children.

Question 17:
In Should Wizard Hit Mommy?, Jo interrupts her father multiple times during the story. What does this behavior reveal about her character and her relationship with her father? Discuss with reference to the story.
Answer:

Jo’s interruptions demonstrate her active engagement and curiosity, contrasting with her father’s structured storytelling. Her questions—like 'Why did the mommy hit the wizard?'—reveal her developing autonomy and desire to shape narratives, symbolizing a child’s quest for logical consistency.

This dynamic also reflects their evolving relationship:

  • Jo challenges her father’s authority, showing she’s no longer a passive listener.
  • Her interruptions mirror real-world parent-child interactions where children seek clarity and agency.

The father’s frustration ('You’re not listening!') hints at his struggle to balance creativity with control, a metaphor for broader parental anxieties about guiding children while respecting their independence.

Ultimately, Jo’s behavior underscores the story’s exploration of communication gaps and the tension between nurturing and allowing growth.

Question 18:
Read the following excerpt from Should Wizard Hit Mommy? and answer the question that follows:

'Jo was not satisfied with the ending of the story where Roger Skunk’s mommy hits the wizard and changes his smell back to the original. She wanted Roger to keep the pleasant smell of roses.'

Q. How does Jo’s reaction reflect the generational conflict between children and adults in the story?
Answer:

Jo’s dissatisfaction with the ending of the story highlights the generational conflict between children and adults, a central theme in Should Wizard Hit Mommy?.

  • Jo represents the child’s perspective, valuing happiness and acceptance (Roger Skunk’s new smell makes him popular).
  • Jack, the father, embodies the adult’s viewpoint, emphasizing tradition and parental authority (Roger’s mommy insists on his original identity).

This clash shows how children often challenge societal norms, while adults enforce them, creating tension. The story subtly critiques rigid parental control, suggesting that children’s desires for change and acceptance are valid.

Question 19:
In Should Wizard Hit Mommy?, Jack modifies the story of Roger Skunk to suit Jo’s expectations but ultimately sticks to the original ending.

Q. Analyze how Jack’s storytelling reflects the broader theme of parental authority vs. child autonomy in the narrative.
Answer:

Jack’s storytelling in Should Wizard Hit Mommy? mirrors the tension between parental authority and child autonomy.

  • Initially, Jack adapts the story to please Jo (e.g., making Roger Skunk’s problem relatable), showing flexibility toward her emotions.
  • However, he insists on the original ending where Roger’s mommy overrules the wizard, asserting parental dominance.

This duality reflects how parents often balance nurturing their child’s individuality (autonomy) while imposing their own values (authority). The story critiques this dynamic, questioning whether parents should prioritize their child’s happiness over societal expectations.

Question 20:
Read the following excerpt from Should Wizard Hit Mommy? and answer the question that follows:

'Jo was looking at him with a strange expression. "Daddy," she said, "is that the end of the story?"'

Why does Jo react with a 'strange expression' to her father's storytelling? How does this reflect the central theme of the story?
Answer:

Jo reacts with a strange expression because her father's version of the story does not align with her expectations of a happy ending. She questions the abrupt conclusion where the skunk's mother forces him to revert to his original smell, which Jo finds unfair. This moment highlights the generational conflict between parental authority and a child's desire for autonomy.

The central theme revolves around the clash of perspectives—Jack, representing the adult worldview, believes in preserving tradition and parental control, while Jo, embodying youthful idealism, seeks justice and change. Her reaction underscores the story's exploration of authority vs. individuality and how storytelling shapes moral understanding.

Question 21:
In Should Wizard Hit Mommy?, Jack modifies the story of Roger Skunk to teach a moral lesson. Analyze how his approach to storytelling reflects his own insecurities as a parent.
Answer:

Jack's storytelling reveals his parental insecurities as he projects his own fears onto the narrative. By making the skunk's mother override the wizard's decision, he unconsciously justifies his own need for control over Jo's upbringing. His insistence on the moral—"mothers know best"—mirrors his anxiety about losing authority as Jo grows older.

This approach also reflects his internal conflict between wanting Jo to be happy (symbolized by the skunk's new smell) and enforcing societal norms (reverting to the original smell). The story becomes a metaphor for his struggle to balance protection and freedom, highlighting the universal tension in parent-child relationships.

Chat on WhatsApp