Online Self Test
Learn & Practice Quizzes & Challenges Competitive Exams
 

The Enemy – CBSE NCERT Study Resources

Previous ChapterNext Chapter
Previous Chapter Next Chapter

Study Materials

12th

12th - English

The Enemy

Jump to Question Sets

Overview of the Chapter

"The Enemy" is a chapter from the CBSE Grade 12 English textbook that explores themes of humanity, conflict, and moral dilemmas. The story is set during World War II and revolves around Dr. Sadao, a Japanese surgeon, who faces a difficult choice when he discovers an injured American soldier on the shore near his home. The narrative delves into the conflict between duty, patriotism, and compassion.

Key Theme: The struggle between personal ethics and national loyalty.

Summary

The chapter begins with Dr. Sadao Hoki, a skilled Japanese surgeon, living with his wife Hana in a coastal house. One evening, they find an unconscious American soldier washed ashore, severely wounded. Despite the risk of being branded traitors, they decide to shelter and treat him due to their medical ethics. The story highlights their internal conflict—balancing their hatred for the enemy with their professional duty to save lives.

Moral Dilemma: Choosing between humanity and patriotism.

Characters

  • Dr. Sadao Hoki: A Japanese surgeon torn between his duty as a doctor and loyalty to his country.
  • Hana: Dr. Sadao's wife, who supports him but is fearful of the consequences.
  • The American Soldier (Tom): An injured enemy combatant whose life Dr. Sadao saves.

Key Takeaways

  • The story emphasizes the importance of humanity over political conflicts.
  • It questions blind nationalism and highlights the moral responsibilities of individuals.
  • The narrative showcases the psychological turmoil faced by those in war-torn societies.

Symbolism: The ocean represents the blurred lines between enemies and humanity.

All Question Types with Solutions – CBSE Exam Pattern

Explore a complete set of CBSE-style questions with detailed solutions, categorized by marks and question types. Ideal for exam preparation, revision and practice.

Very Short Answer (1 Mark) – with Solutions (CBSE Pattern)

These are 1-mark questions requiring direct, concise answers. Ideal for quick recall and concept clarity.

Question 1:
What is the central conflict in The Enemy?
Answer:

The clash between duty and humanity when Dr. Sadao helps an enemy soldier.

Question 2:
How does Dr. Sadao initially react to finding the wounded soldier?
Answer:

He hesitates due to the soldier's enemy status but chooses to treat him.

Question 3:
Why does Hana assist Dr. Sadao despite her fears?
Answer:

She respects her husband's professionalism and shares his moral dilemma.

Question 4:
What symbolizes the internal struggle in the story?
Answer:

The stormy sea mirrors Dr. Sadao's turbulent emotions.

Question 5:
How does the General react to Dr. Sadao's confession?
Answer:

He avoids taking action, prioritizing his personal health over duty.

Question 6:
What is the significance of the surgical tools in the story?
Answer:

They represent Dr. Sadao's commitment to healing over nationalism.

Question 7:
How does Yumi’s refusal to wash the soldier highlight cultural tensions?
Answer:

It shows her loyalty to Japan over humanitarian concerns.

Question 8:
What role does nature play in the narrative?
Answer:

The isolated beach setting emphasizes secrecy and moral isolation.

Question 9:
Why does Dr. Sadao ultimately help the soldier escape?
Answer:

His conscience overrides his patriotic duty.

Question 10:
How does Pearl S. Buck portray ethical dilemmas in the story?
Answer:

Through contrasting characters' reactions to the wounded enemy.

Question 11:
What does the soldier's disappearance signify?
Answer:

Dr. Sadao's successful resolution of his moral conflict.

Question 12:
How is irony used in The Enemy?
Answer:

The General's selfishness contrasts with Dr. Sadao's selfless act.

Question 13:
Who is the author of the chapter The Enemy?
Answer:

The chapter The Enemy is written by Pearl S. Buck, an American writer and Nobel Prize winner.

Question 14:
What is the nationality of the wounded soldier in The Enemy?
Answer:

The wounded soldier in The Enemy is an American prisoner of war during World War II.

Question 15:
Name the Japanese doctor who helps the enemy soldier in The Enemy.
Answer:

The Japanese doctor who helps the enemy soldier is Dr. Sadao Hoki.

Question 16:
Why does Dr. Sadao hesitate to help the wounded soldier initially?
Answer:

Dr. Sadao hesitates because the soldier is an enemy of Japan, and helping him could be seen as treason.

Question 17:
What role does Hana play in The Enemy?
Answer:

Hana, Dr. Sadao's wife, assists him in nursing the wounded soldier and faces societal pressure for helping an enemy.

Question 18:
How does Dr. Sadao's profession conflict with his patriotism in The Enemy?
Answer:

As a doctor, he is bound by ethics to save lives, but as a patriot, he is expected to reject the enemy, creating a moral dilemma.

Question 19:
What is the significance of the title The Enemy?
Answer:

The title highlights the irony of human conflict, where an enemy is also a helpless human needing compassion.

Question 20:
How does the General react to Dr. Sadao's actions in The Enemy?
Answer:

The General ignores the situation, prioritizing his own need for Dr. Sadao's medical skills over national loyalty.

Question 21:
What internal conflict does Dr. Sadao face in The Enemy?
Answer:

He struggles between his duty as a doctor to save lives and his duty as a citizen to report the enemy.

Question 22:
How does the wounded soldier repay Dr. Sadao's kindness?
Answer:

The soldier escapes quietly, ensuring Dr. Sadao is not punished for helping him.

Question 23:
What societal pressures do Dr. Sadao and Hana face in The Enemy?
Answer:

They face ostracization and accusations of betrayal for aiding an enemy soldier.

Question 24:
What theme does The Enemy primarily explore?
Answer:

The chapter explores the humanity beyond war, emphasizing compassion over political divisions.

Very Short Answer (2 Marks) – with Solutions (CBSE Pattern)

These 2-mark questions test key concepts in a brief format. Answers are expected to be accurate and slightly descriptive.

Question 1:
Why did Dr. Sadao hesitate to treat the American prisoner initially?
Answer:

Dr. Sadao hesitated because the man was an enemy soldier during World War II, and helping him could be seen as treason. He was torn between his professional ethics as a doctor and his national loyalty as a Japanese citizen.

Question 2:
How did Hana react when she first saw the wounded American soldier?
Answer:

Hana was initially shocked and fearful because the soldier was an enemy. However, her compassion overcame her fear, and she assisted Dr. Sadao in treating him, showing her humanitarian side.

Question 3:
What role did the servants play in the story 'The Enemy'?
Answer:

The servants were uncomfortable with harboring an enemy soldier and eventually left the house in protest. Their departure highlighted the social and cultural tensions during wartime.

Question 4:
Why did Dr. Sadao not turn the American soldier over to the authorities immediately?
Answer:

Dr. Sadao believed in his duty as a doctor to save lives, regardless of nationality. He also feared the soldier would be executed if handed over, which conflicted with his moral principles.

Question 5:
How did General Takima influence Dr. Sadao's decision regarding the prisoner?
Answer:

General Takima, being a patient of Dr. Sadao, assured him that he would send assassins to kill the prisoner secretly. This gave Dr. Sadao temporary relief but also exposed the hypocrisy and moral ambiguity of war.

Question 6:
What internal conflict did Dr. Sadao face in 'The Enemy'?
Answer:

Dr. Sadao struggled between his loyalty to Japan and his ethical duty as a healer. His conflict represents the broader tension between nationalism and humanism during war.

Question 7:
How does the story 'The Enemy' highlight the theme of humanity?
Answer:

The story shows that compassion transcends national boundaries. Despite the war, Dr. Sadao and Hana chose to help the wounded soldier, emphasizing the universal value of human life.

Question 8:
What was the significance of the storm in the story 'The Enemy'?
Answer:

The storm symbolized the turmoil in Dr. Sadao's mind and the chaos of war. It also created an opportunity for the American soldier to escape, resolving the central conflict.

Question 9:
How did Dr. Sadao ensure the American soldier's escape?
Answer:

Dr. Sadao provided the soldier with a boat, food, and directions to a nearby uninhabited island. He also instructed him to signal a Korean fishing boat for rescue, ensuring his safe passage.

Question 10:
What does the ending of 'The Enemy' suggest about Dr. Sadao's character?
Answer:

The ending shows Dr. Sadao as a man of integrity and compassion, who prioritized humanity over war. His actions reflect his belief in moral duty beyond political divisions.

Question 11:
How does 'The Enemy' critique the concept of nationalism?
Answer:

The story questions blind nationalism by contrasting Dr. Sadao's humanitarian actions with the rigid wartime ideologies. It suggests that humanity should prevail over political conflicts.

Short Answer (3 Marks) – with Solutions (CBSE Pattern)

These 3-mark questions require brief explanations and help assess understanding and application of concepts.

Question 1:
How does Dr. Sadao demonstrate conflict of duty in The Enemy?
Answer:

Dr. Sadao faces a moral dilemma between his professional duty as a doctor to save lives and his patriotic duty as a Japanese citizen during wartime.
He chooses humanity over nationalism by treating the wounded American soldier, showcasing the universal ethics of medical practice.
This conflict highlights the complexity of human emotions and the struggle between personal values and societal expectations.

Question 2:
Explain the significance of the garden in The Enemy.
Answer:

The garden symbolizes tranquility and isolation in Dr. Sadao's life, reflecting his inner turmoil.
It serves as a metaphor for his secluded existence, away from the chaos of war.
The meticulous care he gives to the garden mirrors his precision as a surgeon and his desire for control amidst external conflicts.

Question 3:
How does Hana's character evolve in The Enemy?
Answer:

Hana transitions from a traditional obedient wife to a compassionate and independent individual.
Her initial hesitation in helping the enemy soldier gives way to empathy, showcasing her moral growth.
She challenges societal norms by supporting Dr. Sadao's decision, reflecting her strength and humanity.

Question 4:
What role does the General play in the story The Enemy?
Answer:

The General represents the authority and political pressures of wartime Japan.
His dependence on Dr. Sadao for medical care creates a power dynamic, where he reluctantly tolerates the doctor's actions.
His eventual inaction to arrest the soldier exposes the hypocrisy of war and the fragility of loyalty.

Question 5:
Analyze the theme of prejudice in The Enemy.
Answer:

The story explores prejudice through the initial hostility toward the American soldier due to wartime animosity.
Dr. Sadao and Hana overcome their biases by recognizing the soldier's shared humanity.
This theme critiques the irrationality of hatred and emphasizes compassion over divisive ideologies.

Question 6:
How does the setting of The Enemy contribute to its central conflict?
Answer:

The isolated coastal house intensifies the claustrophobic tension between safety and danger.
The wartime backdrop of Japan-America hostilities heightens the stakes of harboring an enemy.
The setting mirrors the psychological isolation of the characters, trapped between duty and conscience.

Question 7:
How does Dr. Sadao’s internal conflict reflect the theme of humanity versus duty in The Enemy?
Answer:

Dr. Sadao faces a moral dilemma between his professional duty as a doctor to save lives and his patriotic duty as a Japanese citizen during wartime. His internal conflict highlights the struggle between humanity (compassion for the wounded American soldier) and duty (loyalty to his nation). Despite societal pressure, he chooses humanity, showcasing the supremacy of ethical values over blind nationalism.

Question 8:
Explain the significance of the storm in The Enemy as a literary device.
Answer:

The storm symbolizes the turmoil in Dr. Sadao’s mind and the chaos of war. It acts as a plot device, bringing the wounded soldier to his doorstep and intensifying the conflict. The storm also mirrors the emotional turbulence of the characters, foreshadowing the challenges ahead. Nature’s unpredictability parallels the unpredictability of human choices in the story.

Question 9:
How does Hana’s character evolve in The Enemy?
Answer:

Hana transitions from a traditional, obedient wife to a compassionate and independent woman. Initially hesitant, she overcomes her fear and assists Dr. Sadao in treating the enemy soldier, displaying empathy and courage. Her evolution underscores the theme of humanity transcending societal norms. Her actions challenge gender stereotypes, making her a pivotal character in the narrative.

Question 10:
Analyze the role of the General’s messenger in advancing the plot of The Enemy.
Answer:

The General’s messenger acts as a catalyst, creating suspense and tension. His repeated visits heighten the risk of Dr. Sadao’s secret being exposed. The messenger’s presence reinforces the political pressure and the consequences of harboring an enemy. Ultimately, his failure to act reflects the corruption and inefficiency within the system, allowing the story’s resolution.

Question 11:
Discuss the symbolism of the island setting in The Enemy.
Answer:

The isolated island symbolizes Dr. Sadao’s emotional and moral isolation from society. It represents a microcosm of the larger world at war, where conflicts between loyalty and ethics play out. The island’s seclusion also emphasizes the clash between personal conscience and societal expectations, making it a critical backdrop for the story’s central conflict.

Question 12:
How does Pearl S. Buck use irony in The Enemy to critique war?
Answer:

The story employs situational irony when Dr. Sadao, a Japanese doctor, saves an American enemy, while his own countrymen would have killed the soldier. This irony critiques the absurdity of war, where humanity is often overshadowed by hatred. The General’s inaction despite his power further underscores the hypocrisy and futility of wartime ideologies, making the narrative a powerful anti-war statement.

Long Answer (5 Marks) – with Solutions (CBSE Pattern)

These 5-mark questions are descriptive and require detailed, structured answers with proper explanation and examples.

Question 1:
Analyze how Dr. Sadao Hoki’s internal conflict in The Enemy reflects the ethical dilemmas of war. Support your answer with textual evidence.
Answer:
Theoretical Framework

Dr. Sadao faces a moral conflict between his duty as a doctor and loyalty to his nation during wartime. Our textbook shows how his humanitarian instincts clash with patriotism.

Evidence Analysis
  • He shelters the enemy soldier despite risks: "He could not kill the man".
  • His wife Hana questions: "Are we betraying Japan?", highlighting societal pressure.
Critical Evaluation

This mirrors universal ethical struggles in war, where individual conscience battles collective duty. Pearl Buck critiques blind nationalism through Sadao’s actions.

Question 2:
Discuss the symbolism of the seaside setting in The Enemy and its connection to the theme of isolation.
Answer:
Theoretical Framework

The isolated beach represents Dr. Sadao’s psychological and moral separation from society. Our textbook emphasizes how geography mirrors mental states.

Evidence Analysis
  • The "solitary house" underscores his alienation when hiding the American.
  • Stormy waves reflect turmoil: "The sea roared" during critical decisions.
Critical Evaluation

Buck uses pathetic fallacy to show how war isolates individuals from communities. The sea becomes both barrier and connection to humanity.

Question 3:
Examine how Hana’s character challenges traditional gender roles in 1940s Japanese society as depicted in The Enemy.
Answer:
Theoretical Framework

Hana subverts expectations by actively participating in the soldier’s care rather than passive obedience. Our textbook contrasts her with stereotypical war-era women.

Evidence Analysis
  • She assists surgery: "She had never seen an operation" but learns quickly.
  • Her defiance: "I will not tell" shows autonomy.
Critical Evaluation

Buck portrays Hana as transitional feminist figure, balancing duty and rebellion. Her evolution parallels Japan’s postwar social changes.

Question 4:
Evaluate the significance of the title The Enemy in context of the story’s exploration of humanity versus nationalism.
Answer:
Theoretical Framework

The title’s irony lies in questioning who the real 'enemy' is - the wounded soldier or societal prejudices. Our textbook highlights this central paradox.

Evidence Analysis
  • The General calls Americans "enemies", yet seeks Sadao’s medical expertise.
  • Sadao realizes: "The man was simply a wounded human".
Critical Evaluation

Buck deconstructs war propaganda by showing shared humanity transcends political labels. The title becomes a moral question rather than statement.

Question 5:
Compare the General’s and Dr. Sadao’s perspectives on war in The Enemy, using specific examples.
Answer:
Theoretical Framework

The General represents militaristic nationalism while Sadao embodies humanist ethics. Our textbook contrasts these worldviews through their dialogues.

Evidence Analysis
  • General prioritizes duty: "A Japanese should not save an enemy".
  • Sadao argues: "I am trained to save life", valuing Hippocratic oath.
Critical Evaluation

Their ideological clash reflects postwar Japan’s conflict between tradition and modernization. Buck suggests medical ethics should supersede political divisions.

Question 6:
Analyze the moral dilemma faced by Dr. Sadao in the chapter The Enemy. How does his internal conflict reflect the theme of humanity versus patriotism?
Answer:

Dr. Sadao faces a profound moral dilemma when he discovers an injured American soldier, who is technically his enemy, washed ashore. His internal conflict arises from his dual roles as a skilled surgeon bound by the Hippocratic Oath to save lives and as a loyal Japanese citizen during wartime. The tension between humanity and patriotism is central to the story.

On one hand, Dr. Sadao feels compelled to help the wounded soldier due to his professional ethics and innate human compassion. He risks his own safety and reputation by sheltering the enemy, showcasing his commitment to universal humanity. On the other hand, his patriotic duty demands that he report the soldier to the authorities, as failing to do so could brand him a traitor.

The resolution of his conflict—choosing to save the soldier’s life while ensuring his escape—highlights the supremacy of human values over blind nationalism. This aligns with the author’s message that compassion transcends political boundaries, making the story a powerful commentary on war and humanity.

Question 7:
Discuss the significance of the setting in The Enemy. How does the isolated coastal location contribute to the story's tension and themes?
Answer:

The setting of The Enemy—a secluded coastal house in Japan during World War II—plays a crucial role in amplifying the story's tension and reinforcing its themes. The isolation of Dr. Sadao's home mirrors his emotional and moral isolation as he grapples with his decision to help the enemy soldier. The vast, unpredictable ocean symbolizes the uncontrollable forces of war and fate, which bring the wounded American to his doorstep.

The coastal setting also intensifies the suspense and danger. The constant sound of waves and the proximity to the sea create a sense of vulnerability, as the soldier could be discovered at any moment. This geographical isolation forces Dr. Sadao to rely solely on his own judgment, heightening the stakes of his moral choice.

Furthermore, the setting underscores the theme of universal humanity. Despite being in a war-torn nation, the ocean serves as a neutral, boundary-less space, reminding readers that suffering and compassion are universal. The contrast between the peaceful natural surroundings and the brutality of war deepens the story's emotional impact, making Dr. Sadao's act of kindness even more poignant.

Question 8:
Analyze the moral dilemma faced by Dr. Sadao in the chapter The Enemy. How does his internal conflict reflect the broader theme of humanity versus patriotism?
Answer:

Dr. Sadao faces a profound moral dilemma when he discovers an injured American soldier, who is technically his enemy, washed ashore near his home. His conflict arises from the clash between his professional ethics as a doctor and his national loyalty as a Japanese citizen during wartime.

On one hand, his medical training compels him to save a life regardless of the patient's nationality, embodying the Hippocratic Oath. On the other hand, aiding an enemy soldier could be seen as treason, putting his family and himself at risk.

This internal struggle highlights the broader theme of humanity versus patriotism. Dr. Sadao's ultimate decision to prioritize human life over blind nationalism underscores the universal value of compassion. The chapter critiques the rigid boundaries of war, suggesting that empathy and ethics should transcend political divisions.

Pearl S. Buck uses this conflict to question the cost of war on individual morality, making the story timeless and deeply humanistic.

Question 9:
Discuss the significance of the setting in The Enemy. How does the isolated coastal location contribute to the story's tension and thematic depth?
Answer:

The setting of The Enemy—a secluded coastal house in Japan during World War II—plays a pivotal role in amplifying the story's tension and themes. The isolation of Dr. Sadao's home mirrors his emotional and moral isolation as he grapples with his decision to help the enemy soldier.

The coastal location symbolizes the boundary between two worlds: the safety of land (representing Japan) and the unpredictable sea (representing the unknown or the enemy). This duality reflects Dr. Sadao's inner conflict between duty and humanity.

Additionally, the setting heightens suspense. The constant threat of discovery by authorities or neighbors creates a claustrophobic atmosphere, making the reader question whether Dr. Sadao's secret will be exposed.

Thematically, the setting reinforces the idea that moral choices are often made in solitude, away from societal pressures. It also underscores the irony that war's divisions are man-made, while nature (the sea) remains indifferent, serving as a silent witness to human struggles.

Question 10:
Discuss the theme of humanity versus duty in the chapter The Enemy. How does Dr. Sadao's internal conflict reflect this theme? Support your answer with textual evidence.
Answer:

The chapter The Enemy by Pearl S. Buck explores the profound conflict between humanity and duty through the character of Dr. Sadao. As a skilled Japanese surgeon during World War II, Sadao faces a moral dilemma when he discovers an injured American soldier, who is technically his enemy, washed ashore near his home.

Dr. Sadao's internal conflict arises from his professional oath as a doctor, which compels him to save lives, and his national duty as a Japanese citizen, which demands loyalty to his country. The text highlights this when Sadao says, 'What am I to do?', showcasing his turmoil. Despite the risks, he chooses humanity over duty, operating on the soldier and saving his life. This decision reflects the universal value of compassion transcending political boundaries.

Buck uses Sadao's actions to critique the rigid notions of patriotism and war, emphasizing that human life holds greater significance. The soldier's eventual escape, facilitated by Sadao, further underscores the triumph of individual conscience over societal expectations.

Question 11:
Analyze the role of Hana in The Enemy. How does her character contribute to the development of the plot and the central themes of the story?
Answer:

Hana, Dr. Sadao's wife, plays a pivotal role in The Enemy by acting as both a supportive partner and a moral compass. Her character amplifies the story's central themes of compassion, fear, and cultural conflict.

Initially, Hana is hesitant about helping the American soldier due to the potential consequences. However, she overcomes her fear and assists Sadao in nursing the enemy, demonstrating her growth from apprehension to empathy. For instance, she tends to the soldier's wounds and even dismisses the uncooperative maid, showing her resolve.

Hana's interactions with the soldier humanize him, breaking the stereotype of the 'enemy.' Her internal struggle mirrors Sadao's, reinforcing the theme of moral ambiguity in wartime. Additionally, her presence adds emotional depth to the narrative, as her fears about their safety create tension and urgency in the plot.

Ultimately, Hana's character underscores the idea that humanity and kindness can prevail even in the darkest times, making her an essential figure in the story's progression.

Question 12:
Discuss the significance of the setting in The Enemy. How does the isolated coastal location contribute to the story’s tension and themes?
Answer:

The setting of The Enemy—a secluded coastal house in Japan during World War II—plays a crucial role in amplifying the story’s tension and themes. The isolation of Dr. Sadao’s home mirrors his emotional and moral isolation as he grapples with his decision to help the enemy soldier.

  • The coastal location symbolizes the boundary between nations and ideologies, emphasizing the soldier’s unexpected intrusion into Dr. Sadao’s life.
  • The remoteness of the house heightens the suspense, as it becomes a secret refuge for the soldier, away from prying eyes and military authorities.
  • The stormy sea and harsh weather reflect the turmoil within Dr. Sadao’s conscience, torn between duty and compassion.

Additionally, the setting underscores the theme of universal humanity, as the vast, indifferent ocean contrasts with the intimate, personal struggle of the characters. The coastal backdrop thus serves as both a literal and metaphorical space where moral choices are tested, making it integral to the narrative’s impact.

Question 13:
In the chapter The Enemy, Dr. Sadao faces a moral dilemma when he decides to help the wounded American soldier. Discuss how his actions reflect the conflict between professional duty and personal loyalty to his country. Support your answer with instances from the text.
Answer:

In The Enemy, Dr. Sadao's actions highlight a profound conflict between his professional duty as a doctor and his personal loyalty to Japan during wartime. As a skilled surgeon, he is bound by the Hippocratic Oath to save lives, regardless of the patient's nationality. However, as a Japanese citizen, aiding an enemy soldier is considered treasonous.

One key instance is when Dr. Sadao finds the wounded American soldier on the beach. Despite recognizing him as the enemy, his medical instincts compel him to provide immediate care. He says, 'What are we to do with this man?', showing his internal struggle. His wife, Hana, also questions the risk, but Sadao insists, 'But if I don’t operate, he’ll die.'

Another critical moment is when Sadao hides the soldier in his home and tends to his wounds secretly, knowing the consequences if discovered. He rationalizes his actions by thinking, 'The man is a prisoner of war, but he is also a human being.' This reflects his commitment to humanity over nationalism.

Ultimately, Sadao's dilemma is resolved when he helps the soldier escape, prioritizing his professional duty to preserve life. The story underscores the universal ethical principle that humanity transcends political boundaries, a theme central to the chapter.

Question 14:
Discuss the theme of humanity versus duty in the chapter The Enemy by Pearl S. Buck, highlighting how Dr. Sadao's actions reflect this conflict.
Answer:

The chapter The Enemy by Pearl S. Buck explores the profound conflict between humanity and duty through the character of Dr. Sadao. As a skilled Japanese surgeon during World War II, Dr. Sadao faces a moral dilemma when he discovers an injured American soldier, who is technically his enemy, washed ashore near his home.

On one hand, his duty as a loyal Japanese citizen demands that he report the enemy soldier to the authorities, ensuring national security. However, his humanity as a doctor compels him to save the man's life, as he is bound by the Hippocratic Oath to treat anyone in need, regardless of their nationality or allegiance.

Dr. Sadao's internal struggle is evident in his actions:

  • He initially hesitates but ultimately decides to operate on the soldier, showcasing his commitment to medical ethics.
  • He risks his own safety and reputation by hiding the soldier in his house, demonstrating compassion.
  • He eventually helps the soldier escape, prioritizing human life over wartime animosity.

This conflict underscores the universal tension between personal ethics and societal expectations. Dr. Sadao's choice to prioritize humanity over duty highlights the idea that compassion can transcend political and national boundaries. The chapter thus serves as a powerful commentary on the importance of empathy and moral courage in times of conflict.

Question 15:
In the chapter The Enemy, Dr. Sadao faces a moral dilemma when he decides to help the wounded enemy soldier. Discuss how his internal conflict reflects the broader theme of humanity versus patriotism in the story. Support your answer with textual evidence.
Answer:

In The Enemy, Dr. Sadao's internal conflict is a powerful exploration of the tension between humanity and patriotism. As a skilled Japanese surgeon during World War II, he is torn between his duty to his country and his ethical obligation as a doctor to save a life. The wounded American soldier, an enemy of Japan, represents this dilemma.

Dr. Sadao's struggle is evident when he thinks, "He could not kill the man. That would be murder." This highlights his commitment to medical ethics over blind nationalism. However, his loyalty to Japan also weighs heavily on him, as he fears being labeled a traitor. The story underscores that true humanity transcends borders, as seen when Hana, his wife, also empathizes with the soldier despite societal pressures.

Pearl S. Buck uses this conflict to critique the absurdity of war, where compassion becomes a casualty. Dr. Sadao's ultimate decision to help the soldier escape reflects the triumph of humanity over rigid patriotism, making the story a timeless commentary on moral choices in times of conflict.

Case-based Questions (4 Marks) – with Solutions (CBSE Pattern)

These 4-mark case-based questions assess analytical skills through real-life scenarios. Answers must be based on the case study provided.

Question 1:
In The Enemy, Dr. Sadao faces a moral dilemma when he discovers the wounded American soldier. Analyze how his professional ethics conflict with his national loyalty.
Answer:
Case Deconstruction

Dr. Sadao, a skilled Japanese surgeon, finds an injured enemy soldier. His medical training compels him to save lives, but his patriotism demands he report the soldier. Our textbook shows his internal struggle as he weighs Hippocratic Oath against wartime duty.

Theoretical Application
  • Hippocratic Oath: Doctors must treat all patients equally
  • Nationalism: Citizens must prioritize their country during war
Critical Evaluation

His final decision to operate demonstrates how professional ethics can supersede political boundaries. This mirrors real-world cases like battlefield medics treating enemy combatants.

Question 2:
Examine the symbolic significance of the ocean and storm in The Enemy. How do these natural elements reflect Dr. Sadao's psychological state?
Answer:
Case Deconstruction

The turbulent ocean represents Dr. Sadao's conflicted mind when he first spots the wounded soldier. Our textbook describes the storm as mirroring his emotional turmoil about helping an enemy.

Theoretical Application
  • Ocean: Vastness of moral choices
  • Storm: Chaos of wartime ethics
Critical Evaluation

Pearl Buck uses pathetic fallacy effectively. When the sea calms later, it parallels Dr. Sadao's resolved decision, similar to Shakespeare's storm symbolism in King Lear.

Question 3:
Contrast Hana's and the servants' reactions to the American soldier in The Enemy. What does this reveal about societal conditioning versus personal morality?
Answer:
Case Deconstruction

Hana assists her husband despite fear, while the servants abandon them. Our textbook shows this highlights different responses to wartime prejudice.

Theoretical Application
  • Servants: Represent societal hatred for enemies
  • Hana: Shows individual compassion can overcome propaganda
Critical Evaluation

This dichotomy mirrors modern cases like citizens hiding refugees despite government policies. The servants' departure emphasizes how war dehumanizes the 'other'.

Question 4:
Evaluate the ending of The Enemy where Dr. Sadao helps the soldier escape. Does this represent cowardice or heroism? Support your answer with textual evidence.
Answer:
Case Deconstruction

The ambiguous ending shows Dr. Sadao arranging the soldier's escape. Our textbook describes his mixed relief and lingering fear about consequences.

Theoretical Application
  • Heroism: Risking himself to uphold medical ethics
  • Cowardice: Avoiding full responsibility for his actions
Critical Evaluation

Like Atticus Finch in To Kill a Mockingbird, his choice challenges societal norms. The open-ended conclusion invites readers to debate moral complexity in war.

Question 5:
Analyze how Dr. Sadao’s internal conflict in 'The Enemy' reflects the ethical dilemmas faced by professionals during wartime. Provide textual evidence.
Answer:
Case Deconstruction

Dr. Sadao faces a moral dilemma when he discovers an injured American soldier. His duty as a doctor conflicts with his loyalty to Japan during WWII. The line, 'He could not kill the man outright,' highlights his struggle.

Theoretical Application
  • Ethical principles like Hippocratic Oath demand impartial care.
  • Nationalistic pressures create cognitive dissonance.
Critical Evaluation

Pearl S. Buck critiques war’s dehumanization through Sadao’s actions. His final decision to aid escape mirrors universal humanity over patriotism.

Question 6:
Contrast the symbolism of the ocean and garden in 'The Enemy' to explain their role in the protagonist’s psychological journey.
Answer:
Case Deconstruction

The ocean represents danger and the unknown, as seen when the soldier washes ashore. The garden, tended by Hana, symbolizes control and cultural identity.

Theoretical Application
  • Ocean as liminal space between life/death.
  • Garden reflects Japanese aesthetics (wabi-sabi).
Critical Evaluation

Buck uses these symbols to parallel Sadao’s turmoil: the ocean’s chaos versus the garden’s order mirrors his clash of duties.

Question 7:
Evaluate how Hana’s character challenges traditional gender roles in 1940s Japan, citing two instances from the text.
Answer:
Case Deconstruction

Hana assists in surgery despite societal norms, shown when she 'held the ether cone' fearlessly. Later, she argues with Sadao about the soldier’s fate, asserting her agency.

Theoretical Application
  • Subverts ie system by sharing decision-making.
  • Embodies ryōsai kenbo (good wife, wise mother) paradox.
Critical Evaluation

Buck portrays Hana as a bridge between tradition and modernity, using her to critique patriarchal wartime narratives.

Question 8:
Discuss the significance of the title 'The Enemy' in the context of the story’s exploration of humanity versus nationalism.
Answer:
Case Deconstruction

The title initially refers to the American soldier but becomes ironic as Sadao realizes the true 'enemy' is war itself. The soldier’s humanity dismantles prejudice.

Theoretical Application
  • Title mirrors Othering theory in conflict.
  • Juxtaposes jus in bello (war ethics) with compassion.
Critical Evaluation

Buck’s choice critiques dehumanizing propaganda, showing how labels collapse when faced with individual suffering.

Question 9:
In The Enemy, Dr. Sadao faces a moral dilemma when he finds an injured enemy soldier. Analyze how his professional ethics conflict with his national loyalty.
Answer:
Case Deconstruction

Dr. Sadao, a skilled surgeon, is torn between his Hippocratic oath to save lives and his duty as a Japanese citizen during wartime. The injured American soldier represents the enemy, yet his medical training compels him to provide care.

Theoretical Application
  • Hippocratic Oath vs. Patriotism: His profession demands neutrality, but nationalism expects allegiance.
  • Humanitarian Ethics: Sadao’s internal struggle reflects universal moral principles.
Critical Evaluation

His eventual decision to prioritize humanity over war illustrates the complexity of ethical choices. The text highlights how personal conscience can challenge societal norms.

Question 10:
Contrast the reactions of Hana and the servants toward the wounded soldier in The Enemy. What societal biases does their behavior reveal?
Answer:
Case Deconstruction

Hana, though fearful, assists Dr. Sadao, while the servants refuse to touch the American, calling him a 'devil.' Their contrasting responses expose deep-seated wartime prejudices.

Theoretical Application
  • Hana’s Reluctant Empathy: She overcomes initial disgust, showing moral growth.
  • Servants’ Dehumanization: Their refusal reflects propaganda-fueled hatred.
Critical Evaluation

The divide underscores how war manipulates perceptions. Pearl Buck critiques blind nationalism through these reactions, emphasizing shared humanity.

Question 11:
Explain the symbolism of the storm and isolated house in The Enemy. How do these elements amplify the story’s tension?
Answer:
Case Deconstruction

The storm mirrors Dr. Sadao’s inner turmoil, while the isolated house represents his moral seclusion from society. Both elements heighten the suspense of harboring an enemy.

Theoretical Application
  • Pathetic Fallacy: The storm externalizes Sadao’s conflict.
  • Isolation as Metaphor: The house reflects his ethical solitude.
Critical Evaluation

Buck uses setting to parallel psychological stakes. The storm’s chaos contrasts with Sadao’s calculated risk, deepening thematic resonance.

Question 12:
Critically assess the ending of The Enemy where Dr. Sadao lets the soldier escape. Does this resolve his moral conflict convincingly?
Answer:
Case Deconstruction

Sadao’s deliberate inaction allows the soldier to flee, avoiding direct betrayal of either his country or his ethics. The open-ended conclusion invites debate.

Theoretical Application
  • Passive Resolution: His silence becomes a moral compromise.
  • Ambiguity: The ending rejects simplistic answers, reflecting real-world dilemmas.
Critical Evaluation

While some may argue it’s cowardly, Buck suggests that survival sometimes requires nuanced choices beyond binary loyalties.

Question 13:

Read the following extract from The Enemy and answer the question that follows:

'Dr. Sadao had been educated in America, and he knew that the Americans were his enemies. Yet, when he found the wounded American soldier on the beach, he hesitated.'

Based on the above lines, analyze the internal conflict faced by Dr. Sadao. How does this conflict reflect the theme of humanity versus patriotism in the story?

Answer:

Dr. Sadao faces a deep internal conflict between his sense of humanity and his patriotic duty as a Japanese citizen during wartime.

1. Humanity vs. Patriotism: His medical training in America instilled in him the ethical duty to save lives, regardless of nationality. However, as a Japanese, he is acutely aware that helping an enemy soldier could be seen as treason.

2. Moral Dilemma: The hesitation shows his struggle between professional ethics (Hippocratic Oath) and national loyalty. This mirrors the broader theme of whether humanity transcends political boundaries.

3. Author's Message: Pearl S. Buck uses this conflict to critique war's dehumanization, suggesting compassion should override divisive ideologies.

4. Value Addition: The scene also highlights the universality of suffering—pain and vulnerability make the soldier not just an 'enemy,' but a fellow human.

Question 14:

In The Enemy, Hana’s reaction to the wounded American soldier evolves significantly. Illustrate how her initial fear transforms into empathy, citing textual evidence. What does this change reveal about her character?

Answer:

Hana’s transformation from fear to empathy underscores her compassionate nature and challenges societal prejudices.

1. Initial Fear: She is terrified of the soldier, calling him a 'monster' and fearing repercussions from authorities. This reflects wartime propaganda dehumanizing enemies.

2. Shift to Empathy: She later assists Dr. Sadao, tending to the soldier’s wounds and even feeding him. Her observation of his suffering ('his young, tortured face') humanizes him.

3. Character Insight: Her evolution shows moral courage—prioritizing kindness over blind nationalism. Unlike the servants who flee, she chooses humanity.

4. Broader Significance: Hana’s arc critiques gender roles; her empathy contrasts with the rigid militarism of male-dominated wartime Japan.

Question 15:

Read the following extract from The Enemy and answer the question that follows:

'Dr. Sadao had been educated in America, and he knew that the white man would never accept him as an equal.'

Based on this statement, analyze how Dr. Sadao's internal conflict reflects the broader theme of racial prejudice in the story. Support your answer with textual evidence.

Answer:

Dr. Sadao's internal conflict in The Enemy highlights the pervasive theme of racial prejudice during wartime. Despite his medical expertise and education in America, he feels alienated due to his Japanese identity. The line 'the white man would never accept him as an equal' underscores the racial barriers he faces, even as a skilled professional.

This conflict is further evident when he hesitates to help the wounded American soldier, torn between his humanitarian duty and societal expectations. The story critiques racial hierarchies by showing how prejudice clouds moral judgments, forcing Dr. Sadao to navigate loyalty to his nation versus empathy for an enemy.

Question 16:

In The Enemy, Dr. Sadao's wife, Hana, undergoes significant emotional turmoil. Examine how her character evolves from being a traditional Japanese wife to a more independent thinker as the story progresses. Provide examples to justify your answer.

Answer:

Hana's transformation in The Enemy reflects a shift from traditional submissiveness to assertive independence. Initially, she adheres to societal norms, as seen when she hesitates to question Dr. Sadao's decisions. However, her empathy for the wounded soldier challenges these norms.

For instance, she assists in the surgery despite her fear, showing moral courage. Later, she confronts the servants' disapproval, symbolizing her growing autonomy. Her evolution critiques gender roles in wartime Japan, emphasizing how crises can redefine personal agency.

Question 17:
Read the following excerpt from The Enemy and answer the question that follows:

'Dr. Sadao had been educated in America, and he knew that the white man would never trust a colored man, no matter how intelligent he was.'

How does this line reflect the racial prejudice faced by Dr. Sadao, and how does it influence his actions later in the story?
Answer:

The line highlights the racial discrimination Dr. Sadao experienced during his time in America, shaping his understanding of how he, as a Japanese man, was perceived by the white majority. This prejudice influences his actions in the story when he decides to help the wounded American soldier, despite the risks. His empathy stems from his own experiences of being marginalized, making him question the boundaries of enemy and humanity.

Dr. Sadao's internal conflict arises from his professional ethics as a doctor versus his national loyalty. His decision to treat the soldier reflects his rejection of racial bias, showcasing his belief in universal humanity. This act also underscores the theme of compassion transcending war, a key takeaway from the chapter.

Question 18:
In The Enemy, Dr. Sadao faces a moral dilemma when he finds the wounded American soldier. Analyze how his personal values and professional duty clash in this situation, and what this reveals about his character.
Answer:

Dr. Sadao's personal values as a compassionate human being clash with his professional duty as a doctor sworn to save lives, creating intense internal conflict. On one hand, he feels obligated to report the enemy soldier to authorities, adhering to his national duty. On the other, his medical ethics compel him to provide treatment, as he cannot let a person die.

  • His humanity triumphs when he chooses to heal the soldier, showcasing his moral integrity.
  • This decision also highlights his courage, as he risks his safety and reputation.

Ultimately, this clash reveals Dr. Sadao as a principled individual who prioritizes compassion over blind patriotism, making him a nuanced and morally complex character.

Question 19:
Read the following extract from The Enemy and answer the question that follows:

'Dr. Sadao had been educated in America, and his wife Hana had lived there too. They had met in the house of a professor where they both were invited to dinner.'

How does the cultural exposure of Dr. Sadao and Hana influence their actions in the story? Provide evidence from the text to support your answer.
Answer:

The cultural exposure of Dr. Sadao and Hana in America significantly influences their actions in The Enemy. Their education and experiences abroad make them more open-minded and compassionate, especially towards the wounded American soldier, despite him being an enemy during wartime.

Evidence from the text:

  • Dr. Sadao's medical expertise, gained in America, compels him to treat the soldier, prioritizing humanity over nationalism.
  • Hana's familiarity with Western customs helps her empathize with the soldier, as seen when she insists on caring for him despite the risks.

Their actions highlight the conflict between personal ethics and national loyalty, a central theme in the story.

Question 20:
In The Enemy, Dr. Sadao faces a moral dilemma when he finds the wounded American soldier. Analyze how his internal conflict reflects the broader theme of 'humanity versus patriotism' in the story.
Answer:

Dr. Sadao's internal conflict in The Enemy vividly portrays the tension between humanity and patriotism. As a skilled surgeon, he feels compelled to save the American soldier's life, but as a Japanese citizen during wartime, he is expected to turn the enemy over to authorities.

Key points of analysis:

  • His hesitation reflects the struggle between his professional ethics (to heal) and national duty (to report the enemy).
  • The eventual decision to help the soldier escape underscores the triumph of human compassion over rigid patriotism.

This conflict mirrors the broader theme of the story, questioning blind allegiance to nationalism when it contradicts universal human values.

Question 21:
Read the following excerpt from The Enemy and answer the question that follows:

'Dr. Sadao had been educated in America, and he knew that the Americans were his enemies. Yet, he chose to save the life of an American prisoner of war.'

Based on the given context, analyze the internal conflict faced by Dr. Sadao and how it reflects the theme of humanity versus patriotism in the story.
Answer:

Dr. Sadao faces a profound internal conflict between his duty as a doctor and his loyalty to his country. On one hand, his medical ethics compel him to save a life, regardless of the patient's nationality. On the other hand, as a Japanese citizen during wartime, he is expected to view the American soldier as the enemy. This dilemma highlights the central theme of humanity versus patriotism.

The story emphasizes that compassion transcends national boundaries. Despite knowing the risks, Dr. Sadao chooses humanity over blind patriotism, showcasing the moral complexity of war. His actions challenge the rigid definitions of enemy and ally, suggesting that empathy should prevail even in times of conflict.

Question 22:
In The Enemy, Dr. Sadao's wife, Hana, plays a crucial role in the story. Examine how her character evolves from being a traditional Japanese wife to a woman who questions societal norms, using textual evidence to support your answer.
Answer:

Hana begins as a traditional Japanese wife, obedient and supportive of her husband's decisions. However, her character undergoes significant growth when faced with the moral dilemma of harboring an enemy soldier. Initially, she is hesitant and fearful, reflecting societal expectations. For instance, she worries about the consequences of helping the American, showing her ingrained sense of duty to her country.

As the story progresses, Hana's empathy and humanity overshadow her fears. She assists Dr. Sadao in treating the soldier, even though it goes against societal norms. Her evolution is evident when she questions the blind adherence to patriotism and recognizes the value of human life. This transformation highlights the theme of individual morality versus societal expectations, making her a pivotal character in the narrative.

Chat on WhatsApp