On the Face of It – CBSE NCERT Study Resources

Previous Chapter Next Chapter

Study Materials

12th

12th - English

On the Face of It

Jump to Question Sets

Overview of the Chapter

"On the Face of It" is a play by Susan Hill, included in the CBSE English curriculum for Grade 12. The chapter explores themes of isolation, perception, and human connection through the interactions between two characters—Derry, a young boy with a disfigured face, and Mr. Lamb, an elderly man with a prosthetic leg. The play highlights how societal prejudices and personal insecurities shape human relationships.

Characters

  • Derry: A 14-year-old boy with a burnt face, who struggles with self-esteem and societal rejection.
  • Mr. Lamb: An old man with a prosthetic leg who lives alone and maintains a positive outlook on life despite his physical disability.

Summary

The play begins with Derry entering Mr. Lamb's garden, thinking it is empty. Mr. Lamb, sitting unnoticed, startles Derry by speaking. Initially wary, Derry gradually opens up to Mr. Lamb, who offers him a different perspective on life. Mr. Lamb encourages Derry to look beyond his physical appearance and embrace life with optimism. However, Derry remains skeptical, burdened by the cruelty he faces from others. The play ends on a poignant note, emphasizing the fragility of human connections.

Themes

  • Perception vs. Reality: The play contrasts how people perceive disabilities versus the reality of living with them.
  • Isolation and Loneliness: Both characters experience loneliness but cope with it differently.
  • Resilience and Acceptance: Mr. Lamb symbolizes resilience, while Derry represents the struggle for self-acceptance.

Key Dialogues

"It's not what you look like, it's what you are inside." — Mr. Lamb

"People are afraid of me. They stare and whisper." — Derry

Literary Devices

  • Symbolism: The garden symbolizes hope and renewal.
  • Irony: Mr. Lamb, despite his disability, is more accepting of life than Derry.
  • Dialogue: The conversation between the two characters drives the narrative and reveals their inner conflicts.

All Question Types with Solutions – CBSE Exam Pattern

Explore a complete set of CBSE-style questions with detailed solutions, categorized by marks and question types. Ideal for exam preparation, revision and practice.

Very Short Answer (1 Mark) – with Solutions (CBSE Pattern)

These are 1-mark questions requiring direct, concise answers. Ideal for quick recall and concept clarity.

Question 1:
What is the central theme of On the Face of It?
Answer:

Isolation and human connection despite physical differences.

Question 2:
Who is the author of On the Face of It?
Answer:

Susan Hill.

Question 3:
Name the two main characters in the play.
Answer:

Derry and Mr. Lamb.

Question 4:
What is Derry's physical condition?
Answer:

He has a burnt face.

Question 5:
How does Mr. Lamb lose his leg?
Answer:

In a war explosion.

Question 6:
What does Mr. Lamb's garden symbolize?
Answer:

Acceptance and resilience.

Question 7:
Why does Derry initially avoid people?
Answer:

Due to fear of rejection.

Question 8:
What lesson does Mr. Lamb teach Derry?
Answer:

To embrace life despite hardships.

Question 9:
How does Derry's attitude change by the end?
Answer:

He becomes more hopeful.

Question 10:
What is the significance of the play's title?
Answer:

Appearances can be deceptive.

Question 11:
What literary device is prominent in the play?
Answer:

Symbolism.

Question 12:
How does Mr. Lamb describe beauty?
Answer:

As internal, not external.

Question 13:
What happens to Mr. Lamb at the end?
Answer:

He dies from a fall.

Question 14:
What is the climax of the play?
Answer:

Derry returns to Mr. Lamb.

Question 15:
Who is the author of the play On the Face of It?
Answer:

The play On the Face of It is written by Susan Hill, a renowned English author known for her works in drama and fiction.

Question 16:
What is the central theme of On the Face of It?
Answer:

The central theme revolves around perception and reality, focusing on how society judges individuals based on appearances and the importance of looking beyond physical differences.

Question 17:
Name the two main characters in On the Face of It.
Answer:

The two main characters are Mr. Lamb, an old man with a tin leg, and Derry, a young boy with a burnt face.

Question 18:
How does Mr. Lamb react to Derry's fear of being judged?
Answer:

Mr. Lamb encourages Derry to embrace life and not let others' opinions define him, teaching him the value of self-acceptance and resilience.

Question 19:
What does the phrase 'on the face of it' signify in the play?
Answer:

It signifies the superficial judgments people make based on appearances, contrasting with the deeper reality of a person's character.

Question 20:
Why does Derry initially avoid human contact?
Answer:

Derry avoids human contact due to the painful reactions and stares he receives because of his burnt face, leading to feelings of isolation.

Question 21:
What lesson does Derry learn from Mr. Lamb?
Answer:

Derry learns to overcome his fears and understand that true happiness comes from within, not from others' acceptance.

Question 22:
How does Mr. Lamb spend his time in the garden?
Answer:

Mr. Lamb spends his time observing nature, tending to plants, and welcoming visitors, symbolizing his open-hearted and optimistic outlook.

Question 23:
What is the significance of the garden in the play?
Answer:

The garden symbolizes growth, healing, and acceptance, serving as a safe space where both characters confront their insecurities.

Question 24:
How does Derry's attitude change by the end of the play?
Answer:

Derry becomes more confident and hopeful, inspired by Mr. Lamb's wisdom, and decides to face the world without fear.

Question 25:
What does Mr. Lamb's tin leg represent?
Answer:

Mr. Lamb's tin leg represents resilience and adaptability, showing how physical limitations do not define one's spirit or capabilities.

Question 26:
Why is the play titled On the Face of It?
Answer:

The title highlights the contrast between surface-level judgments and the deeper truths about people, urging readers to look beyond appearances.

Very Short Answer (2 Marks) – with Solutions (CBSE Pattern)

These 2-mark questions test key concepts in a brief format. Answers are expected to be accurate and slightly descriptive.

Question 1:
What is the central theme of the play On the Face of It?
Answer:

The central theme of the play On the Face of It revolves around perception and isolation. It explores how people judge others based on physical appearances and how such judgments lead to emotional isolation. The play also highlights the importance of empathy and human connection in overcoming societal prejudices.

Question 2:
How does Mr. Lamb try to comfort Derry?
Answer:

Mr. Lamb comforts Derry by sharing his own experiences and philosophy of life. He encourages Derry to look beyond his physical scars and focus on the beauty of the world. Mr. Lamb uses metaphors like the garden and bees to teach Derry about acceptance and resilience.

Question 3:
Why does Derry feel isolated from society?
Answer:

Derry feels isolated because of his facial disfigurement, which makes him a target of pity, fear, and ridicule. Society's prejudiced attitude and lack of empathy make him withdraw into himself, leading to emotional and social isolation.

Question 4:
What significance does the garden hold in the play?
Answer:

The garden symbolizes hope, growth, and acceptance. It represents Mr. Lamb's positive outlook on life, where he finds beauty in everything, despite his physical disability. The garden also serves as a safe space for Derry to reflect and heal emotionally.

Question 5:
How does Derry's perspective change after meeting Mr. Lamb?
Answer:

Derry's perspective shifts from self-loathing to self-acceptance after interacting with Mr. Lamb. He begins to see the world differently, understanding that physical appearance does not define one's worth. Mr. Lamb's wisdom helps Derry embrace life with newfound confidence.

Question 6:
What does the phrase 'on the face of it' imply in the context of the play?
Answer:

The phrase 'on the face of it' suggests superficial judgments based on appearances. The play critiques how society often misinterprets people's true nature by focusing solely on external flaws, ignoring their inner strength and potential.

Question 7:
How does Mr. Lamb's disability contrast with Derry's?
Answer:

Mr. Lamb has a prosthetic leg, but he does not let it define him. He lives life fully, embracing his imperfections. In contrast, Derry's facial scars make him resentful and withdrawn. Mr. Lamb's attitude teaches Derry to overcome his insecurities.

Question 8:
What role does fear play in Derry's life?
Answer:

Fear dominates Derry's life, making him avoid social interactions. He is afraid of being stared at, pitied, or rejected because of his scars. This fear reinforces his isolation until Mr. Lamb helps him confront and overcome it.

Question 9:
How does the play highlight the theme of loneliness?
Answer:

The play portrays loneliness through both characters—Derry, who isolates himself due to societal rejection, and Mr. Lamb, who lives alone but finds solace in nature. Their bond underscores the human need for companionship to combat loneliness.

Question 10:
How does the play end, and what message does it convey?
Answer:

The play ends on a bittersweet note—Mr. Lamb dies, but Derry returns to the garden, showing his transformation. The message is that while life has hardships, one must embrace it with courage and optimism, just as Mr. Lamb did.

Short Answer (3 Marks) – with Solutions (CBSE Pattern)

These 3-mark questions require brief explanations and help assess understanding and application of concepts.

Question 1:
How does the character of Mr. Lamb in On the Face of It symbolize resilience?
Answer:

Mr. Lamb symbolizes resilience through his optimistic outlook despite his physical disability. He embraces life fully, finding joy in small things like sunlight and nature. His philosophy of 'the world's what you make of it' reflects his ability to rise above adversity. Unlike Derry, who is initially withdrawn, Mr. Lamb teaches the importance of acceptance and moving forward.

Question 2:
Explain the significance of the garden in On the Face of It.
Answer:

The garden in the play represents healing and transformation. It is a safe space where Derry and Mr. Lamb bond, away from societal judgment. The garden's open gate symbolizes inclusivity, while its bees and flowers reflect the beauty of life despite imperfections. It becomes a metaphor for Derry's emotional growth as he learns to see beyond his scars.

Question 3:
How does Susan Hill use contrast between Derry and Mr. Lamb in On the Face of It?
Answer:

Susan Hill contrasts Derry's pessimism with Mr. Lamb's optimism to highlight their differing perspectives on life. Derry is young, angry, and self-conscious about his burns, while Mr. Lamb, though physically disabled, radiates wisdom and acceptance. Their interactions show how mentorship can bridge generational and emotional gaps, ultimately helping Derry evolve.

Question 4:
What role does dialogue play in developing the theme of isolation in On the Face of It?
Answer:

The dialogue in the play reveals the psychological isolation of both characters. Derry's defensive remarks ('People are afraid of me') contrast with Mr. Lamb's welcoming tone ('I’ve got a tin leg, but it doesn’t stop me'). Their conversations gradually break down emotional barriers, showing how communication can combat loneliness. The sparse setting amplifies the power of their words.

Question 5:
Analyze the metaphor of the 'tin leg' in On the Face of It.
Answer:

Mr. Lamb's tin leg is a metaphor for adaptability and impermanence. Unlike Derry, who sees his scars as permanent flaws, Mr. Lamb treats his prosthetic limb as a trivial detail. The tin leg symbolizes how physical limitations need not define one's spirit. It reinforces the theme that true disability lies in the mind, not the body.

Question 6:
How does the ending of On the Face of It reflect Derry's transformation?
Answer:

The ending shows Derry's shift from fear to courage. Despite Mr. Lamb's death, Derry chooses to return to the garden, embracing his mentor's teachings. His decision to 'go back' signifies his acceptance of life's challenges and his newfound resilience. The open-ended conclusion leaves room for hope, mirroring Derry's incomplete but promising journey.

Question 7:
How does the character of Mr. Lamb in On the Face of It symbolize resilience?
Answer:

Mr. Lamb embodies resilience by accepting his physical disability with optimism. Despite losing a leg, he cultivates a garden, engages with people, and refuses to pity himself. His philosophy of 'the world is what you make of it' highlights his mental strength. Resilience is further shown when he encourages Derry to look beyond appearances, proving that inner strength triumphs over adversity.

Question 8:
Explain the significance of the garden in On the Face of It.
Answer:

The garden symbolizes growth, healing, and acceptance. It serves as a safe space where Mr. Lamb and Derry connect, overcoming their insecurities. The garden's openness mirrors Mr. Lamb's welcoming nature, while its beauty contrasts societal prejudices. It also represents the idea that life, like plants, flourishes with care and positivity.

Question 9:
How does the play On the Face of It challenge societal perceptions of disability?
Answer:

The play critiques society's tendency to judge based on appearances. Through Derry's fear of rejection and Mr. Lamb's indifference to pity, it shows how disabilities are misunderstood. Stereotypes are challenged when Mr. Lamb proves that happiness isn't tied to physical perfection. The narrative urges readers to see beyond 'the face of it' and value inner qualities.

Question 10:
Describe the transformation of Derry in On the Face of It.
Answer:

Derry evolves from a withdrawn, bitter boy to someone hopeful. Initially, he hides due to his burnt face, fearing ridicule. After meeting Mr. Lamb, he learns to embrace life despite his scars. Key moments include:

  • Realizing people's opinions don't define him
  • Adopting Mr. Lamb's positive outlook
  • Choosing to return to the garden, showing newfound courage
His journey reflects self-acceptance and emotional growth.

Question 11:
What role does dialogue play in developing the themes of On the Face of It?
Answer:

The dialogue drives the play's themes of isolation and connection. Conversations between Derry and Mr. Lamb reveal their inner struggles and bond. For example:
Derry's defensive remarks show his pain.
Mr. Lamb's anecdotes subtly teach life lessons.
Their exchanges contrast societal harshness with empathy, making themes relatable and impactful.

Question 12:
How does the title On the Face of It reflect the central idea of the play?
Answer:

The title hints at superficial judgments versus deeper truths. 'On the face of it' refers to Derry's scars and Mr. Lamb's disability, which society misinterprets. However, the play reveals their rich inner lives, proving appearances deceive. It emphasizes looking beyond the surface—a core message about perception and humanity.

Long Answer (5 Marks) – with Solutions (CBSE Pattern)

These 5-mark questions are descriptive and require detailed, structured answers with proper explanation and examples.

Question 1:
Analyze the theme of isolation in On the Face of It. How does Susan Hill portray it through Derry and Mr. Lamb?
Answer:
Theoretical Framework

Isolation is central to the play, explored through physical and emotional detachment. Derry's burns and Mr. Lamb's prosthetic leg symbolize societal exclusion.

Evidence Analysis
  • Derry hides due to fear of judgment, stating, 'People are afraid of me.'
  • Mr. Lamb's garden represents his self-imposed isolation yet openness to life.
Critical Evaluation

Hill contrasts Derry's bitterness with Mr. Lamb's resilience, showing isolation as a mindset. Their interactions highlight healing through empathy.

Question 2:
Discuss the symbolism of the garden in On the Face of It. How does it reflect Mr. Lamb's worldview?
Answer:
Theoretical Framework

The garden symbolizes growth and acceptance. Mr. Lamb tends to it meticulously, mirroring his philosophy of embracing life's imperfections.

Evidence Analysis
  • He calls weeds 'just plants growing where they shouldn’t,' showing inclusivity.
  • Derry’s initial rejection of the garden reflects his internalized prejudice.
Critical Evaluation

The garden becomes a metaphor for resilience. Mr. Lamb’s care for it parallels his attempt to 'cultivate' hope in Derry, proving symbolism drives the narrative.

Question 3:
How does Susan Hill use dialogue to reveal Derry's psychological transformation in the play?
Answer:
Theoretical Framework

Dialogue tracks Derry’s shift from self-loathing to self-acceptance. His conversations with Mr. Lamb serve as catharsis.

Evidence Analysis
  • Early dialogues like 'I’m not afraid. People are afraid of me' show defiance masking pain.
  • Later, he admits, 'I’d like a friend,' revealing vulnerability.
Critical Evaluation

Hill uses sparse, impactful dialogue to avoid melodrama. Derry’s evolving tone mirrors his emotional arc, proving dialogue’s role in character development.

Question 4:
Examine the irony in the title On the Face of It. How does it reflect the play’s deeper message?
Answer:
Theoretical Framework

The title ironically hints at superficial judgments versus hidden truths. Society misinterprets Derry and Mr. Lamb based on appearances.

Evidence Analysis
  • Derry’s mother pities him, unaware of his inner strength.
  • Mr. Lamb’s optimism contrasts his physical disability, subverting stereotypes.
Critical Evaluation

Hill uses irony to critique societal prejudice. The title encapsulates the play’s call to look beyond surfaces, making it thematically resonant.

Question 5:
Compare Derry and Mr. Lamb’s coping mechanisms for societal rejection in On the Face of It.
Answer:
Theoretical Framework

Both characters face alienation but respond differently. Derry withdraws, while Mr. Lamb engages with the world.

Evidence Analysis
  • Derry avoids mirrors, symbolizing self-denial.
  • Mr. Lamb leaves his door open, signifying inclusivity despite ridicule.
Critical Evaluation

Hill juxtaposes their strategies to show isolation’s psychological toll. Mr. Lamb’s approach ultimately influences Derry, underscoring the power of perspective.

Question 6:
Analyze the theme of isolation in the chapter On the Face of It by Susan Hill. How do the characters of Mr. Lamb and Derry reflect this theme?
Answer:

The theme of isolation is central to the chapter On the Face of It. Both Mr. Lamb and Derry experience isolation, but in different ways. Derry isolates himself due to his physical deformity and the fear of being judged by society. His bitterness and withdrawal are evident in his reluctance to interact with others. On the other hand, Mr. Lamb, despite losing a leg in an accident, chooses not to isolate himself. He embraces life and finds joy in small things, like his garden and the children who visit him.

Their contrasting attitudes highlight how isolation can be both self-imposed and overcome through a positive outlook. Derry's journey from isolation to a tentative connection with Mr. Lamb shows the transformative power of empathy and understanding. The chapter ultimately suggests that while physical or emotional scars may lead to isolation, human connection can heal and bridge the gap.

Question 7:
Discuss the significance of the garden as a symbol in On the Face of It. How does it reflect the characters' perspectives on life?
Answer:

The garden in On the Face of It serves as a powerful symbol of resilience, growth, and acceptance. For Mr. Lamb, the garden represents his optimistic outlook on life. Despite his physical disability, he tends to the garden with care, showing that life continues to flourish even after hardship. The garden also symbolizes his openness—he leaves the gate unlocked, welcoming others into his space, just as he welcomes Derry into his life.

For Derry, the garden initially seems like a place of fear and discomfort, as he associates it with the stares and judgments of others. However, as he spends time with Mr. Lamb, the garden becomes a place of learning and transformation. It mirrors Derry's gradual shift from bitterness to hope. The garden, therefore, acts as a metaphor for the possibility of renewal and the importance of embracing life despite its challenges.

Question 8:
Explain how the chapter On the Face of It explores the idea of appearance versus reality. Provide examples from the text to support your answer.
Answer:

The chapter On the Face of It delves deeply into the contrast between appearance and reality. At first glance, Derry appears as a bitter and withdrawn boy due to his scarred face, but in reality, he is sensitive and yearns for acceptance. Similarly, Mr. Lamb seems like a cheerful and unbothered old man, but his prosthetic leg reveals his own struggles with physical pain and societal judgment.

One key example is Derry's assumption that people mock him because of his appearance, while in reality, some may simply be curious or indifferent. Mr. Lamb challenges Derry's perception by sharing his own experiences, showing that appearances can be deceiving. The chapter teaches that true understanding comes from looking beyond superficial judgments and recognizing the deeper realities of human emotions and experiences.

Question 9:
Discuss the theme of isolation and human connection in the play On the Face of It by Susan Hill. How do the characters of Mr. Lamb and Derry reflect these themes?
Answer:

The play On the Face of It explores the profound themes of isolation and human connection through the contrasting yet interconnected lives of Mr. Lamb and Derry. Both characters experience physical and emotional isolation due to societal prejudices—Derry because of his burnt face and Mr. Lamb due to his prosthetic leg.

Mr. Lamb represents resilience and optimism. Despite his disability, he chooses to embrace life, finding joy in small things like his garden and open house. His philosophy of "the world is what you make of it" highlights his belief in human connection. He tries to break Derry's isolation by encouraging him to look beyond his scars.

On the other hand, Derry initially embodies bitterness and withdrawal. He fears rejection and hides from the world, symbolizing the emotional scars of isolation. However, through his interaction with Mr. Lamb, Derry begins to see the possibility of acceptance and connection. The play ultimately suggests that while isolation is a painful reality, human empathy and understanding can bridge the gap, as seen in Derry's transformation.

Question 10:
Analyze the symbolic significance of the garden in On the Face of It. How does it reflect the characters' perspectives on life?
Answer:

The garden in On the Face of It serves as a powerful symbol of hope, renewal, and acceptance. It mirrors the contrasting worldviews of Mr. Lamb and Derry while also acting as a space for emotional healing.

For Mr. Lamb, the garden represents his optimistic outlook. He sees beauty in weeds and flowers alike, symbolizing his belief that life, despite its flaws, is valuable. His statement, "A weed is just a plant in the wrong place", reflects his inclusive perspective—he does not judge based on appearances, much like how he treats Derry.

For Derry, the garden initially seems irrelevant, as he is consumed by his anger and isolation. However, as he spends time there, the garden becomes a metaphor for his gradual change. Just as plants grow and transform, Derry begins to open up to the possibility of a life beyond his scars. The garden, thus, symbolizes the potential for growth and connection when one embraces life without fear.

Question 11:
Discuss the theme of isolation and human connection in the chapter On the Face of It by Susan Hill. How do the characters of Mr. Lamb and Derry reflect these themes?
Answer:

The chapter On the Face of It explores the profound themes of isolation and human connection through the contrasting yet interconnected lives of Mr. Lamb and Derry. Both characters experience physical and emotional isolation due to societal prejudices—Derry because of his facial scar and Mr. Lamb due to his prosthetic leg.

Derry initially embodies isolation, as he avoids people due to their cruel remarks about his appearance. His bitterness and fear reflect his internal struggle. However, Mr. Lamb, despite his own challenges, embraces life and connection. He teaches Derry the importance of looking beyond physical appearances and finding joy in small things, like the beauty of nature.

The interaction between the two highlights how human connection can heal emotional wounds. Mr. Lamb's garden becomes a symbol of hope and acceptance, where Derry begins to see the world differently. The chapter ultimately suggests that while isolation is painful, genuine human connection can overcome it, fostering resilience and self-acceptance.

Question 12:
Analyze the symbolic significance of the garden in On the Face of It. How does it contribute to the overall message of the story?
Answer:

The garden in On the Face of It serves as a powerful symbol of hope, acceptance, and renewal. It reflects Mr. Lamb's optimistic outlook on life despite his physical disability and becomes a transformative space for Derry.

  • Symbol of Freedom: The garden, with its open gate, represents inclusivity and the freedom to embrace life without fear of judgment.
  • Metaphor for Growth: Just as plants grow and flourish, Derry's perspective evolves after interacting with Mr. Lamb. He learns to see beyond his scars and societal prejudices.
  • Contrast to Isolation: While Derry initially hides from the world, the garden becomes a place where he finds companionship and understanding, breaking his cycle of isolation.

Through the garden, the story conveys that beauty and meaning can be found even in imperfection. It reinforces the idea that human connection and a positive mindset can help overcome life's challenges.

Question 13:
Discuss the theme of isolation in the chapter On the Face of It by Susan Hill, highlighting how both Mr. Lamb and Derry experience it differently. Support your answer with textual references.
Answer:

The theme of isolation is central to the chapter On the Face of It, where both Mr. Lamb and Derry experience it but in contrasting ways. Derry, a young boy with a burnt face, faces isolation due to societal rejection and his own insecurities. He avoids people, fearing their stares and pity, as seen when he says, 'People are afraid of me. They stare...'. His isolation is self-imposed and rooted in low self-esteem.

On the other hand, Mr. Lamb, an old man with a tin leg, embraces his isolation positively. He finds solace in nature and his garden, stating, 'I’ve got a tin leg, but it doesn’t stop me from living.' Unlike Derry, he accepts his physical difference and refuses to let it define him. His isolation is more about independence than loneliness.

Through these characters, Susan Hill highlights how isolation can be both a prison (Derry) and a choice (Mr. Lamb), urging readers to reflect on their own perceptions of difference and belonging.

Question 14:
Analyze the symbolic significance of the garden in On the Face of It. How does it reflect Mr. Lamb's outlook on life?
Answer:

The garden in On the Face of It serves as a powerful symbol of resilience, acceptance, and hope, mirroring Mr. Lamb's optimistic worldview. Unlike Derry, who sees his scars as a curse, Mr. Lamb finds beauty in imperfection, much like his garden, which is open to all—bees, weeds, and children alike. He says, 'It’s all life. Growing.', emphasizing that life thrives despite flaws.

The garden also symbolizes inclusivity. Mr. Lamb welcomes Derry without judgment, offering him a space to heal emotionally. The overgrown, untamed nature of the garden reflects his belief that life cannot be controlled or confined, much like his own experiences with disability.

Ultimately, the garden becomes a metaphor for Mr. Lamb’s philosophy: life is to be lived fully, regardless of hardships. His nurturing attitude toward the garden parallels his mentorship of Derry, teaching him to embrace life’s uncertainties.

Question 15:
Discuss the theme of isolation and acceptance in the play On the Face of It by Susan Hill. How do the characters of Mr. Lamb and Derry portray these themes?
Answer:

The play On the Face of It explores the profound themes of isolation and acceptance through the contrasting yet interconnected lives of Mr. Lamb and Derry. Both characters suffer from physical disabilities, which lead to societal exclusion, but their responses to isolation differ significantly.

Mr. Lamb, despite losing a leg in the war, adopts a positive outlook on life. He embraces his imperfections and finds solace in nature and human connections. His garden symbolizes his openness to the world, as he says, 'The world’s got a whole face, and the world’s there to be looked at.' His philosophy reflects acceptance—both of himself and others.

In contrast, Derry, a young boy with a burnt face, struggles with self-loathing and fear of rejection. He isolates himself, believing that people only see his scars. However, through his interactions with Mr. Lamb, Derry begins to question his perspective. The play highlights how acceptance starts from within, as Derry eventually learns to confront his fears.

The play ultimately suggests that while isolation is a painful reality for those deemed 'different,' acceptance can be achieved through empathy, resilience, and a change in mindset.

Question 16:
Analyze the symbolic significance of the garden in On the Face of It. How does it reflect the emotional journeys of Mr. Lamb and Derry?
Answer:

The garden in On the Face of It serves as a powerful symbol, representing healing, growth, and connection. It mirrors the emotional transformations of both Mr. Lamb and Derry.

For Mr. Lamb, the garden is a sanctuary where he finds peace and purpose. Despite his physical disability, he tends to it with care, showing his resilience and ability to find beauty in life. The open gate of his garden symbolizes his welcoming attitude toward others, reinforcing the theme of inclusivity.

For Derry, the garden initially represents a place of fear and hesitation, as he is wary of being judged. However, as he spends time there, the garden becomes a space of self-discovery. The act of picking apples—a task Mr. Lamb assigns him—symbolizes Derry’s gradual acceptance of himself and his potential.

The garden, thus, acts as a bridge between isolation and belonging, reflecting the characters’ journeys from loneliness to emotional liberation.

Case-based Questions (4 Marks) – with Solutions (CBSE Pattern)

These 4-mark case-based questions assess analytical skills through real-life scenarios. Answers must be based on the case study provided.

Question 1:
Analyze how Mr. Lamb and Derry represent contrasting perspectives on life in On the Face of It. How does their interaction highlight the theme of acceptance?
Answer:
Case Deconstruction

Mr. Lamb embodies optimism, seeing beauty in imperfections, while Derry is pessimistic due to his facial scar. Their dialogue reveals Lamb’s wisdom in accepting life’s challenges.

Theoretical Application
  • Lamb’s metaphor of weeds and flowers symbolizes coexistence.
  • Derry’s transformation shows acceptance as a gradual process.
Critical Evaluation

Their interaction critiques societal biases, urging empathy. For example, Lamb’s open door policy contrasts Derry’s isolation, reinforcing acceptance as liberation.

Question 2:
Evaluate the significance of the garden setting in On the Face of It. How does it mirror the characters’ emotional states?
Answer:
Case Deconstruction

The garden symbolizes growth and healing. Derry’s initial fear of being judged parallels neglected plants, while Lamb tends to both with care.

Theoretical Application
  • The crumbling wall reflects Derry’s fractured self-esteem.
  • Lamb’s bees and weeds analogy teaches resilience.
Critical Evaluation

Nature here acts as a metaphor for human flaws. For instance, Derry’s eventual comfort in the garden mirrors his self-acceptance, proving setting as a narrative tool.

Question 3:
Discuss how dialogue drives the plot in On the Face of It. Provide examples where conversations reveal deeper psychological conflicts.
Answer:
Case Deconstruction

Derry’s defensive replies (“People stare at me”) expose his trauma, while Lamb’s questions (“What do you see?”) provoke introspection.

Theoretical Application
  • Lamb’s storytelling disarms Derry’s hostility.
  • Derry’s outburst (“I’m not like you”) reveals internalized shame.
Critical Evaluation

The dialogue’s simplicity masks depth. For example, Lamb’s admission of loneliness bridges their emotional gap, showing communication as catharsis.

Question 4:
Contrast the ending choices of Derry and Lamb in On the Face of It. How do their resolutions reflect their philosophies?
Answer:
Case Deconstruction

Derry chooses to return, embracing change, while Lamb’s tragic end underscores his belief in life’s unpredictability.

Theoretical Application
  • Derry’s defiance (“I’ll come back”) shows growth.
  • Lamb’s accidental death mirrors his acceptance of fate.
Critical Evaluation

Their endings critique societal norms. For instance, Derry’s resilience contrasts Lamb’s fatalism, proving survival isn’t just physical but emotional.

Question 5:
Analyze how the metaphor of the garden in On the Face of It reflects Derry's emotional transformation. Provide textual evidence.
Answer:
Case Deconstruction

The garden symbolizes Derry's shift from isolation to hope. Initially, he fears judgment, but Mr. Lamb's perspective helps him see beauty despite flaws.

Theoretical Application
  • Derry's hesitation mirrors societal prejudice against disabilities.
  • The ripe apples represent hidden potential, as Derry learns self-acceptance.
Critical Evaluation

Textually, 'the weeds and flowers grow together' reinforces coexistence of pain and growth, aligning with Derry's journey from insecurity to resilience.

Question 6:
Contrast Derry and Mr. Lamb's perspectives on isolation with current youth mental health trends (2020-24).
Answer:
Case Deconstruction

Derry's isolation stems from social stigma, while Mr. Lamb embraces solitude through philosophy. Both reflect coping mechanisms.

Theoretical Application
  • Modern data shows 60% of disabled teens report loneliness (UNICEF 2023), mirroring Derry.
  • Mr. Lamb's resilience aligns with mindfulness therapies gaining traction post-pandemic.
Critical Evaluation

The play's dichotomy remains relevant as hybrid socialization exacerbates youth isolation, demanding nuanced solutions.

Question 7:
Evaluate how the play's structure (single-setting dialogue) intensifies its themes of perception. Use two dramatic techniques.
Answer:
Case Deconstruction

The confined garden setting forces focus on verbal interplay, stripping distractions to highlight subjective realities.

Theoretical Application
  • Monologues: Derry's Act 1 speech reveals internalized bias.
  • Silence: Pauses underscore tension between appearance (face) and truth (it).
Critical Evaluation

This minimalism echoes Beckett's absurdism, making the audience complicit in judging characters superficially before understanding depths.

Question 8:
Debate whether Mr. Lamb's 'bee stings' philosophy offers practical solutions for modern disability advocacy. Support with examples.
Answer:
Case Deconstruction

His analogy normalizes pain as universal, challenging 'otherization' of disability. However, it risks oversimplifying systemic barriers.

Theoretical Application
  • Positive: Aligns with #BodyNeutrality movement rejecting inspirational tropes.
  • Limitation: Ignores accessibility infrastructure gaps highlighted by 2023 UN Disability Report.
Critical Evaluation

While promoting individual resilience, the play's era lacked today's emphasis on institutional accountability in equity frameworks.

Question 9:
In On the Face of It, Mr. Lamb tells Derry, 'It's all relative, beauty and the beast.' Case Deconstruction: How does this statement reflect Mr. Lamb's worldview? Theoretical Application: Link this to the theme of perception vs. reality in the play.
Answer:
Case Deconstruction:

Mr. Lamb's statement highlights his belief that beauty is subjective, shaped by individual perspectives. His own physical scars don’t define his worth, emphasizing resilience.

Theoretical Application:
  • The play contrasts Derry’s self-loathing with Mr. Lamb’s acceptance, illustrating how perception distorts reality.
  • Example: Derry sees his burns as monstrous, while Mr. Lamb sees them as inconsequential—mirroring societal biases.
Critical Evaluation:

This duality challenges stereotypes, urging readers to question superficial judgments, a recurring motif in the text.

Question 10:
Case Deconstruction: Analyze Derry’s transformation after interacting with Mr. Lamb. Theoretical Application: How does Susan Hill use symbolism (e.g., the garden) to reinforce this change?
Answer:
Case Deconstruction:

Derry evolves from isolation to hope, influenced by Mr. Lamb’s wisdom. His fear of rejection diminishes, showcasing emotional growth.

Theoretical Application:
  • The garden symbolizes renewal; Derry’s willingness to enter it mirrors his openness to change.
  • Example: The ripe apples represent potential, contrasting Derry’s earlier bitterness.
Critical Evaluation:

Hill’s layered symbolism underscores the power of empathy in healing, a central thesis of the play.

Question 11:
Case Deconstruction: Contrast Derry’s and Mr. Lamb’s coping mechanisms for societal rejection. Theoretical Application: Relate their strategies to real-world mental resilience models.
Answer:
Case Deconstruction:

Derry withdraws, while Mr. Lamb engages with the world—their approaches reflect avoidance vs. acceptance.

Theoretical Application:
  • Mr. Lamb’s resilience aligns with cognitive reframing, turning stigma into strength.
  • Example: Derry’s isolation parallels modern social anxiety, whereas Mr. Lamb embodies growth mindset theories.
Critical Evaluation:

The play critiques how society’s labels shape self-worth, urging adaptive coping strategies.

Question 12:
Case Deconstruction: Examine the significance of the play’s title, On the Face of It. Theoretical Application: How does it encapsulate the irony in Derry’s and Mr. Lamb’s lives?
Answer:
Case Deconstruction:

The title hints at superficial judgments—Derry’s scars and Mr. Lamb’s disability mask their deeper humanity.

Theoretical Application:
  • Irony lies in Derry’s internalized hatred vs. Mr. Lamb’s outward positivity despite similar struggles.
  • Example: Society pities Mr. Lamb, yet he’s emotionally richer than Derry’s ‘normal’ tormentors.
Critical Evaluation:

Hill critiques societal hypocrisy, where appearances often deceive, reinforcing the play’s moral complexity.

Question 13:
Read the following extract and answer the questions that follow:

"It’s a pity you can’t see them from here. They’re a picture. And this is nothing. You should see the ones in the orchard. There’s a whole world there."

(a) Who is the speaker and who is being addressed here?
(b) What does the speaker mean by "a whole world" in the orchard?
(c) How does this dialogue reflect the theme of perception versus reality in the chapter?
Answer:

(a) The speaker is Mr. Lamb, and he is addressing Derry, the young boy with a burnt face. Mr. Lamb is trying to shift Derry's focus from his physical appearance to the beauty of nature.

(b) By "a whole world," Mr. Lamb refers to the vibrant and lively ecosystem in the orchard, filled with plants, insects, and animals. It symbolizes the beauty, diversity, and opportunities life offers beyond one's immediate struggles.

(c) This dialogue highlights the theme of perception versus reality as Derry initially perceives himself as an outcast due to his scars, while Mr. Lamb encourages him to see the broader reality—the beauty and possibilities around him. Mr. Lamb’s perspective challenges Derry’s negative self-perception, urging him to embrace life fully.

Question 14:
Read the following extract and answer the questions that follow:

"People are afraid of me. They stare. Or they look away. Children shout… cruel things."

(a) Why does Derry feel people are afraid of him?
(b) How does Mr. Lamb respond to Derry’s fear of being judged?
(c) Explain how this conversation reflects the central conflict in the chapter.
Answer:

(a) Derry feels people are afraid of him because of his facial scars from a burn injury. Society often judges individuals based on appearance, leading to fear, pity, or ridicule, which isolates Derry emotionally.

(b) Mr. Lamb responds by sharing his own experience of being judged (due to his tin leg) and advises Derry to focus on the positives in life, like nature and curiosity, rather than others' opinions. He emphasizes self-acceptance and resilience.

(c) This conversation reflects the central conflict between society’s prejudice and individual self-worth. Derry struggles with external judgment, while Mr. Lamb represents the resolution—choosing inner strength and perspective over societal rejection. The dialogue underscores the chapter’s message of overcoming superficial biases.

Question 15:
Read the following extract from On the Face of It and answer the question that follows:

'People are afraid of me because I look different. But I am just like them inside.'

How does the play On the Face of It explore the theme of social prejudice through the character of Mr. Lamb? Discuss with reference to the given extract.
Answer:

The play On the Face of It by Susan Hill delves into the theme of social prejudice through the character of Mr. Lamb, who faces discrimination due to his physical disability. The given extract highlights how society often judges individuals based on their outward appearance, ignoring their inner humanity.


Mr. Lamb, despite his disfigured face, is a kind and wise man who welcomes everyone into his garden. However, people avoid him due to their fear and discomfort, showcasing deep-rooted prejudice. The play critiques this superficial judgment by contrasting Mr. Lamb's compassionate nature with society's harsh stereotypes.


Additionally, the bond between Mr. Lamb and Derry, a young boy with a burnt face, underscores the shared experience of isolation. Through their interactions, the play emphasizes that true connection transcends physical appearances, urging readers to look beyond societal biases.

Question 16:
In On the Face of It, Derry undergoes a significant transformation after meeting Mr. Lamb. Analyze how Mr. Lamb's perspective on life influences Derry's outlook, citing examples from the text.
Answer:

In On the Face of It, Derry's encounter with Mr. Lamb acts as a turning point in his life. Initially, Derry is bitter and withdrawn due to his facial scar, believing that people will always reject him. However, Mr. Lamb's optimistic and inclusive worldview profoundly impacts Derry.


Mr. Lamb teaches Derry to embrace life despite hardships, using metaphors like the 'garden full of weeds and flowers' to illustrate that beauty and pain coexist. He encourages Derry to focus on possibilities rather than limitations, stating, 'The world’s got a whole face, and the world’s there to be looked at.'


By the end of the play, Derry gains confidence and decides to return to Mr. Lamb, symbolizing his newfound hope. This transformation highlights how Mr. Lamb's wisdom helps Derry overcome his fear of judgment and see life with renewed positivity.

Question 17:
Read the following extract from On the Face of It and answer the question that follows:

'You’re not afraid of me, are you?' Derry asks Mr. Lamb. 'Why should I be?' replies Mr. Lamb. 'Because of my face,' says Derry. 'What’s wrong with your face?' asks Mr. Lamb.

How does this dialogue highlight the central theme of the play?
Answer:

The dialogue between Derry and Mr. Lamb highlights the central theme of perception versus reality and the importance of looking beyond physical appearances. Derry, who is self-conscious about his burnt face, expects others to fear or reject him. However, Mr. Lamb, who has a prosthetic leg, responds with indifference, showing that he does not judge people based on their looks.

This interaction underscores the play's message that true acceptance comes from understanding and empathy, not superficial judgments. Mr. Lamb’s response challenges Derry’s belief that his face defines him, encouraging the audience to reflect on societal prejudices and the need for inner strength.

Question 18:
In On the Face of It, Mr. Lamb says, 'It’s all relative. Beauty and the beast.' Explain the significance of this statement in the context of the play.
Answer:

Mr. Lamb’s statement, 'It’s all relative. Beauty and the beast,' reflects the play’s exploration of subjectivity in perception. He implies that judgments about beauty and ugliness are not absolute but depend on individual perspectives. For instance, Derry sees himself as a 'beast' due to his scars, while Mr. Lamb sees beyond them.

This line reinforces the idea that societal standards of beauty are flawed and that true worth lies in one’s character. Mr. Lamb’s wisdom helps Derry realize that his self-worth should not be tied to his appearance, a crucial turning point in the play.

Question 19:
Read the following extract from On the Face of It and answer the question that follows:

"People are afraid of me because I look different. But inside, I am just like them."

How does this statement reflect the central theme of the chapter? Discuss with reference to the characters of Mr. Lamb and Derry.
Answer:

The statement highlights the central theme of appearance versus reality and the prejudice faced by individuals who look different. In On the Face of It, both Mr. Lamb and Derry suffer due to societal judgments based on their physical appearances.

  • Mr. Lamb, despite losing a leg, maintains a positive outlook and teaches Derry to look beyond superficial differences.
  • Derry, with a burnt face, initially isolates himself due to fear of rejection but learns from Mr. Lamb that inner strength matters more than outward appearance.

The chapter emphasizes that humanity and empathy should transcend physical flaws, a lesson Derry internalizes by the end.

Question 20:
In On the Face of It, Mr. Lamb says, "It’s all relative, beauty and ugliness." How does this philosophy help Derry overcome his insecurities? Provide examples from the text to support your answer.
Answer:

Mr. Lamb’s philosophy teaches Derry that perceptions of beauty and ugliness are subjective and not absolute. This realization helps Derry shift his focus from his scars to his inner worth.

  • Example 1: Mr. Lamb compares himself to a "weed" that some call unwanted, while others see its resilience—showing Derry that labels depend on perspective.
  • Example 2: Derry learns that his "face" doesn’t define him; his thoughts and actions do, as Mr. Lamb accepts him without judgment.

By embracing this mindset, Derry gains confidence to face the world, symbolizing his emotional growth.

Question 21:
Mr. Lamb tells Derry, 'The world's got a whole face, and the world's there to be looked at.' How does this statement reflect Mr. Lamb's philosophy of life? Support your answer with examples from the text.
Answer:

Mr. Lamb's statement reflects his optimistic and inclusive philosophy of life. He believes that the world is vast and full of opportunities, and one should not be limited by physical or emotional barriers. 'The world's got a whole face' suggests that beauty and goodness exist everywhere, even if they are not immediately visible.

For example, Mr. Lamb finds joy in simple things like watching the bees and listening to the wind, showing his ability to appreciate life despite his physical disability. He also encourages Derry to look beyond his scars and embrace life, emphasizing that the world is 'there to be looked at'—meaning it is open for exploration and acceptance.

This philosophy teaches us resilience and the importance of focusing on the positives rather than dwelling on limitations.

Question 22:
Derry's initial attitude towards life is pessimistic, but it changes after his interaction with Mr. Lamb. Analyze how Derry's perspective evolves and what factors contribute to this transformation.
Answer:

Derry's initial attitude is marked by self-loathing and fear due to his facial scars, making him withdraw from society. However, his interaction with Mr. Lamb acts as a turning point in his life.

  • Acceptance: Mr. Lamb does not pity Derry but treats him normally, helping him see that physical appearance does not define one's worth.
  • Inspiration: Mr. Lamb's own resilience despite losing a leg shows Derry that life can be meaningful despite hardships.
  • New Perspective: Derry begins to realize that the world is not as cruel as he thought, as Mr. Lamb's kindness and wisdom open his eyes to hope.

By the end, Derry decides to return to Mr. Lamb's garden, symbolizing his willingness to embrace life and overcome his fears. This transformation highlights the power of human connection and positive influence in changing one's outlook.

Chat on WhatsApp