Online Self Test
Learn & Practice Quizzes & Challenges Competitive Exams
 

A Triumph of Surgery – CBSE NCERT Study Resources

Previous ChapterNext Chapter
Previous Chapter Next Chapter
A Triumph of Surgery

Study Materials

10th

10th - English (Footprints Without Feet)

A Triumph of Surgery

Jump to Question Sets

Overview of the Chapter

The chapter "A Triumph of Surgery" is a heartwarming story from the book "Footprints Without Feet" for Class 10 students. It revolves around a pet dog named Tricki and his owner, Mrs. Pumphrey, who overfeeds him out of love, leading to health issues. The story highlights the consequences of excessive pampering and the importance of proper care, as demonstrated by the veterinary surgeon Mr. Herriot.

A Triumph of Surgery refers to the successful recovery of Tricki after Mr. Herriot intervenes and provides the necessary treatment and discipline, contrasting Mrs. Pumphrey's indulgent care.

Summary

The story begins with Mrs. Pumphrey, a wealthy and affectionate woman, who is deeply attached to her dog Tricki. She overfeeds him with unhealthy treats, causing him to become obese and lethargic. Concerned about Tricki's deteriorating health, she consults Mr. Herriot, a veterinary surgeon. Recognizing the problem, Mr. Herriot decides to hospitalize Tricki to put him on a strict diet and exercise regimen.

At the surgery, Tricki initially struggles but soon adapts to the disciplined routine. He plays with other dogs, eats balanced meals, and gradually regains his health and vitality. Mrs. Pumphrey, unaware of the simple solution, sends eggs, wine, and brandy to the hospital, believing they are essential for Tricki's recovery. Mr. Herriot humorously uses these gifts for himself and his colleagues.

After two weeks, Tricki transforms into a fit and active dog. Mrs. Pumphrey is overjoyed and credits Mr. Herriot's surgical skills for the miracle, calling it a "triumph of surgery." The story ends on a light-hearted note, emphasizing the importance of moderation and proper care over blind affection.

Key Themes

  • The consequences of overindulgence and lack of discipline.
  • The importance of responsible pet care.
  • The contrast between genuine care and misguided affection.

Characters

  • Mrs. Pumphrey: A wealthy and loving but overly indulgent owner of Tricki.
  • Tricki: A pampered dog who suffers due to his owner's excessive care.
  • Mr. Herriot: A practical and compassionate veterinary surgeon who helps Tricki recover.

All Question Types with Solutions – CBSE Exam Pattern

Explore a complete set of CBSE-style questions with detailed solutions, categorized by marks and question types. Ideal for exam preparation, revision and practice.

Very Short Answer (1 Mark) – with Solutions (CBSE Pattern)

These are 1-mark questions requiring direct, concise answers. Ideal for quick recall and concept clarity.

Question 1:
Who is the author of A Triumph of Surgery?
Answer:

James Herriot

Question 2:
What was the name of Mrs. Pumphrey's dog?
Answer:

Tricki

Question 3:
Why was Tricki overfed by Mrs. Pumphrey?
Answer:

Due to excessive love and pampering.

Question 4:
What problem did Tricki face due to overfeeding?
Answer:

He became obese and lazy.

Question 5:
Who helped Tricki recover from his condition?
Answer:

Mr. Herriot (the vet)

Question 6:
Where was Tricki treated for his health issues?
Answer:

At the veterinary hospital.

Question 7:
What diet was given to Tricki during recovery?
Answer:

Simple and controlled meals.

Question 8:
How did Tricki behave with other dogs at the hospital?
Answer:

He played and became active.

Question 9:
What lesson does the story teach about pet care?
Answer:

Proper diet and exercise are essential.

Question 10:
How did Mrs. Pumphrey react to Tricki's recovery?
Answer:

She was overjoyed and grateful.

Question 11:
What mistake did Mrs. Pumphrey make with Tricki?
Answer:

She overfed him with treats.

Question 12:
What change was seen in Tricki after treatment?
Answer:

He became healthy and energetic.

Question 13:
Why did Mr. Herriot decide to keep Tricki at the hospital?
Answer:

To ensure strict diet and exercise.

Question 14:
What emotion did Mrs. Pumphrey show when Tricki returned?
Answer:

She was emotional and relieved.

Question 15:
Who is the author of A Triumph of Surgery?
Answer:
The author of A Triumph of Surgery is James Herriot, a renowned veterinary surgeon and writer.
Question 16:
What was the name of the dog in A Triumph of Surgery?
Answer:
The dog's name in the story was Tricki, a pampered pet who faced health issues due to overfeeding.
Question 17:
Why was Tricki brought to the veterinary surgeon?
Answer:
Tricki was brought to the veterinary surgeon because he was overfed and lazy, leading to severe health problems like obesity and lethargy.
Question 18:
What was Mrs. Pumphrey's attitude towards Tricki?
Answer:
Mrs. Pumphrey was overindulgent and excessively caring, spoiling Tricki with unhealthy treats and lack of exercise.
Question 19:
How did the veterinary surgeon treat Tricki's condition?
Answer:
The vet treated Tricki by stopping his rich diet, providing exercise, and giving a balanced routine, which helped him recover.
Question 20:
What lesson does A Triumph of Surgery teach about pet care?
Answer:

The story teaches that proper diet and exercise are crucial for pets. Overindulgence can harm their health, while discipline ensures their well-being.

Question 21:
What was the initial reaction of other dogs to Tricki in the surgery?
Answer:
The other dogs were curious and friendly towards Tricki, helping him adapt to the new environment.
Question 22:
How did Tricki's behavior change after his recovery?
Answer:
After recovery, Tricki became active, playful, and energetic, showing no signs of his earlier laziness.
Question 23:
Why did Mrs. Pumphrey think Tricki needed medical treatment?
Answer:
Mrs. Pumphrey believed Tricki was seriously ill due to his lethargy and lack of appetite, unaware that overfeeding was the cause.
Question 24:
What role did discipline play in Tricki's recovery?
Answer:

Discipline in diet and exercise was key to Tricki's recovery. It helped him shed excess weight and regain his vitality.

Question 25:
How did the veterinary surgeon describe Tricki's condition initially?
Answer:
The vet described Tricki as bloated and unhealthy, suffering from overfeeding and lack of physical activity.
Question 26:
What was the 'triumph' referred to in the story's title?
Answer:
The triumph refers to the successful recovery of Tricki through proper care, highlighting the victory of sensible treatment over neglect.

Very Short Answer (2 Marks) – with Solutions (CBSE Pattern)

These 2-mark questions test key concepts in a brief format. Answers are expected to be accurate and slightly descriptive.

Question 1:
Why did Mrs. Pumphrey take Tricki to the vet?
Answer:

Mrs. Pumphrey took Tricki to the vet because he had become overweight and sluggish due to excessive pampering and overfeeding. She was worried about his deteriorating health.

Question 2:
What was the name of the veterinary surgeon in the story?
Answer:

The veterinary surgeon in the story was named Mr. Herriot.

Question 3:
How did Mr. Herriot describe Tricki's condition when he first saw him?
Answer:

Mr. Herriot described Tricki as a bloated sausage with a dull coat and listless eyes, indicating severe obesity and poor health.

Question 4:
What was the main reason for Tricki's poor health?
Answer:

The main reason for Tricki's poor health was overfeeding and lack of exercise due to Mrs. Pumphrey's excessive indulgence.

Question 5:
What diet plan did Mr. Herriot suggest for Tricki?
Answer:

Mr. Herriot suggested a strict diet with no rich foods, only plain meals and plenty of exercise to help Tricki lose weight.

Question 6:
Why did Mrs. Pumphrey send eggs, wine, and brandy to the surgery?
Answer:

Mrs. Pumphrey sent eggs, wine, and brandy because she believed Tricki needed these luxury items to recover, showing her inability to understand his actual condition.

Question 7:
How did Tricki behave when he first arrived at the surgery?
Answer:

When Tricki first arrived, he was lethargic, refused to eat, and showed no interest in his surroundings due to his poor health.

Question 8:
What change did Mr. Herriot observe in Tricki after a few days?
Answer:

After a few days, Mr. Herriot observed that Tricki became active, started playing with other dogs, and showed a healthy appetite.

Question 9:
Why did Mrs. Pumphrey think Tricki's recovery was a 'triumph of surgery'?
Answer:

Mrs. Pumphrey believed it was a triumph of surgery because she thought Mr. Herriot's medical skills cured Tricki, not realizing it was simply a result of a balanced diet and exercise.

Question 10:
What lesson does the story 'A Triumph of Surgery' convey?
Answer:

The story teaches that overindulgence can harm loved ones, and sometimes, tough love (like a strict routine) is necessary for their well-being.

Question 11:
How did the other dogs at the surgery help Tricki recover?
Answer:

The other dogs at the surgery motivated Tricki to play and stay active, which helped him regain his energy and lose weight naturally.

Short Answer (3 Marks) – with Solutions (CBSE Pattern)

These 3-mark questions require brief explanations and help assess understanding and application of concepts.

Question 1:
Why did Mrs. Pumphrey think that Tricki needed medical attention?
Answer:

Mrs. Pumphrey thought Tricki needed medical attention because he had become extremely lethargic and overweight due to excessive pampering.
She noticed symptoms like loss of appetite, vomiting, and unusual tiredness, which made her believe he was seriously ill.

Question 2:
How did the narrator, Mr. Herriot, initially react to Tricki's condition?
Answer:

Mr. Herriot observed Tricki's obesity and lack of energy and immediately understood it was due to overfeeding and lack of exercise.
He suggested a strict diet plan and controlled environment instead of medicines, knowing Tricki's issues were lifestyle-related.

Question 3:
What changes did Tricki undergo during his stay at the surgery?
Answer:

At the surgery, Tricki transformed due to:

  • Balanced diet – No rich foods, only healthy meals
  • Regular exercise – Played with other dogs
  • Discipline – No pampering, just structured care

He lost weight, regained energy, and became active again.

Question 4:
Why was Mrs. Pumphrey reluctant to follow Mr. Herriot's advice initially?
Answer:

Mrs. Pumphrey was emotionally attached to Tricki and couldn't bear to see him deprived of luxuries.
She believed her way of caring (treats, comforts) was best, not realizing it harmed Tricki's health.

Question 5:
How did the other dogs at the surgery influence Tricki's recovery?
Answer:

The other dogs played a key role by:

  • Encouraging activity – Tricki joined their games
  • Social interaction – He learned to compete for food
  • Natural behavior – Mimicking healthy habits

This peer influence sped up his recovery.

Question 6:
What lesson does 'A Triumph of Surgery' convey about pet care?
Answer:

The story teaches:

  • Overindulgence harms pets – Love ≠ excessive treats
  • Discipline is vital – Routine & exercise matter
  • Professional advice – Vets know best, not emotions

Responsible care ensures pets stay healthy.

Question 7:
How did the narrator, Mr. Herriot, initially react to Mrs. Pumphrey's concerns about Tricki?
Answer:

Mr. Herriot, being a practical veterinarian, immediately recognized that Tricki's condition was due to overfeeding and lack of exercise. He advised Mrs. Pumphrey to put Tricki on a strict diet and exercise regimen, but she was reluctant to follow his advice due to her emotional attachment.

Question 8:
Describe the changes in Tricki's behavior after he was admitted to the surgery.
Answer:

After being admitted to the surgery, Tricki initially appeared depressed and uninterested. However, as days passed, he began to show signs of improvement:

  • He started interacting with other dogs.
  • His appetite returned, and he ate healthy food.
  • He became more active and playful.
These changes indicated his recovery.

Question 9:
What role did the other dogs at the surgery play in Tricki's recovery?
Answer:

The other dogs at the surgery played a crucial role in Tricki's recovery. Their energetic behavior and active lifestyle motivated Tricki to participate in play and exercise. This social interaction helped him regain his health and vitality naturally.

Question 10:
How did Mrs. Pumphrey contribute to Tricki's poor health condition?
Answer:

Mrs. Pumphrey's overindulgence and excessive pampering were the main reasons for Tricki's poor health. She fed him rich foods like cream cakes and chocolates excessively, leading to obesity. Her emotional attachment prevented her from setting boundaries for Tricki's diet and exercise.

Question 11:
What lesson does the chapter 'A Triumph of Surgery' convey about pet care?
Answer:

The chapter teaches that responsible pet care involves:

  • Providing a balanced diet and regular exercise.
  • Avoiding overindulgence despite emotional attachment.
  • Seeking professional advice when needed.
Mr. Herriot's approach highlights the importance of discipline in maintaining a pet's health.

Long Answer (5 Marks) – with Solutions (CBSE Pattern)

These 5-mark questions are descriptive and require detailed, structured answers with proper explanation and examples.

Question 1:
How does Mrs. Pumphrey's overindulgence lead to Tricki's health issues in A Triumph of Surgery?
Answer:
Introduction

In A Triumph of Surgery, Mrs. Pumphrey's excessive care harms Tricki. Our textbook shows how overfeeding and pampering make him obese.


Argument 1
  • She feeds Tricki rich foods like cream cakes, causing weight gain.
  • Her lack of discipline worsens his laziness.

Argument 2
  • The vet, Dr. Herriot, intervenes to save Tricki.
  • Strict diet and exercise restore his health.

Conclusion

Mrs. Pumphrey’s love, though well-intentioned, becomes harmful. The story teaches us about responsible pet care.

Question 2:
Explain the role of Dr. Herriot as a compassionate vet in A Triumph of Surgery.
Answer:
Introduction

Dr. Herriot, the vet in A Triumph of Surgery, shows deep care for animals. We studied how he helps Tricki recover.


Argument 1
  • He diagnoses Tricki’s obesity and plans treatment.
  • His clinic provides a disciplined environment.

Argument 2
  • He resists Mrs. Pumphrey’s indulgence for Tricki’s good.
  • His methods prove effective as Tricki becomes active.

Conclusion

Dr. Herriot’s professionalism and kindness highlight responsible veterinary care.

Question 3:
Contrast Tricki’s lifestyle before and after his stay at the hospital in A Triumph of Surgery.
Answer:
Introduction

Tricki’s life changes drastically after hospitalization. Our textbook contrasts his pampered past with his healthy present.


Argument 1
  • Before: Overfed, lethargic, and obese due to Mrs. Pumphrey’s spoiling.
  • After: Active, playful, and fit due to Dr. Herriot’s care.

Argument 2
  • Before: No exercise, only luxury.
  • After: Balanced diet and outdoor activities.

Conclusion

The transformation shows the importance of discipline in pet care.

Question 4:
Why is A Triumph of Surgery an appropriate title for the story?
Answer:
Introduction

The title A Triumph of Surgery reflects Tricki’s recovery. We studied how medical intervention saves him.


Argument 1
  • Tricki’s health improves due to Dr. Herriot’s treatment.
  • Surgery here symbolizes disciplined care, not just an operation.

Argument 2
  • Mrs. Pumphrey’s emotional care fails, but science succeeds.
  • The ‘triumph’ is Tricki’s return to vitality.

Conclusion

The title emphasizes the victory of professional care over misguided love.

Question 5:
How does humor play a role in A Triumph of Surgery?
Answer:
Introduction

The story uses humor to highlight human flaws. Our textbook shows funny moments in Tricki’s treatment.


Argument 1
  • Mrs. Pumphrey’s exaggerated grief over Tricki’s diet is amusing.
  • Her constant calls to the vet add lightness.

Argument 2
  • Tricki’s greed for food and sudden energy shift are comical.
  • Dr. Herriot’s patience with Mrs. Pumphrey is humorous.

Conclusion

Humor makes the story engaging while conveying its moral.

Question 6:
Explain the significance of the title A Triumph of Surgery in the context of the story.
Answer:
Introduction

The title highlights Dr. Herriot's success in curing Tricki without surgery. Our textbook emphasizes his practical approach.


Argument 1
  • Tricki recovers through disciplined diet and exercise, not medical procedures.

Argument 2
  • The 'triumph' reflects Dr. Herriot's wisdom over Mrs. Pumphrey's pampering.

Conclusion

It underscores that simple solutions often work better than extreme measures.

Question 7:
Contrast Dr. Herriot's and Mrs. Pumphrey's approaches to Tricki's health.
Answer:
Introduction

Dr. Herriot and Mrs. Pumphrey represent opposite methods in caring for Tricki. Our textbook contrasts their actions clearly.


Argument 1
  • Mrs. Pumphrey spoils Tricki with treats, causing obesity.

Argument 2
  • Dr. Herriot prescribes a strict regimen, restoring his health.

Conclusion

The story teaches balance between love and discipline for pets.

Question 8:
How does the story A Triumph of Surgery depict the theme of responsibility?
Answer:
Introduction

The story explores responsibility through Tricki's care. Our textbook shows how actions have consequences.


Argument 1
  • Mrs. Pumphrey's irresponsibility leads to Tricki's illness.

Argument 2
  • Dr. Herriot's responsible approach saves Tricki.

Conclusion

It reminds us that true care requires wisdom, not just affection.

Question 9:
Describe the transformation of Tricki after his stay with Dr. Herriot.
Answer:
Introduction

Tricki undergoes a dramatic change under Dr. Herriot's care. Our textbook details his recovery journey.


Argument 1
  • He loses weight and becomes active again.

Argument 2
  • His energy returns, proving the success of the treatment.

Conclusion

This transformation highlights the importance of proper pet care.

Question 10:
How did Mrs. Pumphrey's overindulgence affect Tricki in A Triumph of Surgery?
Answer:
Introduction

Mrs. Pumphrey's excessive love for Tricki led to his poor health. Our textbook shows how her overfeeding made him obese.


Argument 1
  • She fed him unhealthy treats like cream cakes and chocolates.
  • This caused Tricki to become lazy and sick.

Argument 2

Her pampering prevented Tricki from exercising. The vet, Mr. Herriot, had to intervene to save him.


Conclusion

Her indulgence harmed Tricki, proving that excess love can be dangerous.

Question 11:
Describe the transformation of Tricki under Mr. Herriot's care.
Answer:
Introduction

Tricki's transformation under Mr. Herriot's care is a key lesson in the story. We studied how discipline improved his health.


Argument 1
  • Mr. Herriot put Tricki on a strict diet and exercise routine.
  • He avoided treats and played with other dogs.

Argument 2

Within days, Tricki became active and lost weight. Our textbook highlights this as a triumph of sensible care.


Conclusion

Tricki's recovery shows the importance of balanced care over pampering.

Question 12:
Why did Mr. Herriot call Tricki's recovery a triumph of surgery?
Answer:
Introduction

Mr. Herriot termed Tricki's recovery a 'triumph of surgery' metaphorically. Our textbook explains it as a victory of proper treatment.


Argument 1
  • No surgery was needed, just disciplined care.
  • His methods cured Tricki's obesity naturally.

Argument 2

It contrasted Mrs. Pumphrey's harmful pampering. The story teaches us about responsible pet care.


Conclusion

The phrase highlights the success of simple, effective solutions.

Question 13:
Compare Mrs. Pumphrey and Mr. Herriot's approaches to Tricki's health.
Answer:
Introduction

Mrs. Pumphrey and Mr. Herriot had opposite approaches to Tricki's health. Our textbook contrasts their methods.


Argument 1
  • Mrs. Pumphrey overfed Tricki, making him sick.
  • Mr. Herriot focused on diet and exercise.

Argument 2

Herriot's practical care healed Tricki, while Pumphrey's love harmed him. The story emphasizes balance.


Conclusion

The comparison teaches us about responsible pet ownership.

Question 14:
How does A Triumph of Surgery highlight the theme of responsible parenting?
Answer:
Introduction

The story mirrors parenting through Mrs. Pumphrey's actions. We studied how overprotection can backfire.


Argument 1
  • Her excessive care made Tricki unhealthy.
  • It shows the dangers of not setting boundaries.

Argument 2

Mr. Herriot's approach symbolizes balanced parenting. The NCERT lesson warns against spoiling children.


Conclusion

The story is a lesson on nurturing without overindulging.

Question 15:
What role does discipline play in Tricki's recovery in A Triumph of Surgery?
Answer:
Introduction

Discipline is central to Tricki's recovery. Our textbook shows how structure restored his health.


Argument 1
  • Mr. Herriot enforced a strict routine.
  • Tricki exercised and ate nutritious food.

Argument 2

This discipline countered Mrs. Pumphrey's chaos. The story proves that order leads to well-being.


Conclusion

Tricki's revival underscores the power of discipline.

Question 16:
Explain the irony in the title A Triumph of Surgery.
Answer:
Introduction

The title is ironic because no surgery occurred. We studied how it reflects Tricki's non-medical recovery.


Argument 1
  • Tricki healed through diet and exercise, not surgery.
  • The 'triumph' was Mr. Herriot's simple methods.

Argument 2

It contrasts Mrs. Pumphrey's assumption that Tricki needed major treatment. NCERT highlights this clever wordplay.


Conclusion

The irony emphasizes that solutions can be straightforward.

Question 17:
How does A Triumph of Surgery teach the value of professional advice?
Answer:
Introduction

The story stresses listening to experts like Mr. Herriot. Our textbook shows how his advice saved Tricki.


Argument 1
  • Mrs. Pumphrey ignored warnings about overfeeding.
  • Only Herriot's plan worked.

Argument 2

It teaches us to trust professionals over emotions. NCERT uses this to advocate for rational decisions.


Conclusion

Tricki's recovery proves expert guidance is invaluable.

Question 18:
Describe the emotional conflict in Mrs. Pumphrey during Tricki's treatment.
Answer:
Introduction

Mrs. Pumphrey faced emotional turmoil during Tricki's treatment. We studied her struggle between love and logic.


Argument 1
  • She worried about Tricki but resisted changing her habits.
  • Her guilt made her send unnecessary items like toys.

Argument 2

NCERT shows her eventual acceptance of Herriot's methods. This conflict mirrors real-life parenting dilemmas.


Conclusion

Her journey highlights the pain of necessary change.

Question 19:
How does A Triumph of Surgery use humor to convey its message?
Answer:
Introduction

The story blends humor with its moral. We studied how light moments make the lesson engaging.


Argument 1
  • Mrs. Pumphrey's dramatic reactions are funny yet insightful.
  • Herriot's calm demeanor contrasts her chaos.

Argument 2

NCERT uses humor to critique overindulgence without being preachy. The tone keeps readers entertained.


Conclusion

Humor makes the story’s warning more relatable.

Question 20:
How did Mrs. Pumphrey contribute to Tricki’s illness in A Triumph of Surgery?
Answer:
Introduction

Mrs. Pumphrey’s excessive love led to Tricki’s poor health. Our textbook shows her overfeeding and pampering the dog.


Argument 1
  • She fed Tricki unhealthy treats like cream cakes.
  • No exercise was allowed, making him obese.

Argument 2
  • She ignored vet advice, worsening Tricki’s condition.
  • Her emotional attachment blinded her judgment.

Conclusion

Her actions highlight how excessive care can harm. The story teaches balance in pet care.

Question 21:
Describe the transformation of Tricki under Mr. Herriot’s care.
Answer:
Introduction

Tricki’s recovery was a result of Mr. Herriot’s disciplined care. Our textbook highlights his methods.


Argument 1
  • He put Tricki on a strict diet and exercise routine.
  • No rich food was given, only healthy meals.

Argument 2
  • Tricki played with other dogs, becoming active.
  • His weight and energy levels improved drastically.

Conclusion

The transformation shows the importance of professional care over pampering.

Question 22:
Why did Mr. Herriot call Tricki’s recovery a ‘triumph of surgery’?
Answer:
Introduction

Mr. Herriot used the term metaphorically, as no surgery was performed. Our textbook explains his approach.


Argument 1
  • Tricki’s recovery was a result of disciplined care, not medicine.
  • His methods were as precise as a surgical procedure.

Argument 2
  • The term highlights the success of his unconventional treatment.
  • It contrasts with Mrs. Pumphrey’s ineffective pampering.

Conclusion

The phrase emphasizes the victory of proper care over indulgence.

Question 23:
Compare Mrs. Pumphrey’s and Mr. Herriot’s attitudes toward Tricki.
Answer:
Introduction

Mrs. Pumphrey and Mr. Herriot had contrasting approaches to Tricki’s care. Our textbook shows their differences.


Argument 1
  • Mrs. Pumphrey was emotional and overindulgent.
  • She ignored Tricki’s health for temporary happiness.

Argument 2
  • Mr. Herriot was practical and disciplined.
  • He prioritized Tricki’s long-term well-being.

Conclusion

The comparison teaches the importance of balanced care.

Question 24:
What lesson does A Triumph of Surgery teach about pet care?
Answer:
Introduction

The story teaches responsible pet care through Tricki’s journey. Our textbook emphasizes this message.


Argument 1
  • Overfeeding and lack of exercise harm pets.
  • Love should not replace proper care.

Argument 2
  • Professional advice is crucial for pet health.
  • Discipline and routine ensure well-being.

Conclusion

The lesson is clear: balance love with responsibility.

Question 25:
How did Tricki’s lifestyle change after returning from Mr. Herriot’s clinic?
Answer:
Introduction

Tricki’s lifestyle improved significantly post-recovery. Our textbook describes his new habits.


Argument 1
  • He became active, playing with other dogs.
  • His diet was regulated, avoiding rich foods.

Argument 2
  • Mrs. Pumphrey learned to limit treats.
  • Tricki’s health and energy levels stabilized.

Conclusion

The changes highlight the benefits of disciplined care.

Question 26:
Explain the humor in A Triumph of Surgery.
Answer:
Introduction

The story uses humor to highlight human folly. Our textbook shows amusing situations.


Argument 1
  • Mrs. Pumphrey’s exaggerated grief over Tricki is funny.
  • Her sending eggs and wine for Tricki adds comedy.

Argument 2
  • Tricki’s greediness and laziness are portrayed humorously.
  • Mr. Herriot’s sarcastic tone adds wit.

Conclusion

The humor makes the moral lesson engaging.

Question 27:
Why did Mrs. Pumphrey think Tricki needed surgery?
Answer:
Introduction

Mrs. Pumphrey misunderstood Tricki’s condition. Our textbook explains her confusion.


Argument 1
  • Tricki’s lethargy and obesity worried her.
  • She assumed only surgery could save him.

Argument 2
  • Her lack of pet care knowledge led to panic.
  • She trusted Mr. Herriot’s expertise blindly.

Conclusion

Her assumption reflects her ignorance about pet health.

Question 28:
Describe the role of discipline in Tricki’s recovery.
Answer:
Introduction

Discipline was key to Tricki’s recovery. Our textbook highlights Mr. Herriot’s methods.


Argument 1
  • Strict diet and exercise restored his health.
  • No indulgence was allowed, unlike at home.

Argument 2
  • Playing with other dogs built his stamina.
  • Routine check-ups ensured progress.

Conclusion

Discipline, not surgery, was the real cure.

Question 29:
How does A Triumph of Surgery showcase human folly?
Answer:
Introduction

The story critiques human mistakes through Mrs. Pumphrey. Our textbook illustrates this.


Argument 1
  • Her overfeeding shows misguided love.
  • Ignoring expert advice reflects stubbornness.

Argument 2
  • Her emotional drama highlights irrationality.
  • She learned only after Tricki suffered.

Conclusion

The story warns against such folly in pet care.

Question 30:
How did Mrs. Pumphrey's overindulgence lead to Tricki's poor health in A Triumph of Surgery? Explain with examples from the text.
Answer:

Mrs. Pumphrey's excessive pampering and lack of discipline directly caused Tricki's health issues. Her overindulgence is evident in multiple ways:

  • Overfeeding: She gave Tricki unhealthy treats like cream cakes, chocolates, and even brandy, leading to obesity and lethargy.
  • Lack of exercise: Tricki was carried everywhere and never walked, weakening his muscles.
  • Ignoring professional advice: Despite the vet's warnings, she continued spoiling Tricki, worsening his condition.

Her actions reflect how excessive love without responsibility can harm. The transformation after Tricki's stay at the hospital proves that discipline and proper care are essential for health.

Case-based Questions (4 Marks) – with Solutions (CBSE Pattern)

These 4-mark case-based questions assess analytical skills through real-life scenarios. Answers must be based on the case study provided.

Question 1:
In A Triumph of Surgery, Mrs. Pumphrey's overindulgence harms Tricki. Case Summary: Describe how her actions affected Tricki. Analysis: What lesson does this teach about pet care?
Answer:
Case Summary:

Mrs. Pumphrey overfed Tricki with treats like cream cakes and chocolates, making him obese and sick. Our textbook shows her excessive pampering led to his poor health.

Analysis:
  • Pets need balanced diets, not human junk food.
  • Vet advice (like Dr. Herriot's) should be followed strictly.
Conclusion:

Responsible pet care requires discipline, not just love.

Question 2:
Case Summary: How did Dr. Herriot's practical approach cure Tricki? Analysis: Compare his method with Mrs. Pumphrey's emotional care.
Answer:
Case Summary:

Dr. Herriot hospitalized Tricki, gave him no food initially, and made him play with dogs. Our textbook calls this a strict regimen.

Analysis:
  • Mrs. Pumphrey’s emotional care worsened Tricki’s health.
  • Dr. Herriot’s scientific method restored his fitness.
Conclusion:

Effective care combines love with professional guidance.

Question 3:
Case Summary: Why did Tricki’s greediness disappear at the surgery? Analysis: Relate this to the theme of discipline vs. spoiling.
Answer:
Case Summary:

At the surgery, Tricki had to compete for food with other dogs. Our textbook shows he became active and stopped overeating.

Analysis:
  • Discipline (structured meals) cured his greed.
  • Spoiling (unlimited treats) had made him lazy.
Conclusion:

Healthy habits develop in disciplined environments.

Question 4:
Case Summary: Explain the irony in Mrs. Pumphrey calling Tricki’s recovery a ‘triumph of surgery’. Analysis: What does this reveal about her understanding?
Answer:
Case Summary:

Mrs. Pumphrey credited surgery, but Tricki healed through exercise and diet. Our textbook highlights her misplaced gratitude.

Analysis:
  • She misunderstood the real cure (lifestyle change).
  • Shows lack of awareness about pet health.
Conclusion:

True care requires learning, not just luck.

Question 5:
Case Summary: How does the story show conflict between emotion and logic? Analysis: Give examples from Tricki’s treatment.
Answer:
Case Summary:

Mrs. Pumphrey’s emotional feeding conflicted with Dr. Herriot’s logical treatment. Our textbook contrasts her love with his science.

Analysis:
  • Example 1: Cream cakes vs. controlled diet.
  • Example 2: Coddling vs. outdoor play.
Conclusion:

Balance is key—love must align with health needs.

Question 6:
In A Triumph of Surgery, how does Mrs. Pumphrey's overindulgence affect Tricki? Analyze the consequences of her actions with examples from the text.
Answer:
Case Summary

Mrs. Pumphrey overfeeds Tricki, leading to obesity and lethargy. Our textbook shows her giving him cream cakes and chocolates.

Analysis
  • Tricki becomes lazy and unhealthy.
  • He stops playing and struggles to move.
Conclusion

The vet, Mr. Herriot, intervenes to save Tricki by putting him on a strict diet, proving overindulgence harms pets.

Question 7:
How does Mr. Herriot demonstrate professionalism in A Triumph of Surgery? Provide two examples of his actions.
Answer:
Case Summary

Mr. Herriot treats Tricki professionally despite Mrs. Pumphrey's emotional attachment.

Analysis
  • He diagnoses Tricki's obesity and prescribes a balanced diet.
  • He resists Mrs. Pumphrey's pleas for extra treats.
Conclusion

His professionalism saves Tricki, teaching us the importance of discipline in pet care.

Question 8:
Contrast the lifestyles of Tricki before and after his stay with Mr. Herriot. Use examples from the text.
Answer:
Case Summary

Tricki transforms from an unhealthy pet to an active dog.

Analysis
  • Before: Overfed, lazy, and sick (e.g., cream cakes).
  • After: Eats healthy food, plays with other dogs.
Conclusion

The story highlights how a disciplined lifestyle improves Tricki's health.

Question 9:
Why is the title A Triumph of Surgery ironic? Explain with reference to the story.
Answer:
Case Summary

No surgery occurs; Tricki recovers through diet and exercise.

Analysis
  • The 'triumph' is Mr. Herriot's simple treatment, not surgery.
  • Mrs. Pumphrey expects surgery, but discipline works.
Conclusion

The irony lies in the title exaggerating a simple solution as a surgical victory.

Question 10:
In A Triumph of Surgery, how did Mrs. Pumphrey's overindulgence affect Tricki? Analyze the consequences of her actions with examples from the text.
Answer:
Case Summary

Mrs. Pumphrey overfed Tricki, leading to obesity and health issues.

Analysis
  • Her excessive care made Tricki lazy and sick.
  • The vet, Herriot, had to intervene to save Tricki.
Conclusion

Our textbook shows how overindulgence harms pets, as seen in Tricki's case. Herriot's strict diet and exercise helped Tricki recover.

Question 11:
Compare the attitudes of Mrs. Pumphrey and the vet, Herriot, towards Tricki in A Triumph of Surgery. How did their approaches differ?
Answer:
Case Summary

Mrs. Pumphrey was emotional, while Herriot was practical.

Analysis
  • She pampered Tricki with treats, worsening his health.
  • Herriot focused on discipline and proper care.
Conclusion

We studied how Herriot's scientific approach saved Tricki, unlike Mrs. Pumphrey's emotional attachment. This shows the importance of balanced pet care.

Question 12:
Explain the transformation of Tricki after his stay at the vet's clinic in A Triumph of Surgery. What changes were observed?
Answer:
Case Summary

Tricki became healthy and active after treatment.

Analysis
  • He lost weight and regained energy.
  • His playful nature returned.
Conclusion

Our textbook highlights how proper diet and exercise, as Herriot provided, led to Tricki's transformation. This teaches us the value of disciplined care.

Question 13:
How does A Triumph of Surgery highlight the theme of responsibility in pet ownership? Support your answer with examples.
Answer:
Case Summary

The story shows the consequences of irresponsible pet care.

Analysis
  • Mrs. Pumphrey's neglect of Tricki's diet caused his illness.
  • Herriot's responsible actions saved Tricki.
Conclusion

We studied how the theme of responsibility is central. Herriot's care contrasts with Mrs. Pumphrey's carelessness, emphasizing proper pet ownership.

Question 14:

Read the following extract from A Triumph of Surgery and answer the question that follows:

"Mrs. Pumphrey was a rich and emotional woman who loved her dog Tricki excessively. She fed him cream cakes, chocolates, and other unhealthy treats, leading to his obesity."

Based on the extract, analyze how Mrs. Pumphrey's behavior reflects the theme of misguided love in the story. Provide examples from the text to support your answer.

Answer:

The theme of misguided love is evident in Mrs. Pumphrey's actions towards Tricki. Her excessive pampering, though stemming from affection, harms Tricki's health. For instance:

  • She feeds him cream cakes and chocolates, ignoring the consequences of an unhealthy diet.
  • She fails to recognize Tricki's obesity as a problem, believing her love justifies overfeeding.

This behavior highlights how love, when not balanced with responsibility, can lead to harm. The vet's intervention later shows the need for practical care over emotional indulgence.

Question 15:

In A Triumph of Surgery, the vet decides to hospitalize Tricki to improve his health. Imagine you are the vet and write a diary entry explaining your decision to take Tricki away from Mrs. Pumphrey. Include the challenges you faced and your hopes for Tricki's recovery.

Answer:

Diary Entry:

Date: [Today's Date]
Today, I made the tough decision to hospitalize Tricki. Mrs. Pumphrey's love for him is undeniable, but her overindulgence has made him severely obese. The challenges were:

  • Convincing Mrs. Pumphrey that her excessive pampering was harming Tricki.
  • Ensuring Tricki adapts to a disciplined routine away from luxury.

I hope that with a balanced diet and proper exercise, Tricki will regain his health. This case reminds me that sometimes, love requires tough choices for the greater good.

Question 16:
Read the following excerpt from A Triumph of Surgery:

'Mrs. Pumphrey was a rich and emotional woman who loved her dog Tricki excessively, feeding him unhealthy treats. When Tricki fell ill, she panicked and called the vet, Mr. Herriot.'

Based on this, analyze how overparenting can harm a child/pet, drawing parallels from the chapter.
Answer:

In A Triumph of Surgery, Mrs. Pumphrey's overparenting of Tricki through excessive pampering and unhealthy treats led to his severe illness. Similarly, overparenting can harm children/pets in multiple ways:

  • Physical Health: Overfeeding or lack of discipline can cause obesity or other health issues, as seen with Tricki.
  • Emotional Dependence: Excessive coddling prevents independence, making them unable to handle challenges.
  • Poor Decision-Making: Without boundaries, they may struggle with self-control.

The chapter highlights how Mr. Herriot's practical care (balanced diet and exercise) saved Tricki, emphasizing the need for a structured upbringing.

Question 17:
In A Triumph of Surgery, Mr. Herriot decides to hospitalize Tricki despite Mrs. Pumphrey's reluctance. Evaluate the ethical responsibility of a professional (like a vet/doctor) when their client's emotions clash with the well-being of their dependent.
Answer:

Mr. Herriot's decision to hospitalize Tricki showcases the ethical responsibility of professionals to prioritize the dependent's welfare over the client's emotions. Key takeaways:

  • Duty of Care: Professionals must act in the best interest of the patient, even if it means disagreeing with the guardian, as Mr. Herriot did.
  • Balanced Communication: He calmly explained Tricki's critical condition to Mrs. Pumphrey, showing empathy while standing firm.
  • Long-Term Impact: His intervention saved Tricki’s life, proving that ethical decisions often require courage.

The chapter teaches us that true care sometimes means making tough choices, a lesson applicable to doctors, teachers, and other professionals.

Question 18:
Read the following extract and answer the questions that follow:

'Mrs. Pumphrey was a rich and emotional woman who loved her dog Tricki excessively. She fed him cream cakes, chocolates, and other unhealthy treats, making him obese and lethargic.'

(a) Why did Mrs. Pumphrey's actions lead to Tricki's poor health?
(b) What lesson does this situation teach us about responsible pet ownership?
Answer:

(a) Mrs. Pumphrey's excessive pampering and overfeeding of Tricki with unhealthy treats like cream cakes and chocolates caused him to become obese and lethargic. Her emotional attachment blinded her to the health risks of such a diet, leading to Tricki's poor physical condition.


(b) This situation teaches us that responsible pet ownership involves:

  • Providing a balanced diet suited to the pet's needs
  • Avoiding overindulgence even out of love
  • Recognizing the health consequences of improper care
  • Seeking professional advice when needed, as Mr. Herriot did
Pets depend on owners for their well-being, so discipline and care must go hand in hand.

Question 19:
Based on the chapter A Triumph of Surgery, imagine you are Mr. Herriot. Write a diary entry expressing your thoughts on Tricki's recovery and Mrs. Pumphrey's behavior. Include key events and emotions.
Answer:

Dear Diary,

Today marked a significant victory in Tricki's health journey. When I first saw him, he was unhealthily overweight due to Mrs. Pumphrey's overindulgence. My approach was simple:

  • Strict diet control with no rich foods
  • Regular exercise with other dogs
  • Natural recovery in the surgery's environment

Seeing Tricki transform into an active, playful dog was deeply satisfying. Mrs. Pumphrey's emotional outbursts and constant worried calls showed her love, but also her lack of awareness. I hope she learns that true care sometimes means saying no. This experience reaffirmed my belief in practical veterinary science over pampering.

- Herriot

Question 20:
Read the following excerpt from A Triumph of Surgery:

'Mrs. Pumphrey was a rich and emotional woman who loved her dog Tricki excessively, feeding him unhealthy treats. When Tricki fell ill, the narrator, a veterinary surgeon, took charge of his treatment.'

Based on this, analyze how overindulgence can harm pets, citing examples from the story.
Answer:

In A Triumph of Surgery, Mrs. Pumphrey's overindulgence towards Tricki led to severe health issues. She fed him cream cakes, chocolates, and horlicks, causing obesity and lethargy. The narrator highlights how excessive love without discipline harms pets:

  • Tricki became listless and lost interest in activities due to overfeeding.
  • His digestive system was compromised, leading to vomiting and refusal to eat.

The story teaches that balanced care, not pampering, ensures a pet's well-being. The narrator's strict diet and exercise plan restored Tricki's health, proving moderation is key.

Question 21:
In A Triumph of Surgery, the narrator mentions,

'Dogs like Tricki need discipline more than luxury.'

Evaluate this statement by contrasting Mrs. Pumphrey's approach with the vet's treatment method.
Answer:

The statement emphasizes that discipline is crucial for a pet's health, as shown in the story:

  • Mrs. Pumphrey's luxury-focused approach: She prioritized Tricki's temporary happiness with unhealthy treats, ignoring long-term consequences.
  • The vet's disciplined method: He provided a strict diet, regular exercise, and no extra treats, ensuring Tricki's recovery.

The contrast proves that while luxury spoils pets, discipline builds their resilience. The vet's success highlights the importance of responsible pet care over emotional indulgence.

Question 22:
Read the following excerpt from A Triumph of Surgery:

'Mrs. Pumphrey was a rich and emotional woman who loved her dog Tricki excessively. She fed him cream cakes, chocolates, and other unhealthy treats, leading to his obesity and illness.'

Based on this, analyze how overparenting can harm a child/pet, drawing parallels from the story.
Answer:

In A Triumph of Surgery, Mrs. Pumphrey's overparenting of Tricki through excessive indulgence in unhealthy food led to his severe health issues. Similarly, overparenting in humans can cause harm in multiple ways:

  • Physical Health: Overfeeding or lack of discipline can lead to obesity and related diseases, just like Tricki's condition.
  • Emotional Dependency: Excessive pampering can make children/pets overly reliant on others, reducing their ability to handle challenges independently.
  • Lack of Resilience: Without facing minor struggles, they may struggle to adapt to real-world situations.

The story teaches us that love should be balanced with responsibility to ensure well-being.

Question 23:
In A Triumph of Surgery, the veterinarian Mr. Herriot takes strict measures to improve Tricki's health. Compare his approach with Mrs. Pumphrey's and explain why professional intervention was necessary.
Answer:

Mr. Herriot's professional intervention contrasts sharply with Mrs. Pumphrey's emotional care:

  • Discipline vs. Indulgence: While Mrs. Pumphrey gave Tricki unhealthy treats, Mr. Herriot enforced a strict diet and exercise routine.
  • Scientific Approach: He relied on veterinary knowledge to diagnose and treat Tricki's obesity, unlike Mrs. Pumphrey's misguided affection.
  • Result-Oriented: His methods restored Tricki's health, proving that expertise is crucial in critical situations.

The story highlights how professional guidance is essential when emotions cloud judgment, ensuring long-term well-being.

Chat on WhatsApp